Had Netaji, Gandhi Ji been alive, they would have not supported CAA- Grandson of Subhas Chandra Bose

0

Kolkata: Grandnephew of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, Chandra Kumar Bose has again raised some uncomfortable questions for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The Bengal BJP vice president claimed that had Netaji been alive, he would not have supported Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), nor would Mahatma Gandhi.

He also said that Narendra Modi government’s tagline Sabka Sath, Sabka Vikash  would remain incomplete without Muslims, for without them, how could it be Sabka Sath?, Netaji’s kin questioned.

Neither Netaji nor Gandhi would have supported CAA

Talking to eNewsroom, Bose said that even Mahatma Gandhi along with Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose didn’t allow religion over politics.

“Netaji was a spiritual person, his spiritual guru was Swami Vivekananda. He was a staunch Hindu, but never used religious symbols for political purposes. He always believed in being an Indian, which is above every religion. Even Mahatma Gandhi believed in giving shelter to persecuted people from both East and West Pakistan. ” said Bose adding that if CAA and NRC are implemented then lakhs of people would become homeless.

He further said, “Neither Netaji nor Gandhi Ji would have supported CAA.”

“It’s good to identify illegal immigrants, but that should not be on religious lines and in the process of such finding, several legal citizens even from the minority community will be homeless. Muslims have always been a marginalized community. Muslims also have the right to stay here, as India has always been secular country. Even minorities have voted  for the BJP to come back to power and this gesture should be respected,” said Bengal BJP vice-president.

Asked about possibility of NRC in Bengal to which the BJP vice-president said that now it is clear that implementation of NRC will not be a cake walk in Bengal.

“It is not just the political parties but the general public organisation in Bengal that are holding protest everyday against CAA and NRC. Students’ movement has started and several colleges where there is no student union are also taking part in the protest. Such students’ protest is a warning bell for any government. The saffron camp should respond to the common people. The Muslims have contributed in Gujarat for the BJP to form government and similarly Muslim votes are very much needed for the BJP to form the next state government in Bengal,” mentioned the 60-year-old leader.

Jinnah was secular leader

Chandra Bose reiterated that Mohhamad Ali Jinnah a ‘secular leader’, Bose said that even Jinnah was not in favour of partition of the country on religious lines and also mentioned that the partition happened due to ‘communal leader’ in the Congress regime.

“Till 1940 Jinnah never wanted Pakistan, but as he was completely alienated by the Congress leadership and realised that he can never share power in India, he raised the Pakistan issue in the Lahore Conference in 1940,” said Bose, who is penning down a book, Relevance of Bose Brothers in 21st Century.

BJP should follow Atal Bihari and not Shyama Prasad in Bengal

Suggesting that the saffron camp can only form the government in Bengal if they follow the path of Swami Vivekananda and Subhas Chandra Bose, the BJP state vice president said, “BJP was formed under the leadership of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and not Dr Shyama Prasad Mookerjee. Utilising -Dr Mookerjee’s name as founder would not help the Party connect with the people of Bengal or the rest of the country. Vajpayee and Narendra Modi are much more popular among Bengalis and the nation today than Dr Mookherjee. I think the Party should follow the path of Swami Vivekananda and Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose in West Bengal and emerge as an inclusive alternative to TMC.”

However, Bose, who is very critical of BJP over citizenship issue has no plan to leave the saffron brigade. “I am not going to leave the party. I have joined party on Narendra Modi’s advice, and when he will tell me to leave, then only I will.”

He added, “But Modi must control the hot heads in the party.”

Resolution passed against CAA, NRC and NPR in Bengal, but protests to continue

0

Kolkata: The dharnas against controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Register of Citizen (NRC) and National Population Register (NPR) are in place in Kolkata. The protesters are in the lookout for newer ways to make the Narendra Modi led central government hear their voices. They have vowed to not budge a ‘millimeter’ till the government is forced to do what the ‘people of India’ wants.

However, amid all, some moment of rejoice for those who have been hitting the streets, participating in sit-ins or running other campaigns to make the collective voice of India – which is against NRC, NPR and CAA, heard by the elected representatives of India.

On Monday, the West Bengal Government, headed by Mamata Banerjee passed anti-CAA resolution, demanding the repealing of the contentious Act. Banerjee, while passing the resolution, even called the act to be against “constitution and humanity’. She demanded the repealing of NPR, which according to gazette issued by the central government is all set to be executed in different parts of India from April 1, 2020. The government has asked the states to complete the exercise by September 2020.

The WB government’s move to pass a resolution against the controversial law comes after the states like Kerela, Rajasthan and Punjab passed a similar resolution.

Reacting to the resolution passed by the Mamata government, Prasenjit Bose, Convenor, Joint Forum Against NRC told eNewsroom, “This is a good move and we are glad that Mamata Banerjee has not only passed a resolution against the controversial law but has asked for CAA, NRC and NPR to be repealed. However, we will still need to observant and keep a vigil, to see if whatever has been said in the State Assembly is delivered at the ground level.” The Forum happens to be one of the most active anti-NRC/NPR/CAA group, which has been working at the grounds in Bengal ever since the final NRC list of Assam was published.

Also expressing gratitude to the state government was Professor Samirul Islam, President Bangla Sanskriti Mancha. He, however, reminded, “We are glad and thankful to our CM for passing this resolution. But we are also aware of the fact that these matters are governed by the centre.

Nevertheless, the resolution gives a message that the state is not a party with them in having these anti-human laws implemented.” He added, “We will continue mobilising the massing at the remote areas of Bengal. We are extensively working in Birbhum and Malda.

Bose, has also assured the Forum will continue to raise awareness at the ground level.

মিড-লাইফ ক্রাইসিসের ভূমিকায় জ্বলে উঠেছেন কঙ্গনা

কলকাতা: আপনার জীবনে এমন একটি সময় আসবে যখন আপনি আয়নার দিকে তাকিয়ে নিজেকে জিজ্ঞাসা করবেন ‘আপনি কি নিজেকে নিয়ে খুশি?’, ‘আপনি যা করতে পছন্দ করেন তা কি করছেন?’ বা ‘আপনার সুখ কোথায়?’

একবার আপনি আপনার কৈশোর পেরিয়ে গেলে এবং তারপরে আপনার 20 এবং আপনার 30 এর দশকের জীবনে প্রবেশ করা হঠাৎ করে এতটা আনন্দদায়ক নয় যতটা এত সময় ছিল। আপনার কিশোর বয়সে আপনি বেড়ে ওঠার সুবিধাগুলি আবিষ্কার করেন, আপনার 20-এর দশকে আপনার স্বাধীন আয়ের সাথে আপনার প্রথম ব্রাশ থাকে এবং যখন আপনি আপনার 20-এর দশকের শেষে ধূসর চুলের প্রথম ঝিক্ঝিক্মা আপনাকে জৈবিক ঘড়ির টিক টিক টিক চিহ্ন দিয়ে আশ্চর্য করে তোলে।

সুতরাং যখন আপনি 30 এর দশকের প্রথম দিকে আপনি বিয়ে করতে চান, বাচ্চাদের জন্ম দেওয়ার চেষ্টা করুন এবং একই সাথে একটি পরিবার সেট করুন। কারণ? এটা করা জিনিস! কেউ কেউ হয়তো এমনকি বুঝতে না পেরে ব্যান্ডওয়াগনের উপর ঝাঁপিয়ে পড়েন যে অন্যদের জন্য করা জিনিসটি আপনার জন্যও পুরোপুরি হয়ে যাবে কিনা!

পাঙ্গা জয়া নিগম (কঙ্গনা রানাউত) এমনই একটি চরিত্র। তিনি এমন একজন যিনি কাবাডিতে প্রাক্তন ভারতীয় অধিনায়ক ছিলেন। তার একটি সমৃদ্ধ কর্মজীবন ছিল, একটি সুন্দর সম্পর্ক যা একটি অনুপ্রেরণামূলক বিবাহের গল্পে পরিণত হয়েছিল। তার একটি বাচ্চা হওয়ার আগ পর্যন্ত, যখন তার ক্যারিয়ার টস করতে গিয়েছিল। এই সবের মাঝেই সে হয়ে ওঠে এই কর্তব্যপরায়ণ স্ত্রী, মা ও টিকিট কাউন্টারের একজন গড় রেল কর্মচারী! একদিন অবধি, যখন পরিস্থিতি বদলে যায় এবং সে সিদ্ধান্ত নেয় বাইরে গিয়ে আবার তার পুরানো আত্মকে খুঁজবে! সামান্য উপলব্ধি পুরানো স্ব ঠিক যেখানে এটি ছিল, তার মধ্যে, এখনও অতীতে বাস.

Film: Panga

Director: Ashwiny Iyer Tiwari

Cast: Kangana Ranaut, Yagya Bhasin, Jassie Gill, Richa Chadha, Neena Gupta

Rating: Four stars out of five 

পাঙ্গা পারফরম্যান্সের দিক থেকে কঙ্গনা এবং জ্যাসি দুজনেই অসাধারণ। তারা একটি সাধারণ দম্পতির চরিত্রে ঠিক পরিমাণে সাধারণতার সাথে অভিনয় করে। মীনু চরিত্রে রিচা চাড্ডা এবং জয়ার মায়ের চরিত্রে নীনা গুপ্তা সমানভাবে দর্শকদের মুগ্ধ করেছে। শো স্টিলার, যাইহোক, যজ্ঞ ভাসিন যিনি জয়ার ছেলে আদির চরিত্রে অভিনয় করেন! পাঙ্গা,অন্য যেকোন চরিত্রের তুলনায় তার কাছে সেরা লাইন এবং ডেলিভারি করার সুযোগ রয়েছে। আসলে তিনি একাধিক উপায়ে নায়ক এবং অনুঘটক!

এটি অনেক লোকের জন্য একটি অনুপ্রেরণামূলক গল্প যারা মধ্য-জীবনের সংকটে ভুগছেন। এটি দুটি আত্মার গল্প, দুই অংশীদার একে অপরের স্বপ্নের দিকে কাজ করার চেষ্টা করছে। প্রকৃতপক্ষে, সেখানে একটি দৃশ্য রয়েছে যেখানে জয়া তার কেরিয়ার তৈরিতে তার স্বামী কতটা গুরুত্বপূর্ণ ভূমিকা রেখেছেন সে সম্পর্কে কথা বলেছেন, তার মা কতটা স্বীকৃতির বাইরে বোধ করেন।

কিন্তু ‘পাঙ্গা’ ‘চাক দে’ নয়! ভারত’। এই ফিল্মটি জনপ্রিয়তা এবং দৃশ্যমানতার পরিপ্রেক্ষিতে দ্রুত হারাচ্ছে এমন কোনো বিশেষ খেলার প্রচারের বিষয়ে নয়। বরং এটি তার অতীতে একজন ব্যক্তির যাত্রা, তার অতীত থেকে টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো টুকরো অতীতকে তুলে ধরা এবং শেষ পর্যন্ত অতীতকে এত গ্ল্যামারাস বর্তমানের জন্য ছেড়ে দেওয়া। ফিল্মটি আপনার নিজের জায়গায় বসতি স্থাপন, আপনার নিজের ত্বকে প্রবেশ করা এবং এক চিমটি লবণ দিয়ে হলেও আপনার স্বপ্নের জন্য পৌঁছানোর বিষয়েও!

Kangana shines in role about mid-life crisis

0

Kolkata: There will come a time in your life when you will look into the mirror and ask yourself ‘Are you happy with yourself?’, ‘Áre you doing what you like doing?’ or ‘Where does your happiness lie?’

Once you are past your teens, and then your 20s and get into your 30s life suddenly isn’t as cheerful as it had been all this while. During your teens you discover the perks of growing up, in your 20s you have your first brush with independent income and by the time you are at the end of your 20s the first flicker of grey hair makes you wonder about the biological clock ticking away.

So by the time you are at the threshold of early 30s you want to get married, try having kids and set up a family all at the same time. Reason? It is the done thing! Some jump onto the bandwagon without perhaps even realising whether the done-thing for others will quite turn into the done-thing for you as well!

Panga’s Jaya Nigam (Kangana Ranaut) is one such character. She is someone who used to be former Indian captain at kabaddi. She had a flourishing career, a beautiful relationship which went on to become an inspiring marriage story. Till she had a baby, when her career went for a toss. In the midst of all this she becomes this dutiful wife, doting mother and an average railway employee at the ticket counter! Till one day, when things change and she decides to go out and look for her old self again! Little realising the old self is just where it was, within her, still living in the past.

Film: Panga

Director: Ashwiny Iyer Tiwari

Cast: Kangana Ranaut, Yagya Bhasin, Jassie Gill, Richa Chadha, Neena Gupta

Rating: Four stars out of five 

In terms of performance both Kangana and Jassie are superlative. They play an ordinary couple with just the right amount of ordinariness. Richa Chadda as Meenu and Neena Gupta as Jaya’s mother wow the audience in equal measure. The show stealer, however, is Yagya Bhasin who plays Adi, Jaya’s son! He has the best lines and more scope to deliver than any of the other characters. In fact he is the protagonist and catalyst in more ways than one!

It is an inspiring story for a lot of people who are suffering from a mid-life crisis. It is also a tale of two souls, two partners trying to work towards each other’s dreams. In fact, there is a scene where Jaya talks about how instrumental her husband has been in building her career, to the extent her mother feels left out of acknowledgements.

But ‘Panga’ is no ‘Chak De! India’. This film is not about promoting any particular sport that is fast losing out in terms of popularity and visibility. Rather it is an individual’s journey into her past, picking up pieces from her past and finally letting go of the past for a not-so glamorous present. The film is also about settling down into your own space, getting into your own skin and reaching out for your dreams, albeit with a pinch of salt!

President lost the opportunity to stand up as a statesman

0

[dropcap]P[/dropcap]resident Ram Nath Kovind had an opportunity to rise above humdrum politics and act as a statesman but he failed to grab it. His Republic Day eve address to the nation sounded like a rehash of the BJP leaders’ everyday speeches. He conspicuously avoided touching upon the burning issues which are agitating the entire nation. If he had only taken a cue from former President Pranab Mukherjee and hinted to the government to put on hold the issues that are threatening to put asunder the nation, he would have stood out as a statesman and saviour of the nation.

Delivering the first Sukumar Sen memorial lecture organised by the Election Commission on January 23, Mukherjee said: “The last few months have witnessed people come out on the streets in large numbers, particularly the young, to voice their views on issues, which in their opinion, are important. Their assertion and belief in the Constitution of India is particularly heartening to see… democracy thrives on listening, deliberating, discussing, arguing and even dissent. I believe the present wave of largely peaceful protests that have gripped the country shall once again enable further deepening of our democratic roots.”

Thousands of men and women, mostly youth, have for over a month been on the streets all over India in protest against ill-conceived CAA, suffering bitter cold and police atrocities. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Ajay Singh Bhist has particularly behaving like a barbarian ruler of medieval times, letting loose his uncivilised police on them. For this gangster-turned-Chief Minister, the dissent is sedition. Instead of reaching out to such a vast number of people to listen to their points of view, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah have not only adopted an obstinate attitude against them but are deepening the crisis by their provocative utterances.

Having whipped frenzy among his supporters against dissenters by branding them Pakistanis and anti-nationals, Modi may not find it easy to be seen as buckling under the pressure of domestic or foreign opposition to his actions; that is, if he does want to restore normalcy in the country. However, an advice by the President, who was chosen by him for the top post, would have provided him a way out.

If the President had hinted at the need for replacing the police danda with dialogue to evolve consensus on the ticklish issues, the government leaders were bound to listen to him. Besides, it would have opened an honourable route for the Prime Minister and the Home Minister to give up their obstinacy.

Because of their arrogance, they would not acknowledge opposition leaders views while the bitter criticism of CAA in foreign media seems to have only hardened their attitude. The things have come to such a pass that the ruling clique is not only fast alienating the vast majority of people within the country, but also losing goodwill abroad. Several politicians in the friendly countries and top ranking business tycoons have already expressed their disapproval of the citizenship legislation in varying degrees.

This would have enhanced the prestige not only of the office of President but of Modi also as he would have been seen giving up his obstinacy in deference to the wishes of the country’s highest Constitutional authority.

 

The views expressed here, are the author’s personal opinion.

Massive Human Chain formed across Kolkata to protest against CAA, NRC and NPR

0

Kolkata: The human chain  formation organised by the United Interfaith Foundation – India (UIFI) started from Goal Park in south Kolkata and ended in Shyam Bazaar five points crossing in north Kolkata, saw people of different age groups holding each other’s hand and singing the national anthem to celebrate Republic Day.

As the clock struck 12 noon, all the participants held their hands and not only sang the National Anthem but also had many participants read out the Preamble of the Indian Constitution.

Talking to eNewsroom, Ashima Ghosh, a homemaker said that she has been extremely vocal against NRC, NPR and CAA from the very beginning as she feels such bills and acts will make several Indians homeless.

“It is not easy to mark and identify illegal immigrants across the country. But in the process to do so several legal citizens will be deprived of their citizenship. It is the main reason I am always hitting the streets wherever there is a protest against NRC,” said Ghosh holding the national flag and singing the anthem at Goal Park more.

Nuns and monks of the Christian community were also seen forming the human chain at Park Circus seven point crossing near the Park Circus Maidan, where the women protesting for last two weeks and the place is being called Shaheen Bagh of Kolkata.

Sister Margaret who was chanting anti BJP slogans said that Kolkata or the city of joy is always united when it comes to oppose any changing and amending to the Constitution.

“We want to up hold the majesty of the Constitution. Today is the 70th birthday of the adoption of Republic of India. So we are celebrating the birthday by standing and holding each other’s hand who are the citizens of India,” mentioned Margaret.

Margaret claimed that the protests also reverberated in the churches during the Sunday morning prayers, as all attendees read out the Preamble together before joining the human chain.

Hundreds of black balloons with the slogans ‘No CAA, No NRC, No NPR’ and ‘BJP are fascists’ were released at Park Circus.

Usman Khan, whose wife has been protesting at Park Circus Maidan for the last 10-12 days said, “Today’s programme was led by common people. We didn’t allow any political leaders or political parties to participate in the human chain. It is our pledge to protect the Constitution. People are excited, determined to carry on the protests. We are sure that both the Prime Minister and the Union Home Minister will have to think twice before implementing such acts at least in Bengal.”

Muzaffar Ali, one of the persons actively supporting the sit-in taking place at Park Circus said that many protesters have joined the human chain today and also that once the women have come out to make their voices heard, there is no way they will head back home till the goal is achieved.

Anjana Roychowdhury, a television actress on her way back from shooting joined the human chain protest at Ballygunge Phari. She said that protests and demonstration had also made British leave the country and also that time has come when the BJP led Central Government will also have to think and re-think the repercussions if they forcefully implement the NRC in India.

“After huge protests erupted against the Rowlatt Act, the British government was forced to withdraw it. And also they were forced to leave our country after the Indians stood firm and united. We will force the present central government to do the same by our unity and confidence,” added the television actress.

They Inherit the Constitution Like a Prayer: Women and Youth Rewrite the Nation’s Soul

0

[dropcap]F[/dropcap]or some 71 years is too short a time, while for others 71 years is too long a time.

India stands at crossroads today as ‘’We the people of India” are fighting and fighting hard with what looks like a battle to reclaim the idea of nationhood. Tagore in his book ‘Nationalism’ was clear that a naturally built human society is much more humane in spirit than an artificially created nationhood.

Our Literary great Rabindra Nath Tagore probably would have been berated as an ‘anti national’considering today’s time. It’s interesting to note that in the preamble of India it is clear that the word used is ‘people’ and not ‘citizen’ in the first line. The framers of our constitution could have added this word in our preamble.

Republic Day and Democracy

“We The Members Of The Constituent Assembly”, however they were clear that it’s the people of the country that make a democracy work. In Hindustani a democracy means jamhooriyat, folkiness in English. So the vision of our country and nationhood was clearly defined by its people, the real power of the people, by the people, for the people and not an autocratic force or regime.

As I speak to some elderly people who have witnessed the partition, reminiscence the times during the partition and say that yes it was challenging to pick up the threads and sew a new independent nation, yet the country blossomed, our diversity was our strength.

The women and the youth of India have taken it upon themselves to reinstate the vision of our founding fathers, with tricolor in their hands and the nation flag painted on their faces, the love for their country is as real as the fear of losing their country.

With 31 States, 1618 languages, 6400 castes, 6 major religions, 29 major festivals we had so much to be proud of. Today these very people who are being beguiled as the Tukde Tukde Gang are the ones who are reclaiming the constitution.

The women and the youth of India have taken it upon themselves to reinstate the vision of our founding fathers, with tricolor in their hands and the nation flag painted on their faces, the love for their country is as real as the fear of losing their country.

It’s time for us to understand where that fear stems from instead of belittling that fear, just because the NRC-CAA Act would not touch you with a barge pole, is plain privilege in action. Ever wondered about the possibility of becoming stateless, stripped off one’s identity, voters id, ration card and getting disenfranchised from the rolls of a citizenship our forefathers fought so hard for?

Today BJP can go hoarse by saying that the protesters are being misled by the opposition. They also can not wash their hands off from the fact that the first time in 71 years, hate, vitriol against the minorities of the country has been given legitimacy thanks to the hate spewers and bots of the BJP IT cell, many of them happen to be elected members of the legislative assembly and the parliament, I am not even mentioning the foot soldiers of the ruling dispensation.

This brazen hatred is spread through electronic media who are serving as stooges of political establishment in power, in today’s challenging times to opine is to make oneself vulnerable to attacks – physical, mental and emotional.

It’s time to introspect then whether they are justified in asking why are the Muslims of the country feeling insecure, as no one is taking away their citizenship. We know that in times of an economic crisis, inflation, joblessness, the government of the day has a lot to answer to, the deflection point should not become the Muslims of India.

This brazen hatred is spread through electronic media who are serving as stooges of political establishment in power, in today’s challenging times to opine is to make oneself vulnerable to attacks – physical, mental and emotional.

We all in our own ways are trying to repair a broken republic, no matter the consequences, why else would people come out on the streets every day protesting against the CAA-NRC, as plain and simple its against the guidelines of the founding principles of democracy-that is discrimination based on religion.

To tell a Shaheen Khan that your name has failed to appear in the NRC for some ambiguous reason and to tell a Pooja Sharma that your name too has failed to crop up in the NRC, however you have an umbrella to protect you from the torrential rainstorm and that is the CAA because only Muslims cannot seek that umbrella is plain bigoted and divisive in nature.

Never before in our country people have risen together in outrage to dissent, as to remain silent is to be complicit in the crime.

The only community in the country that is Indian by choice are the Muslims of India who chose to make India their home, who challenged the Muslim league and the Hindu Mahasabha both, such Muslims fought heroically, some even paying with their lives. Allah Bakhsh was one such hero.

The idea of a monolithic Muslim community was belied by the idea of partition itself-a debate that led to sharp divisions amongst Muslims. Today the flag bearers of communal politics and torch bearers of the two nation theory may claim that Hindus and Muslims have shared a violent history in the past also, however it was the Indian people that arose en masse in revolt against the British rule in 1857.

The official documents of the time of revolt like government gazetteers, reports, memos, newspaper clippings, photographs have a telling narrative of Hindu Muslim unity.

One look at the rebel anthem of 1857 penned by Azimullah Khan in Urdu read Hum Haen Iss Ke Malik, Hindoostan Hamaara, Paak Watan Hae Quam Kaa, Jannat Se Bhi Pyaraa.

At the same time lets also revisit the fact that as India raises the slogan ‘Inquilab Zindabad’-literal meaning- ‘long live the revolution’ yet again in 2020 after almost a 100 years, we need to appreciate the fact that it was first raised by Urdu poet, Indian freedom fighter and the founder leader of the Indian communist party Maulana Hasrat Mohani in 1921, later popularized by Shaheed Bhagat Singh.

History is witness to the fact that the partition caused one of the greatest displacements of people in world history, this unprecedented forced transfer of population took place despite assurance by the leaders of all the parties and the British rulers that there would be no transfer of population, yet it happened, we are today standing on the edge of that precipice.

In my final note would like to iterate once again that the right to life remains afforded to all human beings, as our constitution gives those rights that are inalienable to all human beings of the world irrespective of the citizenship and that is the true essence of our preamble to the constitution.

The first and last line of our preamble is equally telling-We the People in the first line and the last line give to ourselves, we the people are beyond the citizens, we the people who have adopted and enacted the constitution that we have given to ourselves.

So its only the people who decide the citizenry and the rights, duties of the citizens of India, the relationship between the people and the citizen has to be understood. The failure to remember voices that challenged the two nation theory would be our collective failure as patriots.

History is witness to the fact that the partition caused one of the greatest displacements of people in world history, this unprecedented forced transfer of population took place despite assurance by the leaders of all the parties and the British rulers that there would be no transfer of population, yet it happened, we are today standing on the edge of that precipice.

Either we drown or we learn how to swim, the choice is ours.

Former Army Chief, now a Modi cabinet Minister, Could Not Produce Birth Certificate At SC, Same Is The Case of Half A Million People In India- Shashi Tharoor

0

Kolkata: On Day 1 of Tata Steel Kolkata Literary Meet held at Victoria Memorial Hall, Shashi Tharoor was at his charming best! Author of 19 published titles, Tharoor met all his fans, took out time to sign each of their books and shook hands with school students and college-goers alike! For a young school boy he wrote ‘I hope you are never bookless’! In short, unlike most celebrity authors he was more than willing not just to talk, but also talk back!

When asked why did he consider writing ‘An Era of Darkness’ in 2016, the very suave MP from Thiruvananthapurram said the book came out of the debate he did at Oxford Union at Oxford University where he had been invited to speak on ‘Britain owes reparations to her former colonies’. “I decided that this was an opportunity to showcase what was wrong with British colonialism in India. A few weeks later the Union posted a video of that speech on social media and my portion just went completely viral. We had three million downloads in the first 24 hours! My publisher then called me and told me to make this into a book. I was persuaded into writing the book but in so doing I did not write a narrative history but an argument,” he recalled.

He also said he was appalled by a poll conducted by an organization called YouGov in UK which said that 59% of the British youth liked the fact that the British had colonised India and would like to have India back as their colony. “This was about the time when I was finishing the book. This in many ways helped me to understand the moral urgency of the book. You won’t find 59% of the Germans saying that Hitler was a good thing to happen to the world. So clearly, the Brits had been lacking in honesty towards themselves. In India where the book struck a chord and is at risk of some immodesty, it somehow became the largest selling hardback that is not a textbook. The British edition also made it to the bestseller lists in a couple of newspapers in London. I am somewhat surprised to have been discussing it three years,” he added.

But what started off as a literary discussion quickly took shape into a political one with the audience in no mood to let go of a man so eloquent in speech and wry in humour! So when asked about the current state of Indian politics Tharoor said, “Here is a government which came to power using slogans like Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikaas and now is not even talking about any kind of vikaas anywhere. Every monarch from Chandragupta Maurya onwards had wanted to keep all of India united. If not colonised India, would have been ruled by the Marathas and the British policy of Divide and Rule might have never been implemented. There are several civilizational, geographical and local impulses to the unity of India. But sadly we see what our forefathers got rid of so many years back, this government is trying to embibe again i.e. polarise people in terms of religion which is not allowed in the Constitution.”

In his book Tharoor has said that when the British left India the country’s GDP was 3% as compared to 27% when the British first arrived in India. When asked if the present BJP government is slowly taking us back to those times where the economy was suffering more than anything else, Tharoor said the biggest blunder made by the government is demonetisation. He pointed out that the black money situation in the country was as bad as it had been. “It is a very unusual phenomenon.

Development is neither their aptitude nor their priority. Demonetisation is the stupidest economic blunder since Muhammad Bin Tuglaq in this country. We have record high unemployment level, worst in the last 46 years! There is record high farmer suicides, even as we talk there are 31 farmers committing suicide. Food prices have gone up by 100%. To top it all, we are now looking at a situation where investor involvement couldn’t be worse. Look at how they sneered at Amazon when the company expressed an interest to invest $100 billion dollars. Now this kind of mentality is clearly not a development mentality. Their agenda is Divide and Rule and their sole objective is Hindu Rashtra. The British had done their jobs quite well in implanting the minds of bigots with this policy, which even so many years after independence still manages to divide the country in terms of votes. The real tukde tukde gang in this country are the ones who are ruling us and dividing us in terms of religion.”

He then emphasised on the fact that we are at a stage where we need educated reawakening. Especially among the youth and the ones who read books, it is very important to sit up and recognise what is going on around you in the world. “We can’t have a large mass of the population who have chosen to disengage from an attempt to transform this country from what it was. What s going on is an assault on the consciousness of the nation as a whole. Should religion be the determinant of nationhood? Those who agreed to that went ahead with the idea of Pakistan. Those who didn’t came to India. So that debate should have been settled at that time,” he added.

The essential argument of making of the Constitution was a rejection of using religion as a determinant for citizenship. That was because religion assumes pre-set loyalties. “For example the British had separate electorate for Muslims, right? Now what does that mean? It means that as a Muslim your political identity has been established and as a Muslim you will vote differently from a Hindu. Ambedkar and other makers of the Constitution argued this was not correct. They wanted to create freedom for every individual in India. And that is what is being assaulted now with the CAA. And that is because it introduces religion as a determinant of citizenship in India and the absence of one religion as a disqualification of citizenship. And linking it to the NRC made it worse,” he argued.

Tharoor pointed out that one of the ministers in the Modi government, a former chief of army has gone to Supreme Court saying that his birth records in the army documents is wrong and that he does not have a birth certificate at all. The dates were entered by his uncle during his school admission and there is no documental evidence to prove his date of birth. “And that is the case with half a million people in India who don’t have accurate documents. So what are we going to do? Throw them all out,” he quipped.

As a parting note he appealed to the non-Muslims in the audience to not discriminate people on the basis of how each one stretched their hands out before god. Surely, this is not the legacy one would like to pass on to our future generations. “Swami Vivekananda, frequently cited by the BJP, said in Chicago that he was proud to belong to a nation that sheltered people from all religions and faiths persecuted in other countries. The fact now is instead of all nations and faiths, the so-called followers of Swami Vivekananda have reduced it to three nations and six faiths. Is that really the prod tradition we want to hold on to?” he signed off. By then the audience was at the edge of their seats and thunderous in applause!

Kolkata’s Shaheen Bagh to continue their protest against CAA after SC refrains from staying CAA

0

Kolkata: Aap Ladenge Na? Kiya Aap Apni Ladayi Jaari Rakhenge Jab Tak Citizenship Sanshodhan Kanoon Wapas Nahi Hota (Will you fight, right? You will continue your fight till Citizenship Amendment Act did not take back). Kya Aap Jaanti Hain Ke Kab Tak Hai Humari Ladayi? Chaar Haftey Nahi, Chaar Saal Tak – Jab Tak BJP Ki Sarkar Hai.. The speaker while raising these questions got replies in yes from a huge number of protesters (mostly women), have been sitting in at Park Circus Maidan since January 7.

Even when over hundreds of women kept sitting on the maidan floor chanting slogans, a huge number of general public chanting the national anthem, holding placards and national flags kept entering the Park Circus Maidan premise, even after 9 pm.

The enthusiasm ensuing from the crowd even after the Supreme Court of India, not to put a stay on CAA, clearly indicated that the judgment had not deterred the spirit of the protesters at Park Circus, where a large number of women are sitting-in against Narendra Modi-led BJP government’s CAA, National Register of Citizens and National Population Register (NPR) acts.

Supreme Court while hearing 144 petitions filed against CAA, NRC and NPR have given four-week time to the center to gives its reply to the petitions. However, the Apex Court refrained from putting a stay on the controversial act.

park circus women kolkata bengal shaheen bagh caa sc nrc npr
A boy carrying a candle while protesting against CAA

“We were eagerly waiting for January 22 but the SC decision of not putting a stay on CAA has disappointed us. However, this decision will not make much of a difference as we will continue with our fight to reclaim our rights,” reacted Azmat Jamil, a kidney-patient, who has played a key role in starting the sit-in at Park Circus with around 60 women on January 7.

Azmat who has undergone a kidney transplant further said, “Now you can see there are hundreds of women and men participating in this protest. Even today the enthusiasm remains the same as it was on the first day.”

park circus women kolkata bengal shaheen bagh caa sc nrc npr
This electrician has been coming to protest site everyday

Standing a few metres away from Azmat, was Md Ashraf Ali, with his bicycle adorned with anti-NRC/CAA/NPR slogans. He even wears a specially designed – NO CAA slogan around his neck, which glows at night. Speaking to eNewsroom, he said, “I have been coming here since they began the sit-in demonstration on January 7 and I shall keep coming back every day till CAA is revoked.”

In the past 15 days, like Shaheen Bagh of Delhi, several well-known leaders and social activists reached Park Circus to address the protesting ladies. On Tuesday, activist Medha Patkar addressed the protesters while on Saturday former finance minister and Congress leader P Chidambaram were present at the maidan. Earlier, Activist Yogendra Yadav too addressed the gathering.

Meanwhile, Joint Forum Against NRC, an umbrella body of civil societies in Bengal who have been protesting against the controversial law immediately after the final list of Assam NRC was issued, has started a week-long dharna in front of Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) office after the Supreme Court decision to not put a stay on controversial CAA.

City of joys turned to city of protests as PM Modi visits Kolkata

0

Kolkata: On one side Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee for the first time came together during the ongoing tussle over Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Register of Citizens (NRC), National Population Register (NPR), on the other Esplanade area of Central Kolkata witnessed sea of people from all walks of life with black flags in hand and chanting ‘Modi Go Back’ slogan.

Chanting slogans like, ‘Modi Hi Hi and Dilip Ghosh Tor Bachhur Shamal (Dilip Ghosh mind your calves)’ student of Jadavpur university burnt Modi’s effigy at Y channel crossing and sang songs in the middle of the streets criticizing the saffron camp.

Adity Dey, a second year student who was seen standing on top of a private bus holding a poster criticizing the BJP state president said that by the state head one can understand what political party BJP is and also that the dream of the saffron camp to bring a new change in 2021 election will just be a dream.

Many a time we have seen the dubious face of our Chief Minister but hopefully this time we will not have to face the same. Though she had gone to meet the PM, her stand on CAA and NRC won’t be changing. However, BJP’s stand on dividing the country on religious lines should be stopped. The Midnapore MP now, even claims that JNU student Aishe Ghosh staged a drama and the blood was actually red ink. He should be punished for making such comments, and voters should clearly show that the dream of the BJP to form state government in Bengal in 2021, remains a distant dream,” added Dey.

Dilnawad Ahmed, a protesting student claimed that not witn not just black flag, if but also cow dung cakes would be gifted by him to the PM for being adamant on NRC, NPR and CAA, if he got a chance to meet the PM. Ahmed believes that the said laws or agendas is futher dividing the country on religious line.

“BJP worships cows, so cow dung will equally be important for them. If I ever I get to meet Modi personally I will present him cow dung cakes for bringing in evil bills to divide the country more,” said Ahmed.

modi go back kolkata caa nrc protests Mamata Banerjee West Bengal
Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee

“People of a particular community worship Lord Rama but even they hate it when the name of their God is intentionally politicized to create vote banks. In Bengal the lost glory can be restored only by Bam (Left) and not by chanting fake ‘Jai Sri Ram’. So we are showing black flag to Modi and have also painted his poster black and kicked the same. He should leave Bengal at the earliest,” mentioned Mitra.

CPI (M) leader and politburo member Sujan Chakaraborty said that the the Left Fronts fight against the ‘fascist BJP government’ will not stop till the CAA is scrapped.

Anjana Mitra of CPI (ML) who along with few other Left Front workers were seen garlanding a picture of Modi with cow dung cakes and then kicking the poster of the Prime Minister alleging that the ‘anarchist’ doesn’t have place in Bengal.

“People of a particular community worships Lord Rama but even they hate it when the name of a God is intentionally gets politicized for vote bank. In Bengal the lost glory can be restored only by Bam (Left) and not by chanting fake ‘Jai Sri Ram’. So we are showing black flag to Modi and also painted his poster black and kicked the same. He should leave Bengal at the earliest,” mentioned Mitra,

Few student organization chanting ‘Azadi’ and ‘Shame Shame’ broke three barricades put up near the stage of the ruling Trinamool Congress’ Chhatra Parishad’s sit-in- demonstration at Rani Rashmoni Avenue, demanding explanation from Banerjee for meeting Modi, who they said is also instrumental behind CAA and NRC.

Apratim Mukherjee and Ramaiya Khatoon who enacted a skit depicting Modi and Banerjee tried to inform the common people through their statire that Mamata Banerjee despite her slogans against the BJP-led Central government for implementing NRC across the country, is supporting Modi and union home minister Amit Shah to have NRC implemented.

Meanwhile, Chief Minister and TMC supremo Mamata Banerjee visited the protesters at Esplanade in Kolkata and asked them to remain calm peaceful and assured everyone that she will never allow NRC in Bengal.

“The CAA notification will only be on paper and it will never be implemented. This comes a day after the Home Ministry issued a notification that the Act will come into effect from 10 January across India,” said the chief minister.

Speaking about her meeting with the Prime Minister, Banerjee said that she had informed the PM that he should reconsider NRC, NPR and CAA as the people in Bengal are not accepting it.

“PM Modi has said that he is here for certain programmes, has asked me to come for a meeting in Delhi. Come what may, I will not allow CAA, NRC and NPR to be implemented in Bengal, till I am alive. I am showing solidarity to all the protesting students and I will not let anyone to be pushed out of Bengal,” claimed the CM while she participated in the demonstration by TMCP.

Taking dig at Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Banerjee said that people from Delhi glorify themselves in the name of Swami Vivekananda, but we work on Swami Vivekanada’s ideology throughout the year.