The Evolution of Durga: Tracing Her Multifaceted Origin Across Continents and Ages

1

Durga in her present form incorporates different streams, like Simha Vahini (the goddess who rides the lion), the Mahishasura Mardini (one who slays the Buffalo-Demon) and the Dashabhuja or ten-armed goddess. They evolved in different stages and ages.

The Simha-Vahini form was well known for several millennia in the Middle East and the Mediterranean region. She was worshipped as Ishtar in Mesopotamia,  Astarte in Greece and Cybele in Troy. Cybele of Turkey was, in fact, so powerful and in demand that she was taken away to Rome in 204 BC. The Roman emperors worshipped her as the “great mother of the gods”, Magna Mater Deium. Till the 4th century, her temple was located where the holy Vatican stands now.

It is quite interesting to note that her worship was known as “baptism in the blood of the sacred bull”, which reminds us of Durga spilling the blood of the buffalo. She was also referred to as the “goddess of caves” which reminds us of Durga’s origins from the words “inaccessible” or Durgam.

The Devi or the mother goddess was also quite visible in Europe and Africa since times immemorial. We see her image in plenty in the Indus Valley. But she appears less in the Vedic period, from which we get no figurines or material evidence.

The Satapatha and Taittiriya Upanishads, however, refer to “Ambika” but it is only in the Sutras of Boudhayana and Sankhayana that the name ‘Durga’ appears, for the first time. The Epics have stray references to Devi, Sakti, among others, but the ten-armed warrior goddess was not their focus area.

The Bhisma Parva mentions Arjuna worshipping Durga and there are references to Skanda-Kartikeya killing Mahishasura. A few Puranas mention Durga, but it was only when the “Devi Mahatmya” section of the “Markandeya Purana” glorified Durga’s victory over Mahishasura that she was legitimately inducted into the Hindu pantheon.

Soon, the old Vedic triad of “Brahma, Vishnu and Maheshwar” gave way to “Vishnu, Siva and Devi” and Brahma was retired to Pushkar.

Though Brahmanical literature took a long time to accept and glorify the goddess who killed the demonic buffalo, sculptures depicting this Devi appear centuries before the “Devi Mahatmya”. These are, however, not in the present Dasha-bhuja or Ashta-Bhuja forms, with 10 or 8 arms. The earliest image we get is a terracotta one from the 1st century found at Nagar in Rajasthan. It has the Mahisha, so this Durga is Mahisha-Mardini, but as there is no Asura, this form is not yet our Mahishasura-Mardini. We see the lion and the trishul, but Durga has only four hands.

Another set of six Kushana period statues in the Mathura Museum has the trishul and the buffalo, but no lion. J N Banerjea has described in detail the mature images of Mahishasura-Mardini of the Gupta period but the first major text on Durga came only after the Gupta period.

This means while powerful forces may have worshipped her for centuries, Brahmanism accepted her (through the Puranic route) only in the late 6th or 7th century.

 

It has also been posted on Jawhar Sircar’s Facebook page.

ফয়জান আহমেদ হত্যা মামলা শামুকের গতিতে এগোচ্ছে, আইআইটি খড়গপুরে আরও এক ছাত্রের মৃত্যু

কলকাতা: ইন্ডিয়ান ইনস্টিটিউট অফ টেকনোলজি খড়গপুরের ছাত্র আইআইটিিয়ান ফয়জান আহমেদ হত্যা মামলা শামুকের গতিতে এগোচ্ছে। বাংলা সরকারের প্রতিনিধি টানা তৃতীয়বারের মতো আদালতে হাজির হননি। অতিরিক্তভাবে, তৃতীয় বর্ষের মেকানিক্যাল ইঞ্জিনিয়ারিং ছাত্রের হত্যার আরও তদন্তের জন্য গঠিত বিশেষ তদন্ত দল (SIT) মাত্র পাঁচ দিন আগে 13 অক্টোবর তার সদস্যদের যোগ করেছে। এদিকে, বুধবার আইআইটি খড়গপুরে আরেকটি মৃত্যুর খবর পাওয়া গেছে।

আইআইটিিয়ান ফয়জান আহমেদ

গত বছর, ১১ অক্টোবর, আইআইটি খড়গপুরের একটি হোস্টেলে ফাইজান আহমেদের আংশিক পচা দেহ পাওয়া যায়। খড়গপুর পুলিশ এবং আইআইটি কর্তৃপক্ষ উভয়ই দাবি করেছে যে 23 বছর বয়সী ছাত্র, যিনি দুটি রোবোটিক্স গবেষণা দলের সদস্যও ছিলেন, আত্মহত্যা করেছিলেন। তবে তার বাবা-মা তাতে অসম্মতি জানিয়ে কলকাতা হাইকোর্টে মামলা করেন। প্রাথমিকভাবে, একটি একক বেঞ্চ এটিকে হত্যা বলে ঘোষণা করে এবং আরও তদন্তের জন্য একটি এসআইটি গঠন করে। পরে ডিভিশন বেঞ্চ সিঙ্গল বেঞ্চের সিদ্ধান্ত বহাল রাখে।

আজ, একজন আধিকারিক বিচারক জয় সেনগুপ্তের আদালতে একটি খাম জমা দিয়ে জানিয়েছিলেন যে 13 অক্টোবর সিনিয়র আইপিএস অফিসার কে জয়রামনের নেতৃত্বে এসআইটি গঠিত হয়েছিল। আদালত 20 নভেম্বর পরবর্তী শুনানির জন্য ধার্য করেছে এবং SIT প্রতিনিধিকে সেই তারিখের মধ্যে একটি অগ্রগতি প্রতিবেদন জমা দেওয়ার জন্য অনুরোধ করেছে।

“আমরা আদালতকে জানিয়েছি যে একক বেঞ্চ জুন মাসে এসআইটি গঠন করেছিল এবং ডিভিশন বেঞ্চ 16 আগস্টের আদেশে এটিকে ভেঙে দেয়নি। তারা শুধুমাত্র প্রধানকে তাদের দলকে একত্রিত করার পরামর্শ দিয়েছে। তবে, তদন্তে কোনো অগ্রগতি হয়নি,” ফয়জানের আইনজীবী অনিরুদ্ধ মিত্র ইনিউজরুমকে বলেন।

ফাইজানের মামলার আরেক আইনজীবী রঞ্জিত চ্যাটার্জি, বিচারপতি জয় সেনগুপ্তকে জানান যে বিলম্ব অভিযুক্তদের পড়াশুনা শেষ করার পর ভারত ছেড়ে যাওয়ার অনুমতি দিতে পারে, যার ফলে তাদের গ্রেপ্তার করা কঠিন হয়ে পড়ে।

IIT-KGP-এর আইনজীবী অনিন্দ্য মিত্র অনুরোধ করেছিলেন যে তদন্ত সম্পর্কিত খামটি প্রকাশ করা হবে না। হাইকোর্টে শুনানি চলাকালীন, আইআইটি-র আইনজীবীরা ধারাবাহিকভাবে মামলার বিরোধিতা করে আসছেন।

উল্লেখযোগ্যভাবে, বুধবার আইআইটি খড়গপুরে আরেকটি মৃত্যুর ঘটনা ঘটে যখন একটি হোস্টেলে চতুর্থ বর্ষের বৈদ্যুতিক প্রকৌশল ছাত্র কিরণ চন্দ্রের মৃতদেহ পাওয়া যায়। কিরণ তেলেঙ্গানার বাসিন্দা ছিলেন। ফাইজানের মামলার মতোই, খড়্গপুর পুলিশ এবং আইআইটি কর্তৃপক্ষ উভয়ই দাবি করেছে যে এটি একটি আত্মহত্যা।

Faizan Ahmed murder case moves at a snail’s pace, another student dies at IIT Kharagpur

Kolkata: The murder case of Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur student Faizan Ahmed has been progressing at snail’s pace. The Bengal government’s representative did not appear for the third consecutive time in the court. Additionally, the Special Investigation Team (SIT) constituted to further investigate the murder of the third-year mechanical engineering student added its members just five days ago on October 13. Meanwhile, another death was reported at IIT Kharagpur on Wednesday.

Last year, on October 11, the partially decomposed body of Faizan Ahmed was discovered in an IIT Kharagpur hostel. Both the Kharagpur police and IIT authorities claimed that the 23-year-old student, who was also a member of two robotics research teams, had committed suicide. However, his parents disagreed and filed a case with the Calcutta High Court. Initially, a single bench declared it a homicide and constituted an SIT for further investigation. Later, the division bench upheld the single bench’s decision.

Today, an officer submitted an envelope to Judge Jay Sengupta’s court, informing that the SIT, led by senior IPS officer K Jayaraman, was formed on October 13. The court did not disclose the details of who else was included in the SIT. The court scheduled the next hearing for November 20 and requested the SIT representative to submit a progress report by that date.

“We have informed the court that the single bench formed the SIT in June, and the division bench did not disband it in its August 16 order. They only suggested the head assemble their team. However, there has been no progress in the investigation,” Faizan’s lawyer, Aniruddha Mitra told eNewsroom,

Ranjit Chatterjee, another lawyer for Faizan’s case, informed Justice Jay Sengupta that the delays could allow the accused to leave India after completing their studies, thereby, making it difficult to apprehend them.

IIT-KGP’s lawyer, Anindya Mitra, requested that the envelope related to the investigation not be made public. Throughout the hearings at the high court, IIT’s lawyers have been consistently opposing the case.

Notably, another death occurred on Wednesday at IIT Kharagpur when the body of fourth-year Electrical Engineering student Kiran Chandra was found in a hostel. Kiran was a resident of Telangana. Similar to Faizan’s case, both Kharagpur police and IIT authorities have asserted that it is a suicide.

India: From World’s Largest Democracy to Disinformation Capital of The World!

Kolkata: The genocide by Israel in Palestine and Gaza in particular has turned India, the world’s largest democracy into disinformation capital of the world. While Indian fact-checkers have pointed out thousands of misleading tweets and claims in favour of Israel since the Hamas attack on Israel, now on the global level, it is being noticed.

On Tuesday, Twitter handle Frida Khan claimed that she is an Al Jazeera journalist. She tweeted after Israel bombed Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital in Gaza, killing more than 1000 people including children, “I am Al Jazeera Journalist Farida Khan working in Khan Younis, Gaza. I saw with my own eyes that it was the Hamas “Ayyash 250” Rocket. It was Hamas misfired Rocket. Al Jazeera is lying. I have video of that Hamas missile landing in the hospital (sic).”

Soon Al Jazeera tweeted and denied that there is any such journalist associated with them.
“Disclaimer: The X / Twitter account @_Faridakhan falsely claims Al Jazeera affiliation. We want to clarify: This account has no ties to Al Jazeera, its views, or content. Exercise caution, verify information prior to publishing (sic).”

israel-palestine-conflict india disinformation capital of world gaza hamas

After Al Jazeera’s tweet, Farida Khan deleted her first and later account.

Indian fact-checker and Co-founder of Alt News, Mohammed Zubair then pointed out that not only the claim of Farida Khan that she works for Al Jazeera, but her account is fake. The account is of someone from India and it is not of a girl as the name suggests.

Zubair has already debunked thousands of fake tweets and accounts which were falsely claimed in favour of Israel. He also showed, how an old video of 2022 is being shared as Hamas misfired a rocket on a hospital in Gaza.

He also pointed out that right wing troll accounts like @Smokingskills07, which mocks the minor victims in Gaza, is followed by women and child development minister Smriti Irani and several BJP MPs.

israel-palestine-conflict india disinformation capital of world gaza hamas fake

Another fact check organization BOOM Live debunked a fake tweet on October 18 by an Indian handler. “A photo of a list of 17 Nepali nationals who were either killed or injured in Kibbutz Alumim during the recent #Hamas attack is being shared with a false claim that they are names of Indian citizens kidnapped by the Islamic militant group (sic)”.

There are thousands of fake handles and tweets in support of the Israeli military’s propaganda doing rounds. The biggest was that Hamas beheaded forty babies. Which misled media houses as well as American President Joe Biden.

israel-palestine-conflict india disinformation capital of world gaza fake misinformation

On October 13, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the US Representative, NY-14 (BX & Queens) tweeted, “The level of misinformation in all directions at this moment is incredibly high, especially on this platform. If you see a claim, photo, or video that triggers a strong emotional reaction, take a moment to pause and check for veracity/confirmation from multiple sources (sic)”. She did not mention any particular country, from where it is being originated, maybe it was not her work.

But a day ahead, fact-checker Pratik Sinha said that now the world would have realized how the Indian right wing has made India the disinformation capital of the world. Sinha tweeted, “With India now exporting its disinformation actors in the Indian mainstream media and on social media in support of Israel, hopefully the world will now realise how the Indian right-wing has made India the disinformation capital of the world. The disinformation originating from India that fact-checkers globally are having to contend with, Indian fact-checkers have been dealing with that every day for several years now (sic).”

From Union Minister to Assembly Candidate: Scindia’s Second Chance at Chief Ministership

0

Bhopal: The name of Union Aviation Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia is buzzing with speculation as a potential candidate for next month’s Madhya Pradesh Assembly election. His candidature aligns with the Bharatiya Janata Party’s strategy for this round of elections, which is to field a few big-name candidates in each state, such as Union Ministers and Members of Parliament with strong local connections.

In line with this strategy, the BJP will field seven MPs, including three unioFn ministers: Narendra Singh Tomar (Dimani Assembly seat), Faggan Singh Kulaste (Niwas Assembly seat), and Prahlad Singh Patel (Narsingpur Assembly seat), in the assembly election. Another surprising contender for the election is BJP national general secretary Kailash Vijayvargiya (Indore 1 Assembly seat).

Of the four, Tomar, Patel, and Vijayvargiya are contemporaries of Chouhan, and they are seen as potential candidates for chief minister if the BJP wins.

Notably, the civil aviation minister is a Rajya Sabha MP and has never contested a state election. However, his name started gaining attention only after his aunt, Madhya Pradesh sports minister Yashodhara Raje Scindia, opted out of this election, citing health reasons. The 69-year-old Ms Scindia has contracted Covid-19 four times since the pandemic began.

In her absence, her nephew may be fielded either from his aunt’s Shivpuri seat or any of the two other seats in Guna – Bamori or Kolaras. All three are in the Lok Sabha segment of Guna that Jyotiraditya Scindia held from 2002 to 2014, according to a senior party functionary.

His candidature is likely to reignite his hope in the race for chief minister if the BJP come to power. Scindia missed the chance to become one of the youngest chief ministers of the central Indian state when Kamal Nath, 72, was selected for the top job in the state in 2018 by the Congress.

The billionaire heir to the one-time house of Gwalior, Jyotiraditya Scindia, declined the deputy chief minister post, just like Sachin Pilot when the Congress returned to power after 15 long years in 2018. Later, Scindia revolted and walked out of the Congress with a group of his supporters, leading to the downfall of the 15-month-old Kamal Nath government in early 2020 when he joined the Bharatiya Janata Party, possibly to be the chief minister if BJP forms government and wins bypolls, but here also it did not happen.

This was the second time that a member of the erstwhile royal family missed the chief minister post in the state. In 1989, Madhavrao Scindia, his father, a Union Minister (Railways), was unable to secure the top post.

Political observers informs that Scindia was all set to become chief minister after Arjun Singh had to step down following his alleged involvement in the Churhat lottery scam.

A confident Madhav Rao Scindia landed at Bhopal Airport (now named Raja Bhoj International Airport) and camped in the state for two days. According to veteran journalist ND Sharma, Madhavrao Scindia was unable to secure the coveted chief minister post due to stiff opposition from Arjun Singh, “Mr Singh, in a bid to get his way at the time, even kept his MLAs ensconced in the Char Imli residence of loyalist Harivansh Singh,” he recalled.

While a report by Press Trust of India article titled “Like father 30 years ago, Jyotiraditya Scindia misses out on Chief Minister’s post” published on December 15, 2018.

Instead, Motilal Vora was appointed as the chief minister, the report added.

It was not a mere coincidence that Jyotiraditya chose to quit Congress on a particular day, as noted by political analyst and author Rasheed Kidwai. “Jyotiraditya carefully chose the day of his rebellion: his father’s seventy-fifth anniversary, March 10,” as mentioned in Rasheed’s book The House of Scindias: : A Saga of Power, Politics and Intrigue.

Jyotiraditya posted a letter on Twitter addressed to Sonia, the Congress’s interim chief, announcing his resignation from the Congress. Minutes after he posted his resignation, the Congress expelled Jyotiraditya for ‘anti-party activities,’ just as P V Narasimha Rao had expelled Madhavrao in 1996 when he had resigned from the Congress, as written in the author’s book in the chapter titled Jyotiraditya Scindia: The Ambitious Gwalior Royal‘ on page 164.

Political observers also claim that there is no other leader of Scindia’s stature in the Gwalior-Chambal region. The Gwalior-Chambal region played a significant role in bringing the Congress to power in 2018 and has now contributed to the party’s decline in Madhya Pradesh. The Congress won 26 out of 34 seats in last assembly polls. Nearly five years later, both parties are almost evenly matched in the Gwalior-Chambal region. The Congress’s tally here has fallen to 17, while the BJP has increased its strength from a meager 7 to 16 after the by-polls in 2020.

While Scindia has not made it clear whether he will contest the Assembly election, he strongly reacted when a section of the media claimed that he was unwilling to contest in the upcoming Assembly election in Madhya Pradesh after his meeting with Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan at his residence. Scindia loyalist and State BJP spokesperson Pankaj Chaturvedi dismissed this news as “completely baseless and fake.”

So far, the BJP has named 136 candidates, and the Congress party has declared the names of 144 candidates for next month’s Madhya Pradesh Assembly election. The Assembly has 230 seats, meaning that the BJP has 94 and the Congress has 86 more decisions to make. Both parties are likely to release the names of candidates during the Navratri season, which began on October 15.

The party has sent the message that the BJP will contest ‘unitedly’ under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, and not on the face of Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan (an MLA from Budhni assembly seat).

गिरिडीह की ट्रेन सेवा दुविधा: यात्रियों और राजस्व के लिए समय क्यों मायने रखता है

गिरिडीह/कोलकाता: 12 सितंबर को, पहली बार, न्यू गिरिडीह रेलवे स्टेशन को एक एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन, भारतीय रेल से मिली, जो जिले को राज्य की राजधानी रांची से जोड़ती है।

इसके बाद, दो वंदे भारत ट्रेनें शुरू की गईं, एक रांची से हावड़ा तक और दूसरी पटना से हावड़ा तक, जो झारखंड के मुख्य स्टेशनों से होकर गुजरती थी।

मीडिया ने अक्टूबर से ही पटना और हावड़ा के बीच चलने वाली खंडोली एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन की समय सारिणी प्रकाशित की. इन सभी घटनाक्रमों से कोई भी यह विश्वास कर सकता है कि ट्रेन सेवाओं में महत्वपूर्ण सुधार हो रहे हैं और इससे गिरिडीह को सबसे अधिक लाभ होगा। हालांकि, इन परिवर्तनों ने यात्रियों के जीवन पर उस तरह से प्रभाव नहीं डाला जैसा कि कोई उम्मीद कर सकता था।

भारतीय रेल और गिरिडीह

गिरिडीह में 1871 में ही रेलवे स्टेशन था। लेकिन इसे कभी एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन नहीं मिली। अब, इसके दो स्टेशन हैं- गिरिडीह और न्यू गिरिडीह। पिछले सितंबर में न्यू गिरिडीह को इंटरसिटी एक्सप्रेस मिली।

विडंबना यह है कि जहां तक ​​गिरिडीह में रेल सुविधाओं में सुधार का सवाल है, “भारत की जीवन रेखा” जिले के 32 लाख लोगों के लिए अभी तक कुछ खास नहीं बदल पाई। जब नई गिरिडीह-रांची इंटरसिटी ट्रेन का उद्घाटन किया गया, तो यह बहुत धूमधाम से किया गया, जिसमें कोडरमा और गिरिडीह के सांसद अन्नपूर्णा देवी और सीपी चौधरी उपस्थित थे

गिरिडीह-रांची एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन का विपरीत समय

नई गिरिडीह-रांची एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन (18618) की टाइमिंग यात्रियों को मिलने वाले फायदे के विपरीत है। ट्रेन राज्य की राजधानी के लिए अपनी यात्रा दिन के दूसरे भाग में दोपहर 2:30 बजे शुरू करती है और सुबह 6 बजे रांची से प्रस्थान करती है। प्रतिदिन सुबह 4 बजे से दोपहर 12 बजे तक गिरिडीह और रांची के बीच कम से कम एक दर्जन बसें चलती हैं। ट्रेन शेड्यूल को समायोजित किया जाना चाहिए ताकि लोग भारतीय रेलवे का उपयोग करके सुबह राज्य की राजधानी की यात्रा कर सकें और शाम को वापस लौट सकें।

“यदि ट्रेन का समय नहीं बदलता है, तो यह दक्षिण पूर्व रेलवे ज़ोन के लिए पर्याप्त राजस्व उत्पन्न नहीं करेगा, जिससे संभावित रूप से उन्हें इसे बंद करने का कारण मिलेगा। गिरिडीह में एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन शुरू करने का श्रेय लेने वाले व्यक्तियों को व्यावहारिक समय सुनिश्चित करना चाहिए जिससे यात्रियों को लाभ हो।” गिरिडीह स्टेशन के एक रेलवे अधिकारी ने गुमनाम रूप से बात करते हुए कहा।

वंदे भारत ट्रेन धनबाद से होकर ही नहीं जाती और मधुपुर में रुकती नहीं, मतलब दोनों बड़े और महत्वपूर्ण स्टेशन को वंदे भारत नहीं मिली। भारत की कोयला राजधानी के रूप में जानी जाने वाली धनबाद, झारखंड का सबसे बड़ा स्टेशन है और यहां से प्रतिदिन 56 जोड़ी ट्रेनें गुजरती हैं। पटना की वंदे भारत ट्रेन मधुपुर से भी गुजरती है, जो जामताड़ा और जसीडीह की तुलना में एक प्रमुख स्टेशन है, जहां यह रुकती है। मधुपुर स्टेशन पर एक स्टॉप जोड़ने से राजस्व में वृद्धि होगी क्योंकि गिरिडीह के लोग अक्सर अपने शहर में सीधी ट्रेनों की अनुपस्थिति के कारण दूसरे शहरों के लिए ट्रेन मधुपुर से पकड़ते हैं।

पटना से हावड़ा वाया न्यू गिरिडीह का अनौपचारिक टाइम टेबल मीडिया द्वारा जारी

हाल ही में, स्थानीय मीडिया ने पटना-हावड़ा के बीच चलने वाली ट्रेन खंडोली एक्सप्रेस के लिए एक समय सारिणी प्रकाशित की, जिसमें बताया गया कि जल्द ही इसका न्यू गिरिडीह में ठहराव होगा। हालांकि, बाद में पता चला कि यह चैंबर ऑफ कॉमर्स का एक सुझाव था, न कि भारतीय रेलवे अधिकारियों की ओर से कोई आधिकारिक घोषणा।

जोनल रेलवे उपयोगकर्ता सलाहकार समिति (पूर्वी रेलवे) के सदस्य प्रदीप अग्रवाल ने पुष्टि की कि वे दक्षिण पूर्व रेलवे जोन के अधिकारियों से रांची-न्यू गिरिडीह ट्रेन की समय सारिणी में बदलाव करने का अनुरोध कर रहे हैं।

हालाँकि, ट्रेन शेड्यूल की तकनीकी जानकारी रखने वाले कुछ पर्यवेक्षकों का मानना ​​है कि दिन के समय में पटना से हावड़ा तक एक एक्सप्रेस ट्रेन से गिरिडीह निवासियों को कोई खास फायदा नहीं होगा। चूंकि पटना शहर से काफी दूरी है और दिन के सफर की वजह से गिरिडीह यात्रियों को केवल आंशिक लाभ मिलेगा। इसके बजाय, सुबह हावड़ा पहुंचने के लिए गिरिडीह से रात 10 बजे के आसपास प्रस्थान करने वाली स्लीपर ट्रेनों का सुझाव, ज्यादा बेहतर हो सकता है और बड़ी राहत होगी। इसी तरह, अगली सुबह गिरिडीह और पटना पहुंचने के लिए हावड़ा से रात 10 या 11 बजे प्रस्थान एक आदर्श समय रहेगा और इससे राजस्व का भी लाभ होगा। इससे भारतीय रेल और गिरिडीह एक दुसरे से सही मायने में जुड़ेंगे भी।

 

ये स्टोरी, इंग्लिश का अनुवाद है

Giridih’s Train Service Dilemma: Why Timing Matters for Commuters and Revenue

0

Giridih/Kolkata: On September 12, for the first time, New Giridih railway station received an express train by Indian Railways that connects the district to the state capital, Ranchi.

Subsequently, two Vande Bharat trains, one running from Ranchi to Howrah and another from Patna to Howrah, passing through the main stations of Jharkhand, were introduced.

The media published a timetable for the Khandoli Express train, scheduled to run between Patna and Howrah from October itself. All these developments might lead one to believe that significant improvements are occurring in train services and that Giridih would benefit the most. However, these changes did not affect the lives of commuters in the way one might expect.

Giridih and Indian Railways

Giridih had a railway station in 1871 itself. But it never got an express train. Now, it has two stations– Giridih and New Giridih. Last September, New Giridih got an intercity express.

Ironically, as far as improving the rail facilities in Giridih is concerned, the “Lifeline of India” did not change much for the 32 lakh people of the district. When the new Giridih-Ranchi Intercity train was inaugurated, it was done with great fanfare, with Members of Parliament from Koderma and Giridih, Annapurna Devi, and CP Choudhury, in attendance.

Opposite timing of Giridih-Ranchi express train

The timing of the new Giridih-Ranchi express train (18618) is the opposite of what would benefit travelers. The train begins its journey to the state capital in the second half of the day at 2:30 pm and departs from Ranchi at 6 am. Every day, at least a dozen buses travel between Giridih and Ranchi from 4 am to 12 noon. The train schedule should be adjusted so that people can travel to the state capital in the morning and return in the evening using Indian railways.

“If the train timings do not change, it will not generate sufficient revenue for the South Eastern Railway Zone, potentially giving them a reason to discontinue it. The individuals taking credit for introducing the express train to Giridih should ensure practical timings that benefit passengers,” said a railway official at Giridih station, speaking anonymously.

The Vande Bharat trains do not stop at Dhanbad or Madhupur, which is a significant issue. Dhanbad, known as the coal capital of India, is the largest station in Jharkhand and has 56 pairs of trains passing through it daily. Patna’s Vande Bharat train also skips Madhupur, which is a major station compared to Jamtara and Jasidih, where it does stop. Adding a stop at Madhupur station would increase revenue since people from Giridih often choose to catch trains to other cities from there due to the absence of direct trains in their city.

Unofficial time table of Patna to Howrah via New Giridih released by media

Recently, vernacular media organizations published a timetable for the Khandoli Express, a Patna-Howrah bound train, suggesting that it would soon have a stop in New Giridih. However, it was later revealed that this was a suggestion from the Chamber of Commerce and not an official announcement from Indian Railways authorities.

Pradeep Agrawal, a member of the Zonal Railway Users’ Consultative Committee (Eastern Railway), confirmed that they are requesting South Eastern Railway Zone officials to change the timetable of the Ranchi-New Giridih train.

However, some observers with technical knowledge of train schedules believe that an express train from Patna to Howrah during daylight hours may not significantly benefit Giridih residents. As Patna is quite a distance from the city, the train will always be halfway, providing only partial benefit to Giridih commuters. Instead, they suggest sleeper trains departing around 10 pm from Giridih to reach Howrah in the morning, which could better address the long travel issue. Similarly, a 10 or 11 pm departure from Howrah to reach Giridih and Patna the next morning would provide an ideal timing.

By exterminating 1.5 million Palestinians, Israel is not creating a ‘final solution’. It won’t be able to live peacefully

0

So much for ‘human rights’, ‘right to resistance,’ ‘rule-based order’. Well in the last twenty years, we have seen these leaders getting completely exposed. The rule-based order is nothing but clever manipulations of things to protect their interests.

The Palestine issue can not be confined to Hamas and its terror regime. The legitimacy of Hamas has come from the Western world just to create an alternative to the Palestinian Authority. In any society, when the liberal elements fail or are made to fail, the radical right-wing takes over. The right wings have never been the first choice but they thrive on the failure of the ‘secular’ ‘liberal’ element and have to take it all together. This is happening in most of the countries that were decolonised and a lot of credit to these radical right-wingers growing and getting access is the Western World as all these forces have their safe heavens in the Western world from where they speak about ‘human rights’, oppression and ‘democracy’ among others.

Israel-Palestine Conflict

The issue is why are people of Gaza are being punished for the fault of HAMAS. In any country or society, various forces are working to attain their freedom. The killing of civilians on both sides is extremely unfortunate and condemnable in no uncertain terms. Hamas governs Gaza and due to blockade in that region, its rule remains unchallenged. It always happens that a tyrannical regime rules in the absence of an environment for free and fair polling because of the continuing blockade. It suits all the parties. It suits Hamas as they have no challenge to their authority and it suits Israel well to project every Palestinians as terrorists.

Hamas’s act can’t be supported which killed innocent civilians but the question is shouldn’t Israel behave in a more civilised and responsible way? Israel had blockaded Gaza for the last fifteen years. Is it true that Hamas has provided Israel an opportunity to exterminate the people in Gaza?

israel-palestine conflict gaza hamas
An area in Gaza being bombarded by Israel | Courtesy: Times of Gaza/Twitter

The solution to the issue is not the ‘final solution’ by the extremely unpopular right-wing government in Israel. By exterminating about 1.5 million people, Israel is not creating a ‘final solution’ for it but it won’t be able to live peacefully. In the last fifty years, we have seen regular fights and bitter experiences. Israel may be a powerful country because it has the backing of the Western world but I don’t think they could sleep even a single day peacefully. This attack has exposed the chink in their armour that despite the best security apparatus and all digital devices their security was breached and so powerfully.

It is time for peace which can not happen without providing the Palestinians a rightful sovereign space of their own without any intervention by outsiders. Israel and Palestine need to live together. Both Israel and Palestine need to accept that they existed and historically have lived together as citizens of Palestine. It is time, they accept this historical fact. The problem was created by the West which ‘solved’ their problems in the aftermath of the Second World War by ‘settling’ the Jews in Palestine. The British and the Americans are solely responsible for this. The question is whether the trials at Nuremberg and in Japan after the Second World War were just sham and fake because the fact is why were the Jews not given land in the countries they were living in? Why should people living in a place for so many years be sent to a land they had left for a long?

Europe created this crisis and now, it is giving Israel a blank cheque to invade Gaza and exterminate it. How can the world accept such an ‘ultimatum’ to the inhabitants of a state to leave or get killed? Already, Gaza is being destroyed. The same European and American commentators were defending Ukraine’s right to self-defence but that right to self-defence does not exist with Palestine.

israel-palestine conflict gaza hamas west human rights
Darkness, rubble, and grief in Gaza

One reality of our time. Russia could have easily flattened Kyiv but it did not. It still waged a very professional war despite the big propaganda emerging in the Western capitals but today the big ‘respected’ Western media are showing the brutalities of Hamas by showing the pictures of the Palestinian children killed in the mindless, soulless bombing by Israel.

India could have seized this big moment as a power of the global south by initiating a peace dialogue. Instead, we looked happier in the company of the West and Indian cheerleaders have gone to ‘report’ to Indian people how ‘powerful’ Israel is. The aim is to legitimise similar acts in our territory. Israel therefore, became a role model for all the tyrannical regimes to suppress dissent and how to deal with the ‘obstacles’.

India’s historic position has been clarified by the Ministry of External Affairs and Palestine was a friend. Let the media understand that this is not a religious issue. It is not a Muslim Jew issue as both have lived together. It is an issue of decolonisation. Palestine needs their independence. Both Palestine and Israel will have to live together and accept the historical presence of both. India can play a historic role in negotiating a peace deal but for that just ignore your manustream darbaris shouting from the ‘battlefield’ who are not gone to report but just show you the tamasha for the sole purpose of making it convenient for their funders in the coming elections. Every international issue is being played for the domestic constituencies making it difficult for the diplomat to work with other countries.

This madness must stop. Say no to war. Give peace another chance. Accept both Palestine and Israel as two nations living side by side and peacefully.

আইআইটি-এর অস্বাভাবিক অবস্থান: ফাইজান আহমেদ হত্যা তদন্তে সমর্থন প্রত্যাখ্যান

কলকাতা: এটা নিষ্পত্তি করা উচিত, আমার প্রভু, “আইআইটি কেজিপি-র মেকানিক্যাল ইঞ্জিনিয়ারিংয়ের তৃতীয় বর্ষের ছাত্র ফয়জান আহমেদের হত্যা মামলায় খড়গপুরের ইন্ডিয়ান ইনস্টিটিউট অফ টেকনোলজির প্রতিনিধিত্বকারী অনিন্দ্য মিত্র বাধা দিয়েছিলেন। বিচারক জয় সেনগুপ্ত, যিনি ছিলেন ফয়জান আহমেদের আইনজীবী রণজিৎ চট্টোপাধ্যায়ের যুক্তি শুনে বারবার বাধা সত্ত্বেও সিনিয়র আইনজীবী মিত্রের কাছে প্রশ্ন তোলেন, “এসআইটি (বিশেষ তদন্ত দল) রিপোর্ট ছাড়া?” আদালত কক্ষে কয়েক মুহূর্ত নীরবতা ছিল। “আমি পর্যালোচনা করব। অগ্রগতি প্রতিবেদন এবং তারপর সিদ্ধান্ত নিন,” বলেছেন বিচারপতি সেনগুপ্ত।

আইআইটি খড়গপুর হত্যা মামলা

দুই মাস পরে, বিচারপতি জয় সেনগুপ্তের আদালতে কলকাতা হাইকোর্টের একজন নতুন বিচারপতির সামনে আইআইটি খড়গপুর হত্যা মামলা ফয়জান আহমেদ হত্যা মামলার শুনানি শুরু হয়। যাইহোক, এটি একই বিন্দু থেকে শুরু হয়েছিল যেখানে এটি প্রধান বিচারপতি টিএস এবং বিচারপতির সাথে ডিভিশন বেঞ্চে শেষ হয়েছিল। আইআইটি আইনজীবীরা মামলাটি বাতিল করতে চেয়েছিলেন।

11 অক্টোবর, 2022-এ, খড়্গপুরের আইআইটি ক্যাম্পাসে তার হোস্টেল থেকে 23 বছর বয়সী ফয়জান আহমেদের আংশিক পচনশীল দেহ উদ্ধার করা হয়েছিল। এর কিছুক্ষণ পরেই খড়্গপুর পুলিশ এবং আইআইটি কর্তৃপক্ষ উভয়েই দাবি করে যে ফাইজান আত্মহত্যা করেছেন। যাইহোক, হাইকোর্টে প্রায় এক বছরের আইনি লড়াই এবং শুনানির পর, যার মধ্যে ফাইজানের লাশ উত্তোলনের পরে দ্বিতীয় ময়নাতদন্ত অন্তর্ভুক্ত ছিল, দুটি আদালত, প্রথমে একজন একক বিচারক এবং পরে একটি ডিভিশন বেঞ্চ এটিকে হত্যা বলে রায় দেয় এবং আদেশ দেয়। আইপিএস অফিসার কে জয়রামনের নেতৃত্বে এসআইটি তদন্ত করে। তারা এফআইআর-এ ভারতীয় দণ্ডবিধির 302 ধারা অন্তর্ভুক্ত করার জন্য পুলিশকে নির্দেশ দিয়েছে।

ডিভিশন বেঞ্চ বিচারপতি রাজশেখর মন্থার একক বেঞ্চের সিদ্ধান্ত বহাল রাখার পরে, এটি আশা করা হয়েছিল যে আইআইটি এবং রাজ্য উভয়ই তাদের অবস্থান পরিবর্তন করবে এবং নির্যাতিতার পরিবারকে সমর্থন করবে।

হাস্যকরভাবে, ক্যাম্পাসের সীমানার মধ্যে ঘটে যাওয়া অন্যান্য মামলার বিপরীতে, আইআইটি কর্তৃপক্ষ কখনই পরিবারের সাথে সহযোগিতা করেনি এবং প্রতিটি স্তরে কার্যক্রমের বিরোধিতা করেনি।

আজ, অনিন্দ্য মিত্র, আইআইটি কৌঁসুলি, পুনর্ব্যক্ত করেছেন যে মামলার খুব বেশি কিছু নেই এবং এটি নিষ্পত্তি করা উচিত। ভারতের অন্যতম প্রধান ইনস্টিটিউটে অধ্যয়নরত একজন ছাত্রকে জড়িত সবচেয়ে নৃশংস হত্যাকাণ্ডের একটিতে SIT এখনও একটি অগ্রগতি প্রতিবেদন দাখিল করতে পারেনি।

শুনানির সময়, এক পর্যায়ে, ফয়জানের আইনজীবী রণজিৎ চ্যাটার্জিকে আদালতকে জিজ্ঞাসা করতে হয়েছিল, “মামলাটি বিচারাধীন থাকলে আইআইটির জন্য সমস্যা কী?”

আদালত আরও বলেছে যে এটি প্রথমে নিশ্চিত করবে যে ভুক্তভোগী পক্ষ তাদের অধিকার পাবে, এবং তারপরে তারা বিবেচনা করবে যে মামলার কী হওয়া উচিত,” ফাইজানের অন্য আইনজীবী অনিরুদ্ধ মিত্র ইনিউজরুমকে বলেছেন।

ফাইজানের মা, রেহানা আহমেদও মর্মাহত এবং উদ্বেগ প্রকাশ করেছেন যে কেন IIT তাকে ন্যায়বিচারের জন্য সমর্থন করছে না কিন্তু তার সর্বশক্তি দিয়ে এর বিরোধিতা করছে।

তিনি ভাবলেন, “আইআইটি কাকে রক্ষা করতে চায়?”

উল্লেখযোগ্যভাবে, গত তারিখ হিসাবে, 9 অক্টোবর, রাজ্যের কেউ উপস্থিত ছিলেন না।

আদালত 17 অক্টোবর মঙ্গলবার পরবর্তী শুনানির তারিখ নির্ধারণ করেছে।

IIT’s Unusual Stand: Refusing Support in Faizan Ahmed Murder Investigation

Kolkata: It should be disposed off, my lord,” interrupted Anindya Mitra, representing the Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, in the murder case of Faizan Ahmed, a third-year Mechanical engineering student at IIT KGP. Judge Joy Sengupta, who was hearing arguments from Faizan Ahmed’s lawyer, Ranajit Chatterjee, despite the repeated interruptions, posed a question to senior counsel Mitra, “Without the SIT (Special Investigation Team) report?” There was silence for a few moments in the courtroom. “I will review the progress report and then decide,” said Justice Sengupta.

Two months later, the hearing in the IITian Faizan Ahmed murder case began before a new judge at the Calcutta High Court, in the courtroom of Justice Jay Sengupta. However, it started from the same point where it had ended at the division bench with Chief Justice TS and Justice. The IIT lawyers sought to quash the case.

On October 11, 2022, the partially decomposed body of 23-year-old Faizan Ahmed was recovered from his hostel on the IIT campus in Kharagpur. Shortly afterward, both Kharagpur Police and IIT authorities claimed that Faizan had committed suicide. However, after nearly a year of legal battles and hearings at the high court, which included a second post-mortem after exhuming Faizan’s body, two courts, first a single judge, and later a division bench, ruled that it was a homicide and ordered an investigation by the SIT led by IPS officer K Jayaraman. They also directed the police to include Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code in the FIR.

After the division bench upheld Justice Rajasekhar Mantha’s single bench decision, it was expected that both the IIT and the state would change their stance and support the victim’s family.

Ironically, unlike other cases that occurred within campus boundaries, IIT authorities never cooperated with the family and opposed the proceedings at every level.

Today, Anindya Mitra, the IIT counsel, reiterated that there isn’t much to the case and that it should be disposed off. The SIT has yet to file a progress report on one of the most brutal murder cases involving a student studying at one of India’s premier institutes.

During the hearing, at one point, Faizan’s counsel, Ranajit Chatterjee, had to ask the court, “What is the problem for IIT if the case remains pending?”

“The court also stated that it will first ensure that the victim’s side receives their rights, and then they will consider what should happen to the case,” Aniruddha Mitra, another lawyer for Faizan, told eNewsroom.

Faizan’s mother, Rehana Ahmed, has also expressed shock and concern as to why IIT is not supporting her in seeking justice but opposing it with all its might.

She wondered, “Who does IIT wants to protect?”

Notably, as on the last date, October 9, no one from the state was present.

The court scheduled Tuesday, October 17, as the next hearing date.