Home Blog Page 21

As Kolkata Mourned RG Kar Doctor, Bhopal’s 5-Year-Old Victim Left Forgotten: The Unequal Justice in India’s Outrage

Bhopal: A 5-year-old girl was raped and brutally murdered by a neighbour in Shahjahanbad of Bhopal. The accused Atul Nal strangled the child after committing the rape. After going missing for three days, her body was discovered on September 26 in a water tank within the very building where she lived. Despite extensive search efforts involving over 200 police personnel from multiple stations, drones, and search dogs, authorities were unable to locate the girl in time leading to public outrage and criticism of the police response. The prime accused along with his mother and sister has been arrested for their roles in this horrific crime.

Protests erupted throughout the state capital demanding the death penalty for the accused concerning the increasing crime rates against women and girls. The locals in Shahjahanbad rallied and gathered at the police station voicing their anger and frustration. A Special Investigation Team (SIT) has been formed to investigate the case.

A video showed that the mother and sister of the accused were misleading the police during the investigation. The footage reveals both women alongside the prime accused, Atul, standing at their door during the time of the girl’s death feigning sympathy towards the victim’s family while smoothly concealing their involvement in the crime. They audaciously questioned authorities about the safety of women and children displaying no shame or fear in their demeanor.

Rising crimes against women and children in MP

Data from the city police commissioner revealed rape cases in Bhopal rose from 330 in 2021 to 456 in 2022, 523 in 2023, and 381 in just the first eight months of 2024. NCRB data from 2022 shows Madhya Pradesh ranks second in crimes against children with 20,415 cases just behind Maharashtra’s 20,762.

In 2022, 11,717 children went missing in Madhya Pradesh, with 75% (8,844) being girls, as per RTI data analyzed by the NGO Child Rights and You (CRY). On average, 32 children went missing daily, with over 24 being girls. In 2021, 11,607 children went missing in Madhya Pradesh, with 81% (9,407) being girls, according to NCRB data. In 2022, missing girls declined by 6%, but missing boys increased from 19% to 25%. From 2018 to 2022, 53,125 kids went missing in total, with 78% being girls.

According to the State Crime Record Bureau (SCRB), 5,348 women were sexually assaulted in the state in 2023. The highest number of crimes against women in 2023 occurred in Bhopal and Indore zones. A total of 7,773 women were molested, 10,306 kidnapped, and 13,671 faced obscenities statewide in 2023. Bhopal topped the list with 7,745 cases, followed closely by Indore with 7,738. Gwalior reported 6,331 cases, Rewa 6,296, and Ujjain 5,169.

Interestingly, the Madhya Pradesh Women’s Commission has been dysfunctional for years with the chairperson’s position vacant for over four years.

Death penalty law fails to deter a surge in rape.

BJP MLA Archana Chitnis called the incident unfortunate. Speaking to eNewsroom she said, “The Madhya Pradesh government is the first to pass a law to award capital punishment, yet incidents like these continue. There are multiple factors at play—the influence of entertainment, societal culture, and more—all impacting people’s minds. To prevent such incidents, families, society, government, and even religious organizations must act collectively. The situation is deeply concerning. How do we send our daughters out for education when such cases occur? Many claim Madhya Pradesh has a high number of FIRs, but it’s because our government ensures that an FIR is registered immediately against such anti-social elements. The accused are arrested in large numbers following complaints. Collective efforts can improve this situation. Entertainment, music, literature, and cultural activities shape our personalities, and we must address these issues at multiple levels. The accused have no religion or caste; they are simply criminals. The media should also present these matters in a balanced and healthy manner.”

Chief minister Mohan Yadav in a lengthy post on “X” wrote, “There is a provision of death penalty for such heinous crimes and our government will try to ensure that such criminals get the harshest punishment like death penalty.”

In 2018, the Madhya Pradesh government passed the Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2018 which made the state one of the first in India to introduce the death penalty for rape of girls aged 12 years or younger. This amendment strengthened existing laws under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) specifically Sections 376AB and 376DB to impose the death penalty for such offenses.

Despite harsh penalties like death sentences, this central Indian state saw a 66% rise in rape cases in 2023 with an average of 14 women/girls sexually assaulted daily, as per SCRB data.

Opposition criticizes the government’s failure to protect minors.

Recent cases of child sexual abuse even in educational settings have also raised concerns about the safety of children. A 16-year-old boy was sexually harassed by his chemistry teacher, a 5-year-old girl was abused by her school van driver, and a 3-year-old girl was abused by her IT teacher in the past week. On September 27, Madhya Pradesh Congress President and former cabinet minister Jitu Patwari shared a post on X highlighting seven reported cases of sexual harassment and rape of minor girls across different districts of Madhya Pradesh within a week.

While the rape and murder of a trainee doctor in RG Kar Hospital of Kolkata shook the collective conscience of the nation leading to mass protests, the rape and murder of a minor in Bhopal did not bother countrymen. Additionally, this September, a woman was raped in broad daylight at a busy crossroad in Ujjain. Yet, bystanders chose to film the crime and post it on social media instead of helping the victim, while the nation remained silent. The disparity in reaction raises troubling questions about societal priorities and the perceived value of lives based on political context.

Congress MLA Arif Masood led a protest rally in Shahjahanbad criticizing the state government’s failure to protect women and children. He called for the chief minister’s resignation if he had any shame left. Masood also questioned the accountability of Collector Kaushlendra Vikram Singh, asking, “Where is the collector who once boasted in Berasia? Many incidents have occurred. Why are the collector and SP hiding now?”

On September 12, protests erupted at Berasia police station in Bhopal after three minor schoolgirls were allegedly blackmailed by local men. The accused who were arrested for taking photos and attempting to extort the girls faced demands for action from Hindu organizations including the Bajrang Dal. The situation was controlled when Collector Kaushalendra Singh intervened promising swift action while standing on a car’s bonnet.

The accused were slapped with the NSA (National Security Act). Masood was referring to this incident.

Influence of pornography worrying.

Anurag Pandey of the Madhya Pradesh Commission for Protection of Child Rights (MPCPCR) said that we are focusing on awareness and personal safety in response to rising cases in Bhopal. Aggression levels are increasing despite our efforts. “We have found in reported cases that many perpetrators watch pornography before committing rape while intoxication plays a significant role in diminishing humanity. The Madhya Pradesh government is rapidly reporting all cases and law is doing its part but we seek additional resources and measures. We have discussed prevention strategies regarding intoxicants and tightening the grip on violators. We’re also investigating a troubling new pattern where families support the accused. Shocking instances, like the murder and rape of a minor where the family tried to hide the body, are alarming. This behavior is incomprehensible and we are consulting experts to understand the psychological reasons behind it. Although stricter laws are in place, crime rates continue to rise. Improved reporting does not indicate a decrease in crime, so raising awareness remains essential.”

In another shocking incident, a nine-year-old girl was raped and murdered by her 13-year-old brother in Rewa after watching a pornographic video on her mobile phone. The incident happened in April which the mother and two elder sisters of the accused tried to cover up.

The Supreme Court of India recently ruled that viewing, possessing, and not reporting child pornography is an offence under the POCSO and IT Acts, even if not shared further.

Concerns over liquor and drug consumption and its link to rising crime rates

Congress MLA Atif Aqueel in conversation with eNewsroom said every crime has its complexities but the recent rape and murder in Eidgah Multi highlight a deeper issue: the unchecked illegal sale of substances like hashish, opium, marijuana, and alcohol. These readily available intoxicants often drive individuals toward violent acts. Crime rates continue to rise despite the commissioner rule showing failure to address root causes.

“A young girl was raped and murdered yet authorities have failed to take prompt action against this illegal sale creating fear and insecurity. Women and children no longer feel safe in their neighbourhoods. I raised these concerns with officials six months ago, but no action was taken. Criminals must face justice regardless of their background, especially in cases involving minors. We demand severe penalties including capital punishment to deter such crimes. It’s alarming that even a 5-year-old fell victim. The core problem remains the easy access to intoxicants which diminish humanity. We must stop illegal sales to protect society and prevent more tragedies. The government must act now to ensure the safety and dignity of women and children.”

Liquor consumption in Madhya Pradesh has risen sharply. In 2022-23, people consumed 1,909.18 lakh bulk litres of foreign liquor (malt), almost double the 962.18 lakh bulk litres used in 2021-22. For the spirit category, 684.69 lakh proof litres were consumed in 2022-23, up from 471.03 lakh proof litres the previous year.

Overlooked by Media, Celebrated by Millions: How Wali Rahmani’s Social Media Campaign Built a World-Class School

0

Kolkata: The year he became a law graduate, his dream job at a world-class educational institution was also realized. There was no legacy to follow. It took him 5 years to complete the law course, but this international-level infrastructure took shape within just a year. In 365 days, he not only collected Rs 10 crores from the public but also used it to build a modern school with hostels for the poor kids. When he shared the story on social media a fortnight ago, it garnered 20 million views. This 26-year-old young man is none other than Wali Rahmani.

During his teenage years and while studying, Rahmani started his Umeed Academy with three underprivileged kids in 2017.

The law graduate from Jamia Hamdard University’s achievement might be one of the rarest in the world. But it seems to have not received enough attention from the mainstream Indian media, where you will rarely find his story, with only a few exceptions.

“At present, 350 children are studying at Umeed Global School. While most of them are underprivileged, more than 30 are orphans. Most of the students stay in the hostel. When we had no hostel facility, our students were already following a 12-hour schedule, from 7 am to 7 pm, staying in the academy. As we aim to make them future leaders, without making them feel that they are from weaker sections of society, we not only provide the best education but also focus on their health and extracurricular activities,” Rahmani informed eNewsroom.

Umeed Global School Founder’s September 15 video on YouTube

Best Use of Social Media

In India, social media is mostly used to spread hatred or to earn money through bizarre activities. Young Rahmani, understanding the power of social media as early as the time when he was in Standard 12, used it positively. Almost eight years ago, when most people in India were still unfamiliar with the power of YouTube videos, he uploaded his first video on his channel. The gifted orator soon became a young sensation, with Rahmani’s videos garnering millions of views. During that time, he adopted underprivileged kids and started using the money he earned from YouTube to support them. He also gained a large following on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Through these platforms, he connected with donors for his Umeed Academy. After a few years, he received a piece of land as a donation for Umeed Global School. Rahmani once again utilized social media cleverly, asking only for Rs 100 from everyone. He encouraged his followers to share his video with one million people, from whom Rs 100 could be collected, thereby raising Rs 10 crores.

“And it happened! Within 7 days, I had Rs 7 crores. When the school project was nearing completion, I again requested people to help build the hostels, and once more, our donors chipped in,” Rahmani shared excitedly.

wali rahmani umeed global school crowdfund education Bengal Muslims underprivileged orphans classroom
A classroom in progress at Umeed Global School

An Academy for All

The academy has students from various backgrounds, non-Muslim kids as well as teachers, administrators, and staff from communities other than Muslims.

“We believe in providing better education and life to everyone. Yes, since we are more connected with our community and the academy is situated in a minority-dominated area, we have a higher number of Muslim students,” Rahmani clarified.

“Dean of Academics, Rinku Bhattacharya; General Manager, Abhishek Mukherjee; and architect Subrato Mondal played important roles in the journey from Umeed Academy to Umeed Global School. We have such dedicated people for our cause that, while it might sound unbelievable, two trustee members- Saifuddin Perwez and Mohammed Yakoob, left all their other work for one year to complete this state-of-the-art project within a year. We must show our donors that their hard-earned money is being used in a well-planned and honest manner, and our entire school management team helped make this a reality. It also allowed our students to study in a world-class school environment,” Rahmani mentioned.

Wali Rahmani Umeed Global School education students kickboxing champions
The Champions of State level Kickboxing 2024: Students of Umeed Global School with their medals | Photo credit: Umeed Global School

The school provides everything—books, uniforms, and meals for every student. it has smart classrooms, well equipped computer lab, the school has Innovation and Technology Lab. In this lab, students learn Robotics, Drone making, Coding, Artificial Intelligence, and Designing.

The dedication of the team is reflected in their results: for three consecutive years, Umeed students have become state kickboxing champions. This year, 13 students of Umeed Global got medals.

Whenever a young sportsperson or youth achieves something rare, people and the media often ask what others were doing at that age. In such instances, young Rahmani provides a perfect answer—his achievement is not only personal success but also for the benefit of society and the underprivileged children of India.

The kids lovingly call him Abbaji (father figure). And who better deserves such a respectable title?

Democracy Still Lives in Bengal Says Dr Kafeel And Calls Out UP’s Oppression

0

Kolkata: What will you do to show gratitude to a city that extended its help to you when you were down in the dumps? Come back to show your solidarity with its people when they need you. Well, that’s precisely what Dr Kafeel Khan has been doing for the past few days in Kolkata.

“I am back in Kolkata to show my solidarity with the doctor’s movement demanding justice for Abhaya, which is now a people’s movement,said Dr Khan.

Dr Kafeel on RG Kar Protests

Known for not mincing words, he said,Democracy prevails in Bengal. The people of this state have done what none could do in the past. What happened in RG Kar Hospital, is a deplorable act. The fact that a doctor was not just raped but was tortured to death and then some people in the higher order of the medical college made attempts to cover it up is just shameful.He then paused and added,The protest that followed has shown Indians how to take onto the streets and demand for justice.”

When asked what he thought about the entire episode he said,While the public need to be commended, we just can’t deny the fact that the chief minister Mamata Banerjee went to meet the angry doctors and agreed to meet their demands. No matter how angry you are, please understand that Bengal even today offers a space to voice your concern, to protest. Had this been in UP all the protesters would have been put behind bars and had the National Security Act (NSA) slapped on them.”

He mentioned that he had met the protesting doctors when he arrived in the city to extend his solidarity with their movement.It’s almost two months since the crime was committed. The CBI needs to get down to the result and have the guilty punished,” added Dr Kafeel.

The Victim Doctor

The Gorakhpur doctor whose heart-wrenching story even found a place in Shah Rukh Khan’s hit movie Jawaan, was in Kolkata to launch the Bengali translation of his The Gorakhpur Hospital Tragedy: A Doctor’s Memoir of a Deadly Medical Crisis.

The much-acclaimed book, which Dr Khan says was a way to document his journey, has been published in 11 languages and took much time to translate into Bengali.Bengal has given me much love and support. Bengali Bhadralok was the first to hit the streets demanding justice for Dr Kafeel Khan. So, when I was writing this book, I had a vision to have it simultaneously published in Bengali. But somehow, we didn’t have any publisher till now,he said while showing a copy of the Bengali translation of the book.

The activist doctor, who is celebrating his birthday today while narrating his journey claimed that the vilification he received from the Uttar Pradesh government would have been the same had it been some Mishra or John.The government needed a scapegoat to save itself from being dissolved. And that’s what they did – maligned my name to save the government,said Dr Khan along the sidelines of his book launch organised at the Muslim Institute, Kolkata.

However, he pointed out that the journey from being hailed as a saviour to being labelled as a person with an ulterior agenda for the nation has been tough and that despite having his name cleared off all the allegations levelled at him, he is yet to get justice.

And what does justice mean to him? The doctor answered,Assurance of providing free healthcare services to the poorest of the poor in the country.”

The River of a Billion Lives: Vidya Bhushan Rawat on Sacred, Polluted and the Future of the Ganga

0

Kolkata: Vidya Bhushan Rawat, a dedicated activist, author, and filmmaker, has spent the last three decades working with marginalized communities. His commitment has taken many forms—from conducting padyatras (foot marches) for social causes to delivering lectures, conducting interviews, and producing documentaries. Recently, he achieved a rare milestone: traversing the Ganga from its source in the Himalayas to its mouth in the Bay of Bengal. This journey, which began in September 2021, marks three years of documenting the environmental, cultural, and historical dimensions of India’s most revered river.

Rawat’s extensive work includes numerous documentaries capturing the essence of this journey, and with over 25 published books to his name, his forthcoming work on the Ganga is highly anticipated. On the very next day after completing this extraordinary Ganga yatra (journey), he spoke to eNewsroom, sharing his reflections with a calm demeanor, yet at times brimming with excitement—much like the Ganga itself. Here is an excerpt from that conversation.

eNewsroom: Why did you decide to travel along the Ganga River?

VBR: Being a native of Uttarakhand, my love for rivers and mountains comes naturally. The first time I saw the Ganga was in 1978, when I was just a ten-year-old child. I had traveled to visit a relative’s house in Muni Ki Reti, Rishikesh, and was mesmerized by the beauty of the river. The water was a stunning green, pure and serene. Sitting on the bank and watching the calm flow of the river brought me immense joy.

As I grew older and moved to Dehradun for my studies, visiting Har Ki Pauri in Haridwar became a regular activity. I also knew that in our family, as in many others, it was customary to cremate the deceased on the banks of the Ganga in Haridwar. Even after I migrated to Delhi in 1991, my connection to Uttarakhand remained strong because of my deep love for its natural beauty.

Two decades later, I saw a powerful art exhibition by Ambedkarite artist Savi Savarkar at the Lalit Kala Academy. One of the paintings, titled Debrahminising the Ganga, made a lasting impression on me. However, the real spark for my Ganga journey came after I traveled to the upper Himalayan region of Uttarakhand in 2021, shortly after the Covid-19 lockdowns. I witnessed the mountains being exploited and saw muck flowing into the river. This inspired me to create a short 10-minute video titled Ganga Tum Behti Raho, which was well-received by many of my friends.

river ganga ganges environment yatra culture climate uttarakhand
Ganga in Uttarakhand | Credit: VBR

Having undertaken several padyatras in Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand, I began discussing the idea of a boat journey or an exploration of the Ganga. However, logistical and financial challenges made it difficult to realize at the time. Eventually, some friends offered to support my initiative to document the Ganga and the environmental crises it faces, particularly in Uttarakhand. This support helped me begin the project in earnest.

As I delved deeper into the river’s story, I realized that merely documenting the Ganga’s tributaries in the Himalayas would not be enough. I felt compelled to continue the journey all the way to the Bay of Bengal. Although I initially thought the challenges in the Himalayan region were the toughest, I found the low-lying Gangetic plains even more difficult to navigate.

In September 2021, I began my journey with a trek to Gaumukh from Gangotri, covering not just Uttarakhand but also the Yamuna Valley, Tons, Mahakali, and other regions. I traveled through Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand, and West Bengal, completing the journey from Gangotri to Ganga Sagar. This journey has not only been a fascinating exploration but has also deepened my understanding of people, nature, geography, and the crises faced by both the rivers and the communities living along them.

eNewsroom: How significant was your journey in the context of Indian culture, given that civilizations in India grew around the Ganga?

VBR: For Hindus, the Ganga holds immense religious and spiritual value. To most, she is Maa Ganga. In the Uttarakhand region, however, she is known as Shailputri, the daughter of the Himalayas. Unfortunately, over the last few decades, the Ganga has been reduced to a symbol for rituals, often disregarding her dignity and sanctity. For me, it was equally important to look beyond her religious aspect and understand what draws us to the Ganga. Why is she Maa Ganga for everyone? In this sense, the journey has been profoundly educational for me.

Starting from the Himalayan region, I witnessed firsthand that the area is the abode of both Shiva and Buddha. Shaivism and Buddhism flourished in these mountains, nurturing a liberal cultural value system where man-woman relationships were more open and democratic. The priesthood was not as dominant here, but as the Ganga flows down into the plains, we see the increasing ritualization of the river and the cultural dominance of Brahmanism. More rituals led to more pollution in the plains, where few seemed concerned about the health of the river.

The Ganga is not just a source of religious and cultural fulfillment; it has also been a witness to the growth of various cultures and civilizations in India. Empires and kingdoms flourished along its banks, contributing glorious chapters to Indian history. King Jai Chand of Kannauj, vilified in history textbooks by Brahmanical historians, was actually one of the greatest kings of the region. Before him, King Harsha’s empire also thrived along the Gangetic belt.

river ganga ganges environment yatra culture climate heritage bengal
The historic Imambara of Bandel and the back side the Hooghly passing towards Kolkata | Credit: VBR

One of the most outstanding architectural works that has stood the test of time is Chunar Fort. The Ganga looks magnetic here, just before it reaches Kashi, where it becomes even more beautiful and intensifies the spiritual energy of the people, as millions come to bathe in her waters and worship Lord Shiva. The Ganga also witnessed the anti-Brahmanical and humanist values of legendary saints like Raidas and Kabir. Furthermore, one cannot overlook the importance of Sarnath, which holds immense significance for Buddhists worldwide.

Pataliputra, the capital of the great Ashoka, was located on the banks of the Ganga and its five tributaries. Although Patna city has shifted farther away, it is said that the original city lay on the banks of these five rivers. Today, Ganga, Ghaghara, Sone, and Gandak are still in close proximity to the city. Moreover, we cannot forget that Patna is also the birthplace of Guru Gobind Singh, the 10th Guru of the Sikh religion.

Another significant Buddhist center of learning along the Ganga was Vikramshila, one of the greatest universities after Nalanda. Between Bhagalpur and Sahibganj in Jharkhand, there are numerous Buddhist sites. Rajmahal, a town in Jharkhand situated along the Ganga and the Rajmahal hills, was once the capital of undivided Bengal, which included Bihar, Jharkhand, and Odisha. This designation was made by Raja Man Singh, one of Emperor Akbar’s most trusted generals, who was appointed Governor of Bengal. Today, Rajmahal is home to the beautiful Baradari and Juma Masjid, a mosque built by Raja Man Singh.

In Bengal, the Ganga’s journey is breathtaking and relatively unexplored by outsiders. The region is steeped in history, with remnants of Buddhist architecture in Gour, the pre-Mughal capital of Bengal. In Murshidabad, the capital during the Mughal period, we have the iconic Hazarduari and other stunning structures, all situated on the banks of the Bhagirathi. At Nabadwip, the birthplace of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, the Bhagirathi meets the Jalangi River and is thereafter known as the Hooghly. At places like Bandel, Chandernagore, Hooghly, and others, we see a rich mix of Mughal, Portuguese, Dutch, French, and British architecture. The British played a significant role in developing the Hooghly river network, and many of the bridges and buildings they constructed are still in use by the administration today. The old Rajbaris and remnants of the zamindari system in Bengal tell their own tales. Interestingly, the zamindars in Bengal were not Rajputs but Brahmins, Muslims, and Kayasthas.

So, from the Himalayas to the Sundarbans, the Ganga is not just a river—it is the lifeline of India, shaping our civilization and giving us our identity. It nurtured the most fertile lands, supported fishermen and folk communities, and inspired enchanting music, like that of Bismillah Khan, created on its banks. The Ganga is our heritage, and we must not only respect and revere it but also protect it.

eNewsroom: How important is this journey for understanding climate change and environmental issues, especially considering that rivers like the Ganga, which impact billions of lives, are neither as clean nor as vast as they once were?

VBR: Yes, this is one of the most critical aspects of the journey. The rapid melting of glaciers is a tragic reality. This year, we saw many mountains without snow as early as May, which was heartbreaking. In addition, extreme weather conditions, floods, and increased forest fires are contributing heavily to disasters. As I traveled through the Gangetic plains, it was disheartening to see the lack of awareness regarding the protection of the river. From the lower parts of Haridwar, you can already see large sandy patches as the river grows narrower and narrower. Floods deposit silt and sand, which enter our fields in many places, devastating the agricultural system.

river ganga ganges environment yatra culture climate varanasi kanpur buxar
From Varansi to Kanpur to Buxar, Rawat found factory nalas, filth, garbage being thrown out in the river

At Kannauj, a farmer told me that there’s more profit in reti (sand) than in kheti (farming), meaning they’re now more involved in sand mining than agriculture. Sand mining is rampant in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, and it’s leading to greater environmental damage. I must be honest in my assessment: I’m witnessing the desertification of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. Every year, the rivers—Sarda, Ghaghra, Kosi, Gandak, and Ganga—bring floods that result in widespread destruction. The water level of the Ganga is low in many places, causing it to split and widen. Summers are becoming increasingly hotter. The water quality at Kanpur, Varanasi, and Patna is extremely poor; it’s not even fit for bathing.

As the Ganga enters Bengal, it becomes larger because it’s a low-lying area, but this also means floods wreak havoc on the lives of common people, with water everywhere.

The quality of Ganga’s water is a serious concern, and it should worry not just the authorities but every citizen. All efforts must be made to ensure that no sewage flows into the river. Municipalities and village Panchayats along the Ganga and its tributaries must be empowered to penalize industries that discharge chemical waste into the river. But it’s equally important that these local bodies should also be held accountable and penalized if they fail to stop the sewage from entering the river in their jurisdictions. Religious leaders must educate devotees about the importance of not throwing waste into the river. Disposing of old clothes, waste, plastics, flowers, and other items into the Ganga must stop. Bathing in the river should be regulated, and personally, I would request devotees to refrain from it. Instead, they can worship the river by taking a sip of the water and sprinkling it. That would do a great service to the nation.

I’m always amazed by the duplicity of people who claim Ganga is Maa and yet pollute it by spitting in the river and bathing in it as if they have never taken a bath at home. Taking a dip should fulfill a spiritual need, not turn into a “watersport.” If we continue to spoil our water bodies, we will ruin our sources of clean water. Ganga’s water is considered pure, and it is our national duty to protect it, not pollute it. We must remain vigilant because if Ganga’s pollution is not addressed, it could trigger a massive civilizational and environmental crisis for India.

eNewsroom: What have you learned from this journey? Did it challenge any of your preconceived notions about rivers, particularly the Ganga?

VBR: This journey has strengthened my belief that no journey is ever truly complete. It has given me new insights and made me realize how the Ganga has witnessed the growth of countless civilizations, kingdoms, empires, and contributed to literature, art, and culture. To be honest, I had no idea how vast and complex the river’s journey was. We’re typically familiar with names like Haridwar, Kanpur, Allahabad, Varanasi, and Patna, but there is so much more. Most North Indians don’t even know that the Hooghly is part of the Ganga, and in Bengal, the name Bhagirathi carries deep cultural significance. Many people in Bengal refer to the Hooghly simply as Ganga.

I also had the misconception that the river would feel lifeless after Kanpur, but I was wrong. I didn’t realize that Bihar has some of the most beautiful places along the Ganga. Munger, Bhagalpur, and Kahalgaon are breathtakingly beautiful and should be promoted more. I had no idea that Vikramshila, one of India’s greatest ancient universities, was located on the banks of the Ganga. Another revelation was the historic town of Sahibganj in Jharkhand, which truly opened my eyes. The journey from Sahibganj to Manihari by ship was unforgettable, and I was amazed to see large cargo ships sailing on the Ganga, especially in Bihar. It was an incredible experience to take a 45-minute journey on the river with my car aboard one of these ships—it showed me just how vast the Ganga truly is.

The Ganga in Bengal is particularly complex in terms of its branches, both tidal and non-tidal, which helped me gain a deeper understanding of the region. I wasn’t aware of how intricate the river system was. For a long time, I was confused about the origin of the Hooghly, thinking it began at the Farakka Barrage. But visiting Giria in Murshidabad, where the Hooghly begins, cleared up that confusion. Along the way, I encountered so many palaces, temples, mosques, Gurudwaras, and confluences. It has truly been a lifetime experience, but I know the journey will continue. This expedition has filled me with a deep sense of gratitude and a duty to do everything I can to protect and preserve these rivers, which are not just geographical lines but also our identity and heritage.

eNewsroom: Do you believe the Ganga will lose its importance in the next 20-30 years, or will it remain central to Indian life, or possibly even gain more prominence?

VBR: The Ganga, or any river in India for that matter, can never lose its importance. If that were to happen, our civilization would collapse. We cannot even imagine life without the Ganga. Look at the fertile lands of Western Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, and Bengal. Ask the fisherfolk about its significance. However, the threat remains—if pollution continues unchecked, we may be left with only sewage water, which would be catastrophic. Religious revivalism has led priests to reduce the Ganga to a mere object for rituals, without any real effort to ensure its cleanliness.

We need to understand that a cleaner Ganga will bring greater satisfaction to us all. Why do people flock to the Himalayas, Devprayag, and Rishikesh just to see the river? It’s because the Ganga there is vibrant, full of life. Its waters appear sublime—so pure and clean that one instinctively wants to drink from it without hesitation. But as the river flows into the plains, we lose that purity. In Kanpur and Varanasi, you can’t even bathe safely in the river (although people still do, unaware of the poor water quality).

It’s time to take the climate crisis seriously. The issues of the Himalayas are critical, not just for the people of Uttarakhand, Ladakh, or Himachal Pradesh, but for the entire country. The government must remain vigilant, and the state governments should also address these concerns—most importantly, with the involvement of local communities. We cannot and should not attempt any solutions without their participation, as doing so would only lead to further disaster.

eNewsroom: What are your suggestions to policymakers for the betterment of the Ganga?

VBR: In my book, I will provide specific suggestions based on my observations in each state, as there are region-specific issues. However, here are a few common points. First, hold local bodies accountable and empower them to take action against industrial units that are polluting the river. Stop the flow of drainage water into the Ganga. The Green Tribunal or municipal corporations must penalize and prosecute companies or factories that fail to act on polluting units or drainage systems that affect the river. Allocate more funds to monitoring agencies. Engage local communities and villagers in efforts to protect and preserve the Ganga.

Religious tourism needs to be regulated. The massive influx of tourists to the Himalayan region will lead to disaster, as these areas lack the infrastructure to accommodate such large numbers of people. The sanctity of places like Kedarnath and the Sundarbans must be preserved at all costs, rather than allowing religious tourism to turn into a profit-driven enterprise. From the Himalayas to the Bay of Bengal, we need to carefully plan tourism so that a heavy influx of visitors does not damage local cultures and ecosystems.

Will Rahul Gandhi’s Rising Popularity Turn the Tide in Haryana’s BJP-Dominated Political Landscape?

0

New Delhi: All eyes are on Rahul Gandhi’s Haryana election campaign as Leader of Opposition.

After becoming Leader of the Opposition (LoP), the Haryana and Jammu & Kashmir assembly polls are the first real test for Rahul Gandhi to prove that the Congress party’s improved performance in the Lok Sabha elections was not a fluke. The grand old party, leaning heavily on his campaign, is gaining momentum among the masses, especially in Haryana, where the Congress faces a direct contest with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). For the Congress, regaining power in the state is crucial.

The party is riding on renewed energy from Rahul Gandhi’s growing popularity and the anti-incumbency sentiment against the BJP government. However, Rahul Gandhi’s campaign is not only about winning votes but also about uniting the state’s party leaders, who have been divided into factions—a division that has cost them victories in states like Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan.

The Congress MP kicked off his campaign on Thursday with two major rallies in the Hisar and Karnal districts. In Karnal, where Rahul Gandhi held his first rally, he managed to bring together Kumari Selja and former Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda.

The Raebareli MP is scheduled to address around eight rallies in Haryana. Along with him, his sister Priyanka Gandhi is also expected to join the campaign trail soon.

The most critical task for Rahul Gandhi will be to maintain party unity and fight the elections as a cohesive force against the powerful BJP, which is facing 10 years of anti-incumbency. Opinion polls and election surveys suggest that Congress may have the upper hand.

It will also be interesting to see which issues Rahul Gandhi raises during the assembly poll campaign. The Agniveer scheme and the BJP’s heavy-handed treatment of youth, especially the wrestlers who were dragged in Delhi, may feature prominently. The two prominent faces of the protesting wrestlers, Bajrang Punia and Vinesh Phogat, who fought a long battle against former BJP MP Brij Bhushan Singh, accused of sexual harassment of wrestlers, have joined Congress. Phogat, an Olympian, is also contesting the election.

Rahul Gandhi has consistently raised concerns about the Agniveer scheme, challenging the government over it. The Congress has made its opposition to the scheme clear.

The results of the Haryana elections will also have a bearing on the upcoming Maharashtra and Jharkhand polls. Delhi’s former Chief Minister, Arvind Kejriwal, had earlier requested the Election Commission to conduct state elections alongside those in Maharashtra and Jharkhand. If that happens, an additional election may be on the cards. Given the situation, every move by the Leader of the Opposition will be crucial for the party and its leadership.

Bovine Politics, Human Cost: Why Madhya Pradesh’s Cow Protection Year is Making Headlines for the Wrong Reasons

0

Bhopal: After assuming office, the Mohan Yadav-led BJP government in Madhya Pradesh pledged to celebrate 2024 as ‘Gauvansh Raksha Varsh (Bovine Protection Year),’ emphasizing its campaign on cow protection and preservation. In 2020, the state also constituted the ‘gau cabinet (cow cabinet)’ the first of its kind in the nation. Besides, the central Indian state has also amended the Madhya Pradesh Cow Slaughter Prohibition Act, 2004 empowering the district collectors to confiscate vehicles to prevent illegal transportation or smuggling of cows. In a controversial move, the administration has even demolished the homes of those accused of allegedly keeping beef in their refrigerators.

 

Despite government measures and crackdowns, the condition of cows in the state remains dreadful. Hundreds of cows still wander the roads leading to accidents and deaths— of humans and (sacred animals). However, there is little action against those who fail the government’s campaign and public outrage remains absent.

 

Cow Welfare in Madhya Pradesh: Claims, Promises And Reality Checks

 

The Animal Husbandry Department in August reported that 93 cows have died and 295 were injured in road accidents on state highways connecting Bhopal, Raisen, Vidisha, Sehore, Dewas, and Rajgarh cities of the heartland of India. At least three cows died everyday in July. The government reported in June freeing 7,500 cows and arresting 1,000 individuals for illegal cow transportation.

 

The Madhya Pradesh High Court recently issued a notice to key officials seeking a response from the state on stray cattle blocking national highways. A division bench of Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva and Justice Vinay Saraf questioned why cattle are allowed to gather on roads causing disruptions. The notice came in response to a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by Tikamgarh resident Swami Dev Swaroopanand who raised concerns about the dire condition of cattle hurting religious sentiments of Hindus.

 

Notably, in August, the Madhya Pradesh government formed a high-level committee to tackle the issue of stray cattle, launching a 15-day special campaign to address the problem.

 

BJP MLA Vishnu Khatri in conversation with eNewsroom said that addressing the stray cattle issue isn’t simple, especially in rural areas. The government is making efforts. Five years ago, there were no gaushalas (cowsheds) in my assembly; now, we have around 10-12. The Yadav government increased the fodder allowance to Rs 40 per cow which helps. We’ve also involved private organizations to manage some gaushalas like the Tribal community doing an excellent job.

 

Madhya Pradesh has around 2,000 gaushalas and 9 lakh stray cattle. Funding for cows grew 26 times from 2019 to 2024 with daily funds rising from Rs 1.5 to Rs 20 under the Kamal Nath government, and to Rs 40 under the present BJP government.

 

Ground realities and resource allocations

 

Ishika Khakre of Animals With Humanity expressed concerns over the poor conditions of cows on the roads. She identified the lack of dairy by law enforcement as the main reason cows roam the streets. Dairy owners abandon cattle after milking, unable to afford their feed. While the Gauvansh Act in Madhya Pradesh bans cow slaughter, buffaloes can still be sent to slaughterhouses leaving aging cows on the streets. Despite being revered, many cows eat garbage showing a lack of government action.

 

“If the government were truly active, dairy bylaws would be enforced by now. Recent attempts to relocate cows to gaushalas failed due to poor conditions—no food, sanitation, or care. The problem isn’t a lack of laws but their implementation. Our team shared dairy bylaws with authorities in December but no actions were taken until accidents increased. Now, they’re collaborating with policymakers to implement long-term solutions, urging dairy owners to take responsibility and care for their cattle,” Khakre commented.

 

The Hindustan Times reported that the Madhya Pradesh government diverted the funds meant for SC/STs for cow welfare. According to the report, Rs 252 crore is allocated for cow welfare through the Gau Samvardhan and Pashi Samvardhan schemes. Rs 95.76 crore of this is from the SC/ST sub-plan. The fund has grown from around ₹90 crore last year.

 

“This is not a permanent program. Past allocations for cow protection don’t rule out future SC/ST funding. The government addresses various perspectives and fields. While SC/ST funds aim to support their progress, development comes from multiple sources, not just these funds. Any financial shifts are temporary and will improve over time. Previous governments failed to manage gaushalas properly. People only keep cattle for milk and abandon them afterwards. We must instil a sense of responsibility for ageing cattle, similar to caring for elderly parents. Unlike the Congress governments, the BJP is focusing on utilizing resources like cow urine and dung for medicines,” Khatri stated.

 

Communal tension and legal ramifications

 

Muslim men have been continuously harassed and lynched in allegations of cow-related offences, including slaughter, smuggling, theft, and transportation of cattle perpetrated by individuals affiliated with Hindutva organizations and right-wing groups. In May 2022, two Tribal men allegedly accused of slaughtering a cow were lynched by a Hindutva mob in tribal-dominated Seoni of Madhya Pradesh. Sixty three butchered bovines were found on June 19 in the district central to the government’s crackdown. Fifty five cases were registered, 99 people were arrested, and 1,301 cows were rescued in the first half of this year.

 

“Various self-serving organizations and workers take unwanted actions on emotions. Especially, when there is a mob that lacks wisdom. It’s important to differentiate between cow trafficking and animal husbandry during transportation. While unwanted minor incidents may occur, the government intends to protect cows. It has implemented measures to prevent these occurrences and the law takes action in such cases. It protects innocent individuals,” said Khatri.

 

A livestock transporter informed eNewsroom that his vehicle transporting buffaloes was stopped by RSS last week and an FIR was filed against him. “I only transport buffaloes, not cows. My business is entirely legal yet I face harassment. Farmers from various communities such as Rajputs, Yadavs, and Brahmins bring cattle to the market. The Municipal Corporation gives a receipt when the livestock are purchased. As long as the livestock remains with the seller it is legal.

 

However, once buyers obtain the receipt, it suddenly becomes illegal. This has happened to me at least 10 times when my transport was seized. I even pay a monthly fee to different police stations despite running a legal business. They make false allegations of animal cruelty but I won’t quit. Why would anybody risk their life transporting cows knowing the dangers?” he questioned.

 

The IndiaSpend database in 2017 revealed a disturbing trend: India had witnessed 78 cow-related hate crimes since 2012 with a staggering 97% of these incidents occurring after the Bharatiya Janata Party and Prime Minister Narendra Modi came to power in May 2014. Only one incident was reported in both 2012 and 2013. 86% of the victims were Muslims. Data collected by it from 2010 onwards revealed no reported cases during 2010 and 2011.

 

Eleven Muslim homes were demolished on June 15 in Bhainswahi of Mandla in allegations of illegal beef trade and recovery of 150 cows and beef in their homes. The action was taken just a day before Bakrid left entire families without shelter. In another instance in June, the authorities demolished the homes of four Muslim men in Jaora of Ratlam allegedly for throwing cow parts in the temple.

 

By July, the state demolished 21 homes in cow-related incidents in 2024.

 

The Supreme Court of India on September 17 stayed the demolitions of homes including those of accused individuals until October 1. The Court emphasized that even a single instance of illegal demolition undermines the “ethos” of the Constitution. However, this order does not apply to unauthorized structures on public roads, footpaths, railway lines, or water bodies.

 

“The Indian Constitution and laws do not discriminate based on religion or caste. Everyone has the right to celebrate their festivals. Demolitions typically occur only in cases of illegal encroachments and proper notices should be given. Though it may seem selective in the media, encroachment is still encroachment, regardless of religion. Bulldozers should be used appropriately and within legal parameters. I certainly won’t defend the government on this. It’s the responsibility of the concerned department that encroachments should be stopped immediately, not after incidents occur, as delayed demolitions aren’t justified. Bulldozers do not target only criminals; they operate under due process. There must be planning for development to address encroachments effectively,” remarked Khatri.

 

Cow holds a sacred status for many Indian Hindus making it a pivotal element in political discourse. In the 2023 state assembly elections, both the BJP and Congress used cow politics to sway voters. Madhya Pradesh Cow Slaughter Prohibition Act, 2004 law strictly prohibits the slaughter of cows, calves, bulls, and bullocks in the state. It criminalizes the act of cow slaughter with provisions for imprisonment and fines. It also bans the transportation of cows for slaughter within and outside the state.

 

The act amended in 2019 also has provisions against cow vigilantism.

 

Recently, Prime Minister Narendra Modi shared a picture with a calf on his “X” account amplifying the ongoing political narrative around cow protection and its role in shaping public sentiment.

 

“The dairy business is rife with malpractices where cows are treated as commodities. They’re often separated from calves to maximize milk output, and illegal drugs like oxytocin are used in 80% of dairies to boost milk production. Despite this, the government slot online ignores these issues while major players like Amul monopolize the industry, even classifying alternatives like soya milk as beverages. Instead of stricter actions against a particular community, the government should focus on addressing the actual issue. If we can channel the same energy used in demolishing homes into implementing existing laws, we could find real solutions,” Khakre added.

Heart of Bengal’s Healthcare: Inside the Dilemma of Disillusioned Doctors

Kolkata: Three batchmates from Calcutta Medical College passed their MBBS in 2013. Eleven years later, only one of them is working in Bengal’s health department. The other doctors are now employed with central institutions — one in an autonomous medical institution in North India, and the other is working in Kolkata but under the Government of India.

While the RG Kar rape and murder incident brought attention to institutional safety concerns for junior doctors, as well as corruption within these institutions, larger issues affecting resident doctors in Bengal, still persist. eNewsroom interviewed several resident doctors and uncovered two significant problems: salary disparity and deteriorating work culture. These issues are prompting doctors to either leave the state for opportunities elsewhere or avoid returning to ‘Sonar Bangla,’ resulting in a major brain drain of medical professionals from the state.

Batchmate 1: Opts for Central Government Job

“Shortly after completing my MBBS, I took the Union Public Service Commission Examination in 2015. Since July 2016, I’ve been working with the Central Government Health Scheme (Ministry of Health and Family Welfare). From the beginning, I have received a Seventh Pay Commission salary. Although private practice is not allowed, I haven’t felt much need for it. I chose a central government job because I need a basic work structure that the state government doctors, especially in rural areas, are not provided with. Most of the time, you’re initially posted in rural areas or on the outskirts,” said

He added, “I would have worked outside the state anyway, but when I was offered a central government job with a better pay scale (almost double) with a Kolkata posting, I was content. I’m now a Senior Medical Officer.”

This medical officer draws a monthly salary of Rs 1,50,000.

“It’s not that I don’t want to work in rural areas or for the state government. Apart from the salary difference, there’s also a lack of proper medical facilities needed to work effectively for the state,” he explained.

bengal health sector doctors brain drain medical

Batchmate 2: An Endocrinologist Working at an Autonomous Institution

“I was admitted in one of India’s best centres for my MD, so I completed my Master’s in Medicine (MD, Internal Medicine) in 2016 and my Doctorate in Medicine (DM, Endocrinology) in 2019. In 2021, I joined as an Assistant Professor at the same institution. I may be promoted next month,” said the doctor over the phone.

The endocrinologist earns Rs 1,70,000 and receives Rs 1.4 lakh in hand along with other perks, including full treatment coverage and medicine costs borne by the institution.

“Under me are a few students from Bengal doing their DM. These students are sponsored by the Bengal government. They have no choice but to return to Bengal after three years, but they’re not happy about it because they have no alternative,” the Assistant Professor remarked.

When asked if he feels an obligation to serve Bengal, as he completed his MBBS there, he responded: “I’m grateful for my education at Calcutta Medical College—it was very good. My schooling and medical education in Kolkata laid the foundation for everything I am today. While pursuing my MD and DM studies, I wanted to return to Kolkata because my ageing parents live alone in South Kolkata. But my friends advised me against it, saying it’s very difficult for someone like me, who is dedicated to their work, to thrive in Bengal. For me, salary is not the main issue; I need a dedicated work environment, which my friends say is severely lacking in Bengal.”

Batchmate 3: A Senior Resident at RIO, Calcutta Medical College

“I’m the one who joined most recently in 2020. After completing my graduation, I did a one-year fellowship and later began my service obligation,” said a senior resident at the Regional Institute of Ophthalmology (RIO), Calcutta Medical College. The ophthalmologist earns a fixed Rs 70000, without any additional perks, housing allowance, or health insurance.

The ophthalmologist, whose father is a renowned paediatrician, plans to open a clinic soon, so he is not seeking other jobs, either in government or the private medical sector. His sister, a microbiologist working in a government hospital, has done her MD and, after seven years of service, earns Rs 1,04,000.

“For the lower salary, the state government justifies it by allowing private practice for doctors. But like central jobs, if the state offered a better pay, 30 to 40 per cent of doctors would leave private practice because it carries huge risks. There’s a luck factor involved, along with the expenses of setting up an office. Clinics are not ideal places to treat patients,” noted the state government doctor.

bengal health sector doctors brain drain medical protest
A torch relay was organized by protesting doctors for the justice in RG kar case on September 20th. Several concerned citizens and activists participated in it | Courtesy: Mahasweta Samajdar/Facebook

Comparative Salary in Jharkhand and Bengal’s DA Case

In neighbouring Jharkhand, doctors receive higher salaries than their Bengal counterparts and are allowed to engage in private practice.

“The West Bengal doctors’ DA case is pending in the Supreme Court. We won the case in the High Court, but the state government appealed to the Apex Court. You can imagine that when the DA case is still unresolved, how we can fight for the implementation of the seventh pay commission in the state?” he reasoned.

State government doctors do benefit from the Old Pension Scheme (OPS), while central employees are required to opt for the New Pension Scheme (NPS).

Stories of Two Colleagues Working in Bengal’s Health Department

A cardiovascular and thoracic surgeon, performing complicated surgeries in private setups, expressed frustration at not being allowed to conduct surgeries in medical colleges. “I’m from North Bengal Medical College, currently on deputation at a medical college in Kolkata. When I ask to perform surgeries, I’m threatened of being sent back to North Bengal,” said the surgeon.

One of the demands of the 43-day-long protest by junior doctors was to address the work culture in North Bengal medical colleges, but this went unheard.

“A colleague of mine, who completed MCH from AIIMS is having to work in Bengal because of his parents. He is also facing difficulties in the current scenario,” the doctor lamented, adding that both of them are reconsidering their service in government hospitals.

Health of the Bengal Health Department

West Bengal has 23 government medical colleges and 8 private colleges. Every year, 3,900 doctors (3,600 from government institutions and 1,300 from private colleges) graduate.

Most of the doctors taking up government jobs are opting for Health Services over academic roles due to shorter duty hours in the former.

One of the best steps taken in the last decade in Bengal’s health sector was the development of Super Specialty Hospitals in every block. At least 43such units have been built. However, these facilities lack critical resources and are not serving their intended purpose.

There has been no recruitment of resident doctors since 2020, with lateral entries taking place in 2023. Additionally, there has been no recruitment in dental colleges since 2016.

Since TMC came to power, Mamata Banerjee has held the health portfolio. Previously, Dr Surja Kanta Mishra served as the health minister during the Left Front era.

Protest Leader and Medical Officer Prescribes Remedies for Bengal’s Ailing Medical Sector 

Accepting that there is a brain drain of doctors from Bengal, Dr Sourav Bhakat, Ex student of RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, who also led the 43-day protest of junior doctors after the rape and murder of a trainee doctor in RG Kar told eNewsroom, “In my batch of 2022, almost thirty percent went outside. And now, more students are opting for DNB courses instead of MD.”

The Diplomate of National Board (DNB) is a postgraduate degree in medicine awarded by the National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences (NBEMS) under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India.

Dr Sourav, who is also a medical officer with GoB further said, “Not only the salary is less in Bengal in comparison to Delhi and Mumbai, but here it is also mandatory, which is not there in many states.”

The young doctor also reasoned why issues of salary and long work hours were not among their demands in the recently ended protest. “We did not ask for the raise in salary, as the people will say the protest is going on for salary enhancement. And as we have the habit of working continuously for 36 hours, we have added other important issues.”

But then how do you feel, things will improve in Bengal?

The young doctor has prescribed a remedy too to repair the broken system, “To change the system, senior doctors, who are in official positions need to correct themselves. They should be neutral. If a professor or senior doctor does not obey the wrong orders in fear of transfers, the threat culture will be weakened. The officials should not be nominated but elected. Today all are saying we need justice, but it will go in vain if the system within our colleges and hospitals does not change.”

Heroes of the People: Swara Bhaskar and Kunal Kamra Call Out India’s Judiciary and Police

0

New Delhi: When Dipankar Bhattacharya, CPI (ML)’s national general secretary, called political prisoners the true heroes in the struggle for democracy on Tuesday in Delhi, he pointed out the handful of people with the courage to stand up in the world’s largest democracy. While it is true that all the political prisoners, who are charged under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA), whether for CAA-NRC related protests, Bhima-Koregaon violence cases, or IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt, are heroes in New India, few others are outside and raising their voices for them, like actor Swara Bhaskar and stand-up comedian Kunal Kamra. Both remain targets of right-wing trolls and face attacks from governments, their films and shows being canceled, but their voices are becoming stronger, especially Swara’s.

The two concerned citizens—Swara and Kunal—spoke their hearts out on the (in)justices of the judiciary and the (non) policing of Indian police at the Association for Protection of Civil Rights (APCR)’s public conference ‘Curtailed Freedoms: A Travesty of Justice,’ demanding the release of political prisoners who have been incarcerated for more than four years for protesting against the draconian Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019.

Personal Accounts and Injustices Highlighted by Families of Incarcerated Activists

Several Muslim student leaders and activists were arrested in the aftermath of these demonstrations, allegedly in connection with the Northeast Delhi riots of February 2020. Eighteen prominent individuals involved in the protests were charged under the UAPA in what has been widely observed as a targeted crackdown on protests.

On Tuesday, activists, leaders, and concerned citizens came together to mark four years since the imprisonment of student leader Dr Umar Khalid, demanding an end to his unlawful incarceration.

swara bhaskar kunal kamra umar khalid judiciary police
The speakers- Hartosh Singh Bal, Kunal Kamra, Sanjay Rajoura, Sawra Bhaksar, Farzana Yasmeen, Nargis Saifi at APCR’s conference on September 17 | Courtesy: NadeemKhan/Facebook

Swara Bhaskar’s Fiery Critique of Indian Judiciary

The Supreme Court of India in August 2024 said, “When a case is made out for a grant of bail, the courts should not have any hesitation in granting bail. The allegations of the prosecution may be very serious. But the courts must consider the case for granting bail by the law. Bail is the rule, and jail is an exception is a settled law.”

The only individual’s case from FIR 59/2020 to have reached the Supreme Court after being adjudicated and denied bail by the Delhi High Court is Umar Khalid. His bail application was not heard 12 times throughout 2023 and 2024. Khalid ultimately withdrew his application. A Delhi High Court judge recently recused from hearing his fresh bail plea.

In her 19-minute long speech, Swara minced no words and spoke her mind on the present-day judiciary in India: “Ordinary citizens are afraid of jail, of being beaten up—Muslims, Dalits, the poor—they get beaten up anywhere in this country. People like us worry about losing work and having films or comedy shows shut down. But what are you afraid of? By the time you reach the High Courts and Supreme Court, you’re 50 or 60, your children are settled and educated in good universities, maybe even abroad. So, what do you still want? A governor’s post? A Rajya Sabha seat? You have so much, and yet, you’re not able to simply do your job.”

She continued: “Four years is a long time. Umar was arrested in 2020, and since then, we’ve seen waves of COVID come and go, yet his bail hasn’t been heard. In this time, I met my husband, we fell in love, got married, and had a daughter who’s now one. While our families have accepted us, the justice system still hasn’t. So much has changed, yet they remain imprisoned.”

She went on: “A few months ago, Umar’s bail hearing was set, but the judge recused himself, claiming he wasn’t capable of handling the case. Judges, who live comfortably with perks funded by taxpayers, must fulfill their responsibilities. Recusing from such cases feels like a betrayal to the citizens, especially when their role demands that they read the case, consult the law, and make decisions.

“The citizens of our country have been let down by many institutions entrusted with power through our democratic system, but none have failed us as profoundly as the judiciary. It’s a crying shame,” she added.

Kunal Kamra’s Hard-Hitting Address on Policing

Comedian Kunal Kamra said, “I’m here because I’m Hindu. If I were Muslim, I’d just be in a photo. That’s the truth, and I realized this back in 2016 when I had been doing comedy for a few years.” He continued by criticizing Indian policing, questioning whether the police ever actually perform their duties or simply report crimes. “If there was a conspiracy, where were you then?” he questioned.

Kunal, citing examples of his shows being canceled, narrated how the Indian police are failing in their duties. He recounted an incident in Gujarat where someone threatened to blow up the auditorium on social media. Despite receiving calls from both the hall management and the police to cancel the show, no one contacted the person who made the threat. In contrast, he noted that in the US, the police would have apprehended the individual within half an hour, and such threats would be unlikely to occur.

swara bhaskar kunal kamra umar khalid judiciary police
SQR Ilyas, Dipankar Bhattacharya, Digvijay Singh along with the female speakers | Courtesy: Nadeem Khan/Facebook

Besides hailing political prisoners as heroes, Dipankar condemned the judiciary for delaying hearings and denying bail, even when rulings are clear. The ML leader highlighted how communal violence in India frequently targets Muslims and drew attention to the misuse of draconian laws like TADA, which led to many wrongful imprisonments and deaths.

He compared the conditions in India, especially regarding political prisoners, to the oppressive situation in Gaza, criticizing the erosion of judicial independence due to political interference.

Personal Accounts of Incarcerated Activists and Their Families’ Struggles

Nargis Saifi, wife of incarcerated activist Khalid Saifi, opened the conference with a reflection on the justice system’s inconsistencies. She pointed out a recent court order stating that “bail is the rule, and jail is the exception,” questioning who the rule truly applies to. “It seems that the rule is only for those whom the system favours, like Kejriwal and Manish Sisodia. It was easy to send them to jail, and equally easy to secure their release. But no one is willing to listen to people like us whose trials haven’t progressed in over four years. Judges and courts keep changing whenever it’s time for a bail hearing. It feels like an endless wait,” she remarked.

Khalid Saifi was arrested in February 2020. His wife, who never stepped out of home alone, is relentlessly fighting for her husband’s freedom.

Agreeing with Nargis Saifi, Umar Khalid’s father, Syed Qasim Rasool Ilyas, voiced his deep frustration with the legal system and its selective application of laws. He highlighted how draconian laws like UAPA are being misused to trap ordinary citizens in endless legal battles, pointing to the repeated delays in Umar Khalid’s bail hearing. “Instead of the prosecution proving guilt, the accused have to prove their innocence under UAPA. This flips the entire justice system on its head,” he remarked. Ilyas also criticized the way fabricated cases under such laws keep individuals in jail for years without any progress in trials, even when the charges lack merit.

Shakra Begum, the mother of Gulfisha Fatima, conveyed her pain in just a few words. She shared how her daughter, who had pursued education to make something of herself, was imprisoned for simply raising her voice. With a heavy heart, she expressed, “I have full faith in the judiciary that we will get justice, but this is not right. We were illiterate. These are the consequences of educating our children. It would have been better if we had let them remain uneducated.”

She added, “Mujhe himmat nahi hai bolne ki, wahi bolti thi. Yeh kya ho gaya hai.” (I do not dare to speak; she was the one who spoke up. What has this come to?)

MBA graduate and activist Fatima wrote many notes, crafts, and poetry in letters to her friend. She has been languishing in jail since April 2020.

Supreme Court Senior Advocate Shahrukh Alam highlighted how laws like the UAPA disproportionately affect Muslims, with their names often singled out in the media and court cases. She pointed out the reluctance of political allies and civil society to directly address the discrimination faced by Muslims. Alam also criticized the selective labeling of protests, where some are seen as acts of national catharsis, while others are branded as terrorist conspiracies, questioning the criteria behind such distinctions.

Rajya Sabha MP Digvijay Singh said, “We have faith in the Constitution, but just as Hitler targeted the Jews, they have targeted Muslims from the very beginning. Anyone who speaks in favour of Muslims is labelled anti-national. This mindset is at the root of all these problems and remains a significant danger before us. The way this ideology has infiltrated every level and every field is a threat to our democracy and our Constitution. Their mask is on every face. How many of you know that the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) is an unregistered body? It has no registration, no membership, and no accounts. If someone is caught, they claim he isn’t a member. How can he be a member when there’s no membership? The same was said when Nathuram Godse was caught—he wasn’t their member. The issue is the same. This fight is long, and the way they have infiltrated every system, whether it’s the Intelligence Bureau, UPSC, judiciary, or All India Services, needs serious discussion.”

The Caravan Magazine Editor Hartosh Singh Bal said that these issues did not begin in 2014, recalling the 1984 Sikh massacre. He pointed out how Congress rewarded the policemen involved with promotions because they saw aligning with the government as its advantage. Muslim elite leaders of the Congress Party remained silent for 60-70 years in Uttar Pradesh. He questioned why it took the BJP’s rise to power for these leaders to realize the need for change. He further noted that while the Congress has now started addressing Sikhs by name, they have yet to explicitly mention ‘Muslims’ in their discourse.

Satirist Sanjay Rajoura voiced his deep disappointment over the imprisonment of intellectuals in India. He argued that if justice had been served after the 1984 Sikh riots, the violence in Gujarat in 2002 could have been avoided.

Farzana Yasmeen, sister of Meeran Haider, reflected on her brother’s five years of imprisonment, stating that he is behind bars because he stood up for the people’s rights. She shared how Meeran always found joy in the unity of those who raised their voices for his freedom.

Student leader and RJD Youth President of Delhi Meeran Haider was arrested in April 2020. His party has yet to take a stand for him.

Noorjahan, the mother of Athar Khan, described her son’s four-year struggle in jail, noting the 62 hearings in the High Court, all resulting in rejection. She expressed frustration over being denied video calls with Athar, who was unjustly punished for a hunger strike he never participated in. Noorjahan questioned whether the police officials who charged her son under UAPA would ever be held accountable.

Young Athar Khan was also arrested from Chand Bagh by Delhi police in July 2020. Besides him, Mohammad Saleem Khan, Shifa Ur Rehman, Shadab Ahmed, and Sharjeel Imam are also in jail in the same case.

The February 2020 Northeast Delhi riots had left 53 people dead and 581 injured. The Delhi Police had arrested 2,619 people in connection with the riots. Of these, 2,094 are currently out on bail, and 172 remain lodged in jail.

Karma, Confession, and Compassion: How Religions Embrace the Power of Forgiveness

0

[dropcap]O[/dropcap]n the 8th of September this year, Jains observed Michchhāmi Dukkaḍaṃ (मिच्छामि दुक्कडम्) and 10 days later the Digambar Jains end this period with Kshamavani. This period of Paryushan is for daily fasting, inner reflection and confession — when they greet all saying: “Please forgive me with your full affection.

Jains greet their friends and relatives on these days saying “May all the evil that has been done be in vain.” It also signifies that “I am apologetic for everything if I have harmed you, knowingly or unknowingly, in any way by my action, my talk or my thought.” The phrase is an ancient Prakrit one and the Jain scholar Hemachandra gave it a symbolic etymological basis in his Yogasastra verse 3.124.

Jains insist that it is best to avoid bad karma and to clean the accounts of our deeds. The lesser the adverse balance of karma we have the less will be the damage — and we face better prospects in the next life. It should ultimately lead to salvation or liberation from this worldly life of any kind.
What do other religions do about hurt, repentance and apology?

The Bhagavad Gita teaches that forgiveness is a virtue that can heal and liberate the soul from the cycles of suffering. It asserts that when individuals choose forgiveness, they exhibit compassion and free themselves from the bonds of resentment. But Hindus have no specific occasion like the Jains — to beg for an apology, publicly.

Forgiveness is a vital Buddhist practice in both the bodhisattva and the arahant or liberation traditions – irrespective of whether or not there is repentance by the transgressor. The Buddhist practice of forgiving is basically a spiritual concern which is not founded on the premise of repentance like Jainism.

Islam teaches that Allah is Al-Ghaffur “The Oft-Forgiving”, and is the original source of all forgiveness Seeking forgiveness from Allah with repentance is a virtue. On Shab-e-Barat, a major event in the Islamic calendar, Muslims collectively worship and ask Allah to forgive their wrongdoings. The Holy Prophet had proclaimed that Allah would raise the status of whoever suffers an injury and forgive the person responsible — and take him to a higher degree and remove one of his sins.

The Jewish celebration of Yom Kippur or the Day of Atonement, the most solemn of Jewish religious holidays, is observed to expiate their sins and achieve reconciliation with God. Yom Kippur concludes the 10 days of repentance” that begin with Rosh Hashana (New Year’s Day).  The purpose of Yom Kippur is to effect individual and community purification by the practice of forgiveness of the sins of others and by sincere repentance for one’s own sins against God.

In Christian religions, the first Sunday before Lent that precedes Easter is called “Forgiveness Sunday”. It is observed more in Orthodox Churches, where each member of the community proceeds to the front of the church to ask fellow parishioners to forgive him or her. One by one, people bow to the person to say “Forgive me!” The other person responds: “God forgives. I forgive.” This is followed by extending hands and the kiss of peace — until each person has asked every other person for forgiveness, and the entire church is encircling the sanctuary.

A National Forgiveness Day was also started in Vancouver, Canada, by Christians from 1994 which was later named as the Global Forgiveness Day, fixed on July 7th. The main motto of the day was to forgive and to be forgiven.

In 2019, UNESCO recognised the Celestinian Forgiveness celebration in L’Aquila, Italy as an Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity. The annual ritual was inspired by Pope Celestine V, who issued a historical ‘Bull’ (order) in 1294 — as an act of partnership among different communities in Italy’s city and province of L’Aquila. The local communities undertake a ‘Forgiveness Walk’, with the lighting of the ‘Fire of Morrone’, accompanied by processions with drums, clarions and flag bearers — in true medieval style.

The traditional values of the celebration are forgiveness, hospitality, solidarity and peace are transmitted through tales told at home, in schools and in families. It is close to the community bonding festival of the Jains but while UNESCO has given international honour to the Italian Festival, our Jain ritual, which is much older, remains unrecognised.

संथाल परगना में बांग्लादेशी घुसपैठ के अपने ही आरोप को भाजपा ने अदालत में नकारा