Yesterday, I joined the protest at College Street. I went because things had reached that tipping point in my mind, and because I am tired of being just a spectator. But I also went because there was something deeply personal about this particular confrontation. I am not sure why it mattered so much to me, but it did. Without undue romanticising, it can hardly be refuted that College Street is not just another street in Calcutta. It is an institution, a state of mind, almost a declaration of what Bengal has historically stood for.
Here now, though, books are becoming the object of intimidation. It is impossible to sit and watch our right to buy and sell books becoming matters of political confrontation. Do you realise how frightening that is? Everything we took for granted is being threatened now – the food we eat, the songs we sing, what we read, whether we can read, all of it.
I have Facebook friends writing posts about how our horror about the cultural appropriation speaks of Bengali supremacist inclinations. If expressing horror at the public semi-nude gyrations by women, with their breasts being fondled by men in full public view (there are multiple verified videos) by people from out of state means that, then yes, we are a superior people. Deal with it.
It is sad to see them argue their case because they have not lived here. I do, and can say most out-of-state residents here are integrated into mainstream Bengali life far more seamlessly than anywhere else in India. Of course, the legendary Bengali laziness has something to do with this extraordinary capacity for accommodation. But whatever, we have made room for difference because difference has never seemed particularly threatening.
Calcutta is probably the only city where most of the big businesses are in the hands of Marwaris, Gujaratis and folks from other states. Our cultural heterogeneity has been our strength. People have settled, established businesses, raised families, built neighbourhoods and become part of the city’s complicated, affectionate, sometimes infuriating social fabric. The Bengalis have assimilated them, and they have assimilated Bengal, often without anyone making a grand ideological announcement about it.
But assimilation is not the same as surrender. Hospitality does not require cultural amnesia. And tolerance cannot become an invitation for organised intolerance.
College Street Bookstall Attack Raises Questions Over Freedom of Expression in Bengal
The clash between the ABVP and the SFI over bookstalls was not simply another episode of student politics. It was symptomatic of a much larger cultural assault. The November 17 attack tore down books and damaged shops, essentially branding all forms of study as anti-national.
I have no intention of romanticising the Left, or pretending that it has always been a flawless guardian of intellectual freedom. The Left has had its own history of intolerance and political excesses. But that is precisely the point. The freedom to read cannot be conditional upon whether the books are approved by the Left, the Right, the ruling party or the opposition. A society that allows one political organisation to decide which books are acceptable is a society that has begun surrendering its freedom of thought.
If Bengal does not realise what is at stake, then we probably deserve this. What is happening in Bengal today is not simply the arrival of another political ideology. It is the increasingly aggressive attempt to impose a particular cultural identity upon a society whose greatest strength has historically been its capacity to accommodate competing identities.
There is a worrying change in public vocabulary too. It is happening across the country, but I think we need to stop the suspicion of intellectual traditions that do not fit a prescribed national narrative. And we need to do it now.
From Bookshops to Food Choices, Political Intolerance Is Changing Bengal’s Cultural Landscape
It is not true that protests haven’t happened. These happened during Durga Puja too, in Jadavpur, Dum Dum, Bongaon and elsewhere. The College Street confrontation is part of that larger pattern. The cultural transformation is not happening in isolation, and it is not only about books either. It is visible in several aspects of everyday life.
Food is being turned into political statements. One after the other, we have non-vegetarian places being targeted. The idea that somebody else’s dietary preference is an affront to one’s religion or national identity is profoundly alien to Bengal’s social ethos.
We have seen attempts to turn food into a political statement. We have seen religious symbolism increasingly weaponised for political mobilisation. Durga Puja, which has historically been a remarkable expression of community participation, artistic imagination and cultural inclusiveness, has been pulled into a competitive politics of religious assertion.
The public sphere has become more aggressive, more performative and less tolerant. Just last week, there was serious bhajan-jamming (I learnt the term then, God help me) in our complex when, for 2.5 hours, some morons were singing Anup Jalota-style bhajans with the speakers blaring at least a thousand decibels louder than the rule. I went down and told them to make it less blaring. Nothing happened, except my fame as the nasty old local grump got reinforced.
None of this means that Bengal was ever a utopia. We have had political violence, intolerance, party-controlled institutions, intellectual arrogance and our own share of bigotry. We should not pretend otherwise. But there was also a recognisable social compact: you could disagree with your neighbour, read a book he disapproved of, eat something he would never touch, worship differently or not worship at all, and still share a cup of tea.
That compact is being eroded.
ABVP-SFI Clash Over Bookstalls Highlights the Growing Threat to Intellectual Freedom
We have seen this played out elsewhere before. The Nazi book burnings of May 1933 were organised events, often led by university students. More than 25,000 books deemed un-German were consigned to bonfires. Writers, intellectuals and thinkers whose ideas challenged the regime were systematically targeted.
The significance of these burnings was not merely the destruction of literature. They were public declarations about who had the authority to determine what a nation could think. It became part of a much wider programme of cultural and intellectual control.
Think about the commonalities here. In fact, even yesterday, we saw some ruling party luminaries symbolically shredding Sonia Gandhi’s book (and managing to shred a picture of Bal Thackeray in their excitement).
The answer to a book we dislike is another book, a counterargument, a discussion or a debate. It is not intimidation. We can’t just remove inconvenient political opinions.
But even in those places considered havens of free thought, the US and UK (which provided a sanctuary for Salman Rushdie when they didn’t need to), we now find controlling the imagination of an entire population becoming almost the norm. (Reference: Gaza, what else?)
Bengal will not suddenly stop being Bengali. Cultures rarely disappear overnight. The danger is that their essential characteristics will gradually be displaced until a generation grows up believing that the new normal is how things have always been.
The lesson for us is that resistance must be organised and sustained. A march can draw attention to an injustice; a functioning network of independent thought can help defeat it.
The most sobering lesson probably is that once fear enters the cultural bloodstream, its consequences invariably outlast the political circumstances that produced it.
Protests do matter. Legal interventions matter. Solidarity matters. But none of these is sufficient without a sustained public commitment to intellectual freedom. Also, College Street cannot become the property of the Left, just as it cannot become the property of the Right. A bookstall selling Marx should have the same right to exist as one selling Vivekananda, Aurobindo, Ambedkar or Savarkar.
Bengal’s Tradition of Cultural Diversity Faces a Challenge from Politics of Cultural Assertion
We need to agree that defending books must be genuinely non-partisan. We must be prepared to defend the rights of people whose politics we profoundly disagree with. Otherwise, we are merely defending our own political convenience.
I don’t really know how we can do it with the police and civic authorities having one set of rules for organisations they favour and another for those they dislike. If violence occurs, perpetrators must face the law, irrespective of political affiliation. This is a pipe dream, I know, but well, one is allowed to dream, right?
What Bengal needs to do right away – and it is the people who should do it, even under duress – is refuse to normalise intimidation.
Every time someone is threatened for expressing an opinion, every time a restaurant is targeted for its food, every time an artist is bullied for an unpopular position, we must speak up. Silence is often defended as pragmatism. People say it is not their fight, that they have families and livelihoods to protect, that somebody else will take up the cause. But a culture of intimidation survives precisely because so many people make that calculation.
This is a city that gave us the Bengal Renaissance, the reformers who challenged social orthodoxy, the poets who questioned convention, the filmmakers who made us look at humanity differently, the scientists who expanded our understanding of the world and the writers who taught us that no idea should be beyond examination.
This is the city of Vidyasagar, Vivekananda, Tagore and Nazrul, who all spoke of inclusion; of Sukanta, Satyajit Ray, Ritwik Ghatak and Mrinal Sen, who refused to make art comfortable. I have myself seen folks discuss – all very animated – Marx, Ramakrishna and Tagore in the Rabindra Sarobar area.
I am just back from a trip to Andaman where they have completely changed Port Blair into a city featuring only Savarkar. Everything was about him – from the guide explaining facts in the Cellular Jail to the light and sound show (which was technically brilliant, but), to the many statues everywhere. This must have happened sometime in the last 12 years, so we have to ensure, and we have to do it now, that our inheritance isn’t a collection of statues, slogans and carefully selected historical personalities.
There is no way we can allow a political regime to redefine Bengal’s cultural identity according to its electoral ambitions. This is not even only about the current regime but previous ones too; it just wasn’t so stark. Cultures can be hollowed out when ordinary people become accustomed to watching their freedoms being chipped away.
We do not need to pretend that every intrusion is harmless. There is a limit to being polite when politeness is mistaken for acquiescence. Bengal has never been great because everybody thought alike. It has been great because it allowed people to think differently.
If we lose that, we will have lost something infinitely more valuable than an election, a government or a political ideology.
Why Defending the Freedom to Read Must Go Beyond Left Versus Right Politics
Yesterday, standing among people protesting at College Street, I had no placard with me. Around me were people like me, with similar creaking 60- or 70-year-old bones, not even shouting for or against any party.
I was reminded that resistance need not always be dramatic. Sometimes it is simply the decision to show up. To stand beside a bookstall. To refuse to let somebody else decide what is fit to be read. To insist that a street which has belonged to readers for generations must remain a street for readers.
We have to agree that nobody has the right to take away our freedom to think.




