“Rate of transmission of SARS Coronavirus Type 2 within affected communities may be faster”

0

Kolkata: It is almost a year since Covid-19 virus was first identified. However, once again the world is on red alert, this time because of new Covid-19 variant which has been detected in the U.K. The severity of the infection and its transmissibility is still being assessed, however scientists believe that it can be more infectious. Dr. Sanjay Bhattacharya, Consultant Microbiology, Tata Medical Center, Kolkata helps eNewsroom track the virus movement across the world, at the same time, he sheds light on the efficacy of the new vaccine being rolled out and its impact in India.

eNewsroom: So far there are more than 240 mutations found in India. How concerned we should be about the new variant?

Dr. Sanjay: New strains or new variants of SARS Coronavirus Type 2 have emerged in different parts of the world. They were first reported from the United Kingdom and then subsequently from South Africa and Brazil. These strains are genetic variants of the SARS CoV-2 virus which evolves as a result of various selection pressures. Variation in genetic composition of microbes over time as a result of evolutionary pressures are not uncommon and are seen in most microbes associated with various infectious diseases (examples include Influenza virus, HIV among others). It has been observed by researchers that these variants have a greater propensity to spread from person and person; hence the rate of transmission within affected communities may be faster. In India, research and reference laboratories approved by the government have developed tests to detect these variants. These tests are complex and expensive and cannot be done in any lab doing Covid -19 sample testing. Variants detected within India are generally from travellers coming from countries affected by the variant strains. We need to be careful and do the standard things recommended by the government in all situations. 

eNewsroom: What according to you will be the efficacy of the new vaccines being rolled out in the market, will it still remain as effective? 

Dr. Sanjay: The efficacy of the Covid vaccine against the variant strains is a subject of ongoing clinical research. For assessment of vaccine efficacy longitudinal studies over weeks, months and sometimes years have to be done. As vaccination against Covid-19 becomes more common we will learn in the due course the relative efficacy of various vaccines against common and variant strains. 

eNewsroom: Should there be any additional measure to protect oneself from the new strain in Kolkata? 

Dr. Sanjay: Caution is required while travelling, especially travelling abroad to countries affected by the new variant strains. Quarantine and testing are required post arrival from the affected countries. We should also follow whatever the health authorities in our respective areas advise. This may imply certain travel restrictions, use of standard precautions, testing of symptomatic and contacts. 

 eNewsroom: What is the implication of the virus in India? 

 Dr. Sanjay: India has done well in controlling the virus through elaborate testing, travel restrictions, and other Covid-19 related health and social measures. We need to follow guidelines provided by the government. Only time can tell what would-be long-term implications of the new variant strain within India. 

Multiple factors affect infection related outcomes- virus factor is one of them but there are also host factors (mainly related to the optimal response of the human body’s immune response to the virus. Besides timelines of diagnosis and medical interventions make a lot of difference. The public should strictly follow government’s health advisories, standard precautions including use of mask, hand hygiene and social distancing as far as possible); get tested if symptomatic. Covid-19 is a global infectious disease which is testing our society’s preparedness with respect to healthcare and adherence to guidelines. 

 

Will BJP’s electoral promises in Bengal turn out to be another ‘jumla’?

0

New Delhi: Amid chants of “Jai Shri Ram”, union home minister Amit Shah flagged off Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) fifth and final rath yatra on Thursday, in South-24 Parganas district for the upcoming assembly polls in West Bengal.

“With these Parivartan Yatras (rallies for change) we will reach every door in Bengal with the Jai Shri Ram slogan,” said Shah while terming BJP’s political slogan as “symbol” of alleged “anti-appeasement politics” of Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee.

While addressing a public gathering, among other announcements, Shah also promised to provide 33% reservation to women in government jobs in the state if people of Bengal bring BJP in power.

Just a week ago during his first visit when Shah had started first “Parivartan Yatra” from Cooch Behar, he made two other lucrative promises — credit of Rs 18,000 in each farmer’s account and citizenship to the Matua community through the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).

At the beginning of February, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman while presenting the central government’s Budget 2021, allocated Rs 25,000 crore for infrastructure in Bengal. Railway minister Piyush Goyal also allocated Rs 6,636 crore for rail projects in the state. Besides Bengal, BJP has also announced multi-crore allocations for infrastructure development in three other poll-bound states — Assam, Tamil Nadu and Kerala. The Trinamool Congress (TMC) government in West Bengal has also proposed an outlay of Rs 29,96,88 crore in its state Budget 2021-22.

All recent budgetary allocations and promises made by the saffron party are part of its strategy to defeat the Trinamool government led by chief minister Mamata Banerjee. But, despite all this, there is a tough fight for BJP which has been dreaming to overthrow the Mamata Banerjee government since 2014, when it came to power at the centre.

bjp electoral promises west bengal jumla election caa citizenship matuas jobs women reservation
Screenshot of BJP’s 2014 Lok Sabha Election manifesto

‘Jumla’ politics

Political scientist Prof. Dwaipayan Bhattacharya at Jawaharlal Nehru University, while speaking to eNewsroom said that budgetary allocation would not decide electoral verdict for either the BJP or the TMC but “how such allocation is played out in public domain” and “a lot will depend, [on] which party will sound more convincing” to the voters.

Prof. Bhattacharya maintained, “While a section of Bengal’s electorate wants alignment with those in power at the Centre, a good number also prefers federal autonomy for the state. The TMC’s insider-outsider rhetoric is meant mainly to appeal the latter.”

In the 2016 state elections, BJP could win only three out of 294 assembly seats. But it got 18 seats out of 42 in the Lok Sabha election (2019) which enhanced its hope.

Kavita Krishnan, a politburo member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) — Liberation (CPI(ML)-Liberation) doubted the impact of Union Budget allocations to Bengal and Amit Shah’s promises.

“BJP can’t use the centre’s funds as a bribe for political gain in the assembly election. BJP has already made much mistrust. They don’t know Bengal politics and its society. Amit Shah has made vague promises. There is unease for BJP in Bengal,” Krishnan said while recalling Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s promise to deliver Rs 15 lakh to each citizen’s bank account during the 2014 general elections which was later termed as a ‘jumla’ by the then BJP president Amit Shah in a TV interview.

BJP’s vague electoral promises

During the 2015 Bihar elections, PM Modi had himself promised a Rs 1.25-crore special package for Bihar while campaigning but it was not delivered after BJP lost the election as revealed in an RTI reply filed by RTI activist Anil Galgali to the Union finance ministry in December 2016.

During the 2020 assembly polls in Bihar, BJP faced severe criticism for announcing “free coronavirus vaccination for all” if the party came to power.

In May 2020, BJP had announced Rs 20 lakh crore as special economic relief during the Covid-19 pandemic to uplift India from the economic slowdown and make it self-reliant (Atmanirbhar Bharat). But, since then there is no official report that can suggest how much money the central government spent in various states.

In 2014, BJP had promised in its manifesto that it would bring 33 percent reservation for women in the parliament, which was never even discussed in the house in these years.

Promise for the creation one crore jobs for the youth was made by none other than Modi himself in 2013, as PM candidate but it has become a dream for the youths of India. Instead of new job creation, the decision of demonetization and lockdown, crores of Indians have lost jobs in the recent past.

Party had also promised to implement the Swaminathan Commission’s recommendations, doubling farmers’ income and assurance of higher Minimum Support Price (MSP) for productivity. But later on in June 2018, PM Modi announced a plan to double farmers’ income by 2022.

Contrary to its promises, BJP brought three new farm laws last year without consultation with farmers’ groups. Consequently, thousands of farmers have been agitating against the laws at Delhi’s borders since November 2020.

 CAA and Matuas

It is clear that with just lofty financial announcements, BJP cannot dent into the bastion of TMC. Hence, it has come up with its trump card, the CAA and other possible Hindutva politics tools. BJP has been promising citizenship for Bangla-speaking Hindus in Assam and Bengal from Bangladesh, claiming that Muslims from the neighbouring country are regularly infiltrating. But in Bengal, it seems scared to talk about the National Register of Citizenship (NRC). Due to delaying over formulating rules by the central government, TMC sees CAA implementation as a sham.

Both BJP and TMC have an eye on the Matua community as it shares a good proportion of population in the state. But Shah’s promise to grant them citizenship after winning the election, when the Covid-19 vaccination process is completed, is questionable.

Kavita Krishnan said that BJP was using CAA as a bargaining tool during election time. “BJP is transparently dishonest. Despite one year after bringing CAA, why didn’t they grant them citizenship? Citizenship is granted by the central government, not by the state government. So why are they promising it in a state election?” asked Krishnan. She added that the BJP government which is in power at the Centre for about seven years should seek votes based on its performance.

Prof. Bhattacharya pointed out, “Sections of Matuas don’t want CAA-NRC since the twin laws demand that they prove their citizenship afresh with documents while many had always claimed legitimate citizenship. To claim that they are persecuted refugees without adequate papers would invalidate their previous claims.”

How a wheel-chair bound patient’s indomitable spirit created Shaheen Bagh like anti-CAA protest in Kolkata

Kolkata: If anti-Citizenship Amendment Act protest at Shaheen Bagh gave Dadi (Bilkis Bano) to the world, Park Circus Maidan site at Kolkata gave Asmat Aapa. The anti-CAA activist Asmat Jamil was backbone of Park Circus sit-in protest.

Nostalgia, pain and grief were rife at the Park Circus Maidan, when fellow activists assembled to pay their last homage to their beloved Asmat Jamil, fondly addressed as Asmat baji. It was the same spot, where she with a handful of homemakers began a sit-in demonstration on January 7, 2020.

Her dedication, perseverance and never say die attitude propelled the wheelchair-bound, ailing lady into a mass leader.

Asmat, an advanced stage cancer patient, who frequently had to undergo dialysis led the anti-CAA movement from the forefront. She was seen busy motivating, coordinating or planning strategies with people who became part of the movement at the dharnasthal.

Thanks to her and many other women who joined the movement at her call, Park Circus Maidan not only emerged as major protest site till Covid-19 forced the activists to go back to the confines of their home. The zeal and enthusiasm of Asmat and her fellow activists made well-known anti-CAA faces including Shaheen Bagh’s Bilkis Bano alias Dadi, Tushar Gandhi, Rajratna Ambedkar visit the dharnasthal.

While speaking to eNewsroom, when the movement was at its peak, Asmat had said, “I might be physically unwell, but I understand the health risk involved but that is not going to stop me from coming here. I will not let the politicians with ulterior motives shred the unity and secular fabric of India.”

Listen to Asmat Jamil during her anti-CAA protest at Park Circus Maidan:

And it was this attitude of hers that made Asmat popular among the activists.

“Asmat Baji was a simple homemaker,” recalled Ratnabali Roy, a theatre artist, who was a regular face at the Park Circus dharnasthal. “She was unwell, battling cancer and a kidney ailment, but that didn’t stop her from leading the movement. She inspired us,” Roy reminisced. She maintained that the love for the Constitution that Asmat bore was comparable to her love for the three children that she has left behind.

Debu Shaw, a regular night guard at the dharnasthal, broke into tears, as he remembered his Asmat Baji. He pointed out, “I hold these anti-human laws responsible for her death. She was so worried about the democratic fabric of India being shredded to bits by CAA and NRC that she never cared about her health. She was so dedicated to the cause that she was here always, leading the movement from the forefront.”

Meanwhile, fellow activist, Manzar Jameel, remembered her as the face of the movement, who even in her death has left many inspired. He mentioned, “We are here to bid the final farewell to the lady who became the symbol of vigil against the citizenship regime.”

Adding to that Rafay Siddiqui, another activist from Kolkata said, “She was a role model. Sadly, we have lost her. But even in her death, she has left thousands of Asmat Jamils, who will be back on the streets if needed.” He recalled how Asmat had to rush to Mumbai’s Tata Memorial Centre for treatment when the movement was at its peak. “But that visit didn’t deter her from coming to the dharnasthal.”

Wali Rahmani, a youth icon, who also protested against CAA with Asmat added, “Despite being fragile health-wise, this iron lady kept fighting against the fascist government for the rights of the citizens. History shall indebted to her sacrifices.”

क्यों अर्थव्यवस्था के मामले में भारत बांग्लादेश से नीचे 161 वें पायदान पर है?

0

क्या तेज़ गति से बढ़ती अर्थव्यवस्था के हिसाब से भारत का स्थान दुनिया में 164 है? दुनिया के 193 देशों में से हम 164 वें नंबर पर हैं? प्रोफेसर कौशिक बसु के ट्वीट से यही जानकारी मिलती है। प्रो बसु विश्व बैंक के पूर्व मुख्य अर्थशास्त्री और अमरीका की कॉरनेल यूनिवर्सिटी के प्रोफेसर हैं। प्रोफेसर बसु ने लिखा है कि 5 साल पहले भारत अग्रिम कतार के देशों में था। आज 164 वें नंबर पर है।

प्रोफेसर बसु ने statisticstimes.com का लिंक दिया है। इस साइट पर सबसे पहले यही लिखा है कि आंकड़े अंतर्राष्ट्रीय मुद्रा कोष (IMF) से लिए गए हैं। 2020 में किस देश की कितनी जीडीपी रहेगी उसका अनुमान लगाया गया है। दुनिया के सिर्फ तीन देश हैं जिनकी जीडीपी 3 प्रतिशत से ऊपर रहेगी उनमें से एक भारत का पड़ोसी बांग्लादेश है। बांग्लादेश से ऊपर गुयाना और दक्षिण सुडान हैं। इसके अनुसार दुनिया की 193 में से 167 अर्थव्यवस्थाएं माइनस में रहेंगी। निगेटिव। सोचिए दुनिया की 79 प्रतिशत अर्थव्यवस्था निगेटिव में हैं। केवल 26 अर्थव्यवस्थाएं 2020 में सकारात्मक विकास दर हासिल करेंगी। जिनमें से 12 एशिया और अफ्रीका में हैं। सभी यूरोपीय और अमरीकी अर्थव्यवस्था का विस्तार रूक जाएगा।

चौपट अर्थव्यवस्था के दौर में भारतीय जनता ने महंगाई को जिस तरह गले लगाया है वह अद्भुत है। हर बढ़ती हुई कीमत जनता को स्वीकार है। जनता ने महंगाई को लेकर सरकार को मनोवैज्ञानिक दबाव से मुक्त कर दिया है। लोग ख़ुशी ख़ुशी 98-100 रुपये लीटर पेट्रोल ख़रीद रहे हैं बिज़नेस मंदा है। सैलरी कम है। कमाई कम है। नौकरी नहीं है। इसके बाद जिस तरह से जनता झूम कर एक लीटर पेट्रोल के लिए 98-100 रुपये दे रही है वह अद्भुत है। तेल कंपनियां चाहें तो मौके का फायदा उठाकर 200 तक कर सकती हैं। जनता वह भी ख़ुशी ख़ुशी दे देगी। वह विपक्ष के मुंह पर ज़ोरदार तमाचा मारने का कोई मौक़ा नहीं गंवाना चाहती है।

विपक्ष सर धुन रहा है कि जनता ही विरोध नहीं कर रही है तो वह कहां पोस्टर बैनर लेकर धरना देने जाए और जाने से भी कोई दिखाएगा नहीं, कोई छापेगा नहीं। गोदी मीडिया ने भी महंगाई नाम के मुद्दे की मौत का एलान कर दिया है। महंगाई और रोज़गार इन दो मुद्दों से भारत मुक्त हो चुका है। नौकरी की मांग करने वाले बेरोज़गारों को एक मिनट में काबू किया जा सकता है। तुरंत धर्म के ख़तरे से संबंधित कोई मीम भेज कर या उसकी रक्षा करने से संबंधित बयान देकर। इन चीज़ों से भारत के युवाओं को जितनी मनोवैज्ञानिक सुरक्षा मिलती है उतनी किसी चीज़ से नहीं। नौकरी नहीं चाहिए।उन्हें दो चीज़ चाहिए। एक धर्म से नफ़रत। एक धर्म पर गौरव। मेरी राय में यह दोनों ही चीज़ें प्रचुर मात्रा में सबको दी जा रही हैं।

हम एक ऐतिहासिक दौर से गुज़र रहे हैं। जनता महंगाई और बेरोज़गारी से परेशान नहीं है। जो सरकारी कंपनियां बिक रही हैं वहां इस फैसले का विरोध करने वाले इस बात से कम दुखी हैं कि सरकार बेच रही है, इस बात से ज़्यादा दुखी है कि भक्त लोग सरकार के फैसले के साथ हैं। इन कंपनियों के कर्मचारी ही कहते हैं कि अभी भी बहुत लोग हैं जो कहते हैं कि मोदी जी जो कर रहे हैं वो सोच समझ ही कर रहे हैं। सही बात है। सोच समझकर करने से ही तो अर्थव्यवस्था की ये हालत है। कि अभी हम डूबे हैं। उस पर ताला बंद नहीं हुआ है। इसके लिए तारीफ़ तो होनी ही चाहिए।

Modi govt should answer, does it believe in freedom of expression or not —Paranjoy Guha Thakurta

0

Kolkata: Senior journalist and author, Paranjoy Guha Thakurta is in Kolkata to release the Bangla version of his co-authored book Real Face of Facebook in India. The timing of the launch of the book becomes significant as Bengal’s important election is round the corner. The 65- year-old journalist is facing several cases from the corporate world for his investigative work, talked at length about his book, assault on journalists during the present regime, and how suppression of freedom of expression is ruining the image of India. Excerpts from the interview:

eNewsroom: You wrote a book on Facebook, can you elucidate this social media giant’s use and misuse during elections in India?

Paranjoy: First of all, when you talk about Facebook, it is not just Facebook but also WhatsApp and Instagram too. Today, not just in India, but also in other parts of the world, Facebook and WhatsApp are being misused. They are being used to spread misinformation, disinformation, and hateful information. The agenda is simple – increase enmity and violence between two communities. And before elections, it aims to simply influence people’s opinions. Those who have the money can hire trolls. They are paid to spread wrong information.

We are seeing that in the last few years, Facebook posts and WhatsApp messages behind every riot in India.

modi govt freedom of expression press facebook right wings Bengal election paranjoy guha thakurta

We have seen a senior Facebook officer Ankhi Das (Facebook India policy head) resigning. She had refused to put down the hateful messages of T Raja Singh (MLA from Telangana), Kapil Mishra (ex-MLA), and Anant Kumar Hegde (former Union Minister). She had even said that it is against “our business”. It is not me, who is saying, but what the Wall Street Journal, Reuters, Time, BuzzFeed is writing on Facebook.

In America and Austria, Members of Parliament and intellectuals are saying, Facebook has become so powerful that it should be brought under control. In America, the discussion is even going on that it (FB, WA, Insta) should be segregated. Here in India, we are seeing it being misused during the election.

I also find that Facebook and WhatsApp are being misused by right-wing groups. And the same is happening globally, not just in West Bengal or India.

Watch Paranjoy Guha Thakurta’s live interview: 

https://www.facebook.com/enewsroom.in/videos/184485406543958

eNewsroom: What is the solution? How to tackle the situation?

There is no easy solution to this. As Jawahar Sircar suggested today – ‘occupy Facebook, occupy WhatsApp’ can be one of the solutions. At the same time, we need to make the common man aware of social media being a two-edged sword, it can help you and harm you too. If you want to fight against those who are harming you, raising awareness is a must. If people believe whatever comes to WhatsApp, then the fight will get more difficult. As Ravish Kumar said, people are getting educated through WhatsApp University.

Unfortunately, crores of youth believe in whatever is forwarded to their WhatsApp inbox.

eNewsroom: Assault on journalists has been on the rise in India, especially during farmers’ protests.

As we are talking, right now, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) raid is on at the house of Prabir Purkayustha (NewsClick’s director). I think the government is misusing the agencies. Why do people who speak against PM Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah, Bhagwat, BJP, and RSS are being called anti-national? I love my country. I am a proud Indian.

Why do senior journalists like Mrinal Pande, Zafar Agha, Rajdeep (Sardesai), Vinod K Jose have to face sedition charges? And cases registered from one state to another. Kerala journalist (Kappan Siddiqui) has been slapped with sedition charges for reporting about the Hathras rape case. Why Mandeep (Punia) has to face FIR for reporting. How you are behaving against journalists, what it means. Do you believe in every citizen’s basic rights or not?

I do not say that you defame somebody or say something which triggers a riot. But I have a question to all those in power today, they should answer – do they believe in freedom of expression or not?

eNewsroom: Do you think this is ruining India’s global image?

Paranjoy: Today India’s reputation before is not good. Rihanna (pop singer) tweets and look, what the Indian government does! External Affairs ministry issues statement. Twitter has said, “we are not ready to obey your instruction”. I think it is foolish. The image of India, as the world’s largest democracy, is not getting bright, on the contrary, the BJP government and its supporters are ruining it.

Caligula cries: PM Modi’s tearful farewell to Ghulam Nabi Azad

0

Even Caligula cried. 

Images of the third Roman emperor popped up in my mind when I watched our prime minister crying on the floor of Rajya Sabha when he bid farewell to Gulam Nabi Azad, the veteran Congress leader from former Jammu &Kashmir state. Choked with emotion, he was unable to speak for a few minutes even after taking two sips from his glass of water as the house fell silent across the aisle.

As tears welled out of his eyes beneath the specs, Narendra Damodardas Modi really resembled the age-old image of our Hindu saints with his flowing white beards and silver crown. He wiped his eyes and tried to complete his tribute to Azad but choked again only to end it with a gesture of military salute to the opposition leader.

The memory game

The memory that made Modi tearful was related to one of the terrorist attacks in Kashmir valley on Indian tourists. The 2006 incident that killed a dozen and left many injured involved Gujaratis from Modi’s home state. Back then Modi was Gujarat’s chief minister while Azad was his counterpart in J & K. Modi recalled how Azad not only took the initiative to send back the dead and injured back to their home but also cried sharing their pain and shock.

Azad is a ‘good Muslim’ who takes ‘pride into being a Hindustani Muslim’ and is soulful in his appreciation of Indian democracy. He regretted the forced exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from the valley, wished end of militancy and terrorism and urged majority Hindus to come two steps forward to make Indian Muslims including their Kashmiri counterparts.

These well-meaning nationalist sentiments from an Opposition leader of Kashmir must have warmed the heart of Modi. His Man Friday, Amit Shah who wears the hat of the country’s home minister too, also became soft-eyed. The mellowed mood of the top duo, both Gujarati, over Azad’s expressed bonhomie with people of their home state and the Union was politically significant too.

The teary politics over Kashmir

Though he has little following in the valley, Azad’s words will help the ruling duo to sidetrack the mild criticism of Congress and other mainstream opposition over the de facto abrogation of article 370 of Indian constitution that had guaranteed special status of J&K and abolition of its statehood last August. Azad himself later pointed out that the abolition of the state and its legislature that denied him the chance to get back to the upper house.

Nevertheless, it was a moving scene of personal as well as bipartisan camaraderie in the Indian Parliament, that had witnessed the  bwidening gulf between the government and opposition only the day before. The poignant moment temporarily bridged the gulf when Modi and his minions are labelling all opposition and civil society dissenters as ‘anti-nationals’. It was also reassuring for the survival of the largest democracy in the era of Trump and America’s Capitol Hill moments, the oldest democracy.

Caligula is dead. Long live Caligula.

Still, Caligula continued to haunt me. Most historians remember the young Roman emperor as an energetic, fanciful and ambitious as well as a self-obsessed, sadistically cruel and cunning man, almost insane. He expanded the empire, initially tolerated countervailing senators, and made some populist moves on imperial transparency. But later he turned himself into a living god and insisted on his ‘worshipping’ both by the powerful senators and common subjects.

‘One Lord One King’ was his motto.

He threw commoners to wild beasts in Roman arena when there were no prisoners to feed the hungry lions and tigers or when he was simply bored. He killed or forced potential competitors and conspirators to commit suicide or flee on the basis of mere whims or suspicions. He engaged himself into many excesses including the construction of spectacular palaces and monuments dedicated to his glory, all at the expense of public funds when hunger plagued the realm.

Nevertheless, Caligula too cried on some occasions, particularly, after the murder of his younger sister before his own assassination.

Caligulas of our age   

Our Mota bhai is not young as Julias Caesar. But like many modern dictators that we have witnessed, he too shares Caligula’s traits, which includes his public display of emotions in, especially when our pain is personal. Unfortunately, personal is political too.

True, every Gujarati can’t be a Gandhi as every Bengali can’t be a Rabindranath in their sharing of the universal human pains, or closer home, sorrow of all Indians across the fault line of faiths and languages. So Modi did not feel like crying when another orgy communal violence killed Gujaratis, both Hindus and Muslims, the latter more in number under his watch in 2002. Let us correct ourselves. Did he not feel sorry for the ‘mongrel puppies who came under his wheels accidentally’ later?

He may not have cried when thousands of Kashmir’s civilians; women, children and teenagers had become collateral damage of anti-terror military and para-military encounters for decades. Still, his eyes were moist for the Pundit diaspora during his heady show of strength in the Trump land.

After his rise on the Raisina hills, Modi’s eyes did not well up or his voice quiver when some people collapsed in the serpentine queues in front of ATMs and Banks during Notebandi (demonetization). Neither he nor Shah wasted their precious drops of tears for the millions of migrant laborers and their hapless families who trudged for hundreds of kilometers along the national highway during the ‘talabandi’ (Lockdown). Nor did they feel the excruciating pain when the Kathua or Hathras girls were killed after being gang raped.

So, why complain if Modi does not feel the pains of 200 odd families of farmers who died of cold and other afflictions on roads under the freezing sky during the agitation against pro-corporate farm laws? Rest assured, our Caligula will cry again, maybe in 2024.

Kolkata-based digital media organizations express grave concern on ED raids at NewsClick, issue statement

0

Kolkata: We the undersigned strongly condemn the harassment and intimidation of independent media houses and journalists associated with them by the Bharatiya Janata Party run central government. The raids by the Enforcement Directorate at the office of NewsClick and the homes of its directors and editor Prabir Purkayastha is not an isolated stray incident, but part of the BJP government’s ongoing witch hunt of media houses, journalists and activists, who refuse to toe its line. NewsClick has been intensely reporting the ongoing farmers’ agitation and the raids are clearly meant to intimidate it and a sort of warning signal to other online portals who dare to speak truth to power.

We consider the raids as a clear attempt to suppress journalism critical of the government and its policies. We call upon all media houses, journalists, activists to condemn such use of state agencies to intimidate journalists, and actively oppose silencing of free and independent media by the central government.

We demand that the government immediately stop the ED’s action against NewsClick and explain why it was raided to begin with. We demand immediate release of all journalists arrested on charges of sedition and under the anti-terrorist UAPA.

The government of India does not maintain any annual press freedom index but contests the global one prepared by Paris-based Reporters Sans Frontiers. The latter found that India had slipped down to 142 in 2020 from 138 three years back in the global ranking of 180 countries. The quasi-judicial Press Council of India also fails to provide any annual or decadal data base on attacks and arrests of media persons.

However, an independent study on attacks on journalists in India in the last five years has revealed that there have been more than 200 serious attacks on journalists in the country in the period between 2014 and 2019. According to the study by article-14.com titled Getting Away with Murder, “There were 40 killings of journalists between 2014-19. Of these, 21 have been confirmed as related to their journalism.”

Another report prepared by the Rights and Risks Analysis Group (RRAG) that at least 55 journalists faced arrest, registration of FIRs, summons or show cause notices, physical assaults, alleged destruction of properties and threats for reportage on Covid-19 or exercising freedom of opinion and expression during the national lockdown from March 25 to May 31, 2020.

In this scenario, we call upon all media organizations, particularly the digital news and views platforms to record and collate attacks on independent, citizen journalists too.

frontierweekly.com
guruchandali.com
edeshaamar.com
sohomon.com
4numberplatform.com
groundxero.in
fishields.com/
thebackgroundd.in
aramva.co.in
dalitcamera.com
Amra Monbhashi

IAMC rubbishes ‘cheap’ attacks by Middle East Forum

0

Washington DC: The Indian American Muslim Council has responded to a ludicrous attack from the Middle East Forum (MEF), a widely discredited Islamophobic organization, recently published online by Sunday Guardian Live.

The response is in the form of a letter to the publication ridiculing the attack against IAMC and its coalition partners, comprising of prominent human rights defenders in the US and India. The Sunday Guardian Live article, written by Benjamin Baird of the MEF makes baseless allegations about IAMC having links with “violent and extremist” entities, which includes individuals such as India’s Vice President Dr. Hamid Ansari as well as prominent writer and social activist Harsh Mander, who is a featured speaker at Amnesty International.

IAMC is known as an advocacy group dedicated to safeguarding India’s pluralist and tolerant ethos.

The advocacy group issued a press statement and stated, the pathetic attacks published in this barely known online publication, is astounding for their sheer absurdity. However, they also demonstrate the desperation of Hindu nationalist front organizations in the US to besmirch IAMC, even at the expense of collaborating with racist and xenophobic organizations like MEF that have no credibility. They are a continuation of the attacks initiated by MEF in an “opinion” piece published by Newsweek in December.

What is the Middle East Forum?

Middle East Forum has earned well-deserved notoriety as a well-funded racist group with a track record of xenophobia, bigotry, racism and hate-mongering. It has been called out by the Southern Poverty Law Center as well as the Center for American Progress, and is widely acknowledged as a rabid Islamophobic organization that revels in peddling hate and disinformation.

Multiple female employees at MEF have accused Daniel Pipes, MEF’s President, of having protected his second-in-command, himself accused of serial sex offenses in at least four cases of sexual harassment in the US. MEF is now embroiled in multiple sexual assault, sexual harassment and gender discrimination lawsuits by several female employees.

Additional details about MEF and its reputation for having “spent the better part of three decades vilifying Muslims,” can be found in the open letter.

Why are they attacking IAMC?

Hindu nationalist front organizations in the US have entered into a collaboration with MEF, in order to blunt the impact of IAMC and other organizations advocating for the defense of human rights and religious freedom in India.

In December 2020, Newsweek published a piece by Sam Westrop, who works for the MEF, alleging IAMC to be an “anti-Hindu, Islamist organization” with alleged links to an extremist organization in India. This is the same Sam Westrop who was ordered by a British court in 2017, to pay damages of £140,000 for falsely claiming in an article that a Tunisian Muslim man was a “convicted terrorist.”

Notably, after IAMC tweeted its second letter to Newsweek expressing displeasure with Westrop’s canard, the editor-at-large of Newsweek Naveed Jamali, wrote on Twitter that “people like Sam Westrop or the Middle Eastern Forum shouldn’t be given a platform.”

The piece published in Sunday Guardian Live is written by another MEF employee Benjamin Baird. Baird builds on Westrop’s distortions to craft an image of IAMC with the goal of undermining our advocacy for peace, pluralism and justice. Far from hurting IAMC, the piece is a classic example of cyber-lynch mobs that Hindu nationalist front organizations are now unleashing in the US, imitating the physical lynch mobs that countless Muslims and Dalits have fallen victim to in India.

One of the leading Hindu nationalist organizations in the US that is visibly collaborating with MEF to attack US groups working for human rights in India is the Hindu American Foundation (HAF).

IAMC President Ahsan Khan termed (published in Clarion India ) the continuous attacks by Hindu nationalist front organizations as a larger part of the “smear campaign” to spread vile and dangerous propaganda against Muslim organizations in America.

“Them going to this extent to attack IAMC actually energizes us even more, as it implies that our advocacy is hurting their efforts at ‘contextualizing’ the persecution of minorities in India and at mainstreaming Islamophobia in the US,” Khan said.

IAMC urged everyone interested in the details of the absurd attack to read the open letter to Sunday Guardian Live. These details provide a window into the minds of the bigoted individuals who are behind these attacks and for whom facts do not matter.

ED raids on NewsClick, is a clear attempt to suppress journalism critical of the government: DIGIPUB

0

Delhi: The raid by a team of the Enforcement Directorate at the office of NewsClick and at the home of Prabir Purkayastha, the founder and editor-in-chief, sent shock waves across the media fraternity.

DIGIPUB News India Foundation, an association of digital only media organizations in India strongly condemns the raids conducted by the ED at the office of NewsClick, and the homes of its directors and editor Purkayastha.

The raid, which began at 10 a.m., was seen as a continuum of the series of attacks on the media in recent times, especially on sections of the media that have been critical of Narendra Modi led BJP government and have questioned the policies of the government consistently.

DIGIPUB, in its statement claimed that NewsClick has always upheld the highest standards of journalistic integrity and speaking truth to power. Its commendable journalistic work seeking to hold power accountable speaks for itself.

The statement further reads, “DIGIPUB believes that the ED raids on NewsClick, its editor and directors, is a clear attempt to suppress journalism critical of the government and its allies. Such use of state agencies to intimidate journalists and suppress adversarial journalism is detrimental to not only the freedom of the press, but also the very idea of democratic accountability. Everyone emerges poorer in the long run.”

It demanded, “We demand that the government stop the ED action against NewsClick forthwith and make clear why the news organisation was raided to begin with. A free press, so integral to the preservation of democracy, can’t survive if journalists aren’t allowed to carry their professional work without fear.”

Meanwhile, NewsClick too issued a brief statement on the raids, “Truth shall prevail. We have full faith in the legal system,” said a brief statement by Newsclick, adding that the raids are still underway and a full statement will be released only after the process is over.

Earlier, speaking briefly on the issue to some reporters, Pranjal, accompanied by two ED officials, said: “There has been an ongoing raid since morning. We were shown a notice. Right now our documents are being checked. We are co-operating and will continue to co-operate.”

Earlier, soon after the raids, several journalists had expressed shock and anger on raid and tweeted about it.

Enforcement Directorate Conducts Raids on NewsClick Office, Officials’ Residences

0

New Delhi: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Tuesday morning raided the residences of several officials and journalists associated with NewsClick.in, an independent media portal based in Delhi. It is believed that ED raids the independent news portal, as it highlights common men’s plights.

Sources within the media group confirmed to The Wire that those raided included owner Prabir Purkayastha and editor Pranjal. According to The Hindu, the organisation’s office in Delhi’s Saidulajab was also raided.

ED raids NewsClick

According to The Quint, the ED said the raids on NewsClick were linked to an alleged money laundering case and the agency was probing funding the organisation had received from “dubious companies” abroad.

Anchor Abhisar Sharma, who hosts two YouTube programmes for NewsClick, also confirmed the raid on Twitter.

Along with Abhishar, senior journalists Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, Urmilesh, Aunindyo Chakravarty also report from here. In recent times, many independent journalist used to work from NewsClick’s office.

Most of these journalists’ shows are very popular and attract large viewers on YouTube and other platforms.

Some journalists took to social media to say that the ED raid on NewsClick was the government’s latest attempt to harass journalists who do no toe the official line.

 

This story first published at The Wire.