Kolkata: Is the controversy over religious conversion in West Bengal, raised by BJP leaders, partly rooted in old admission-related grudges against missionary schools? Joeeta Basu, a senior teacher at St Xavier’s School, made this allegation during a roundtable discussion on Religious Conversion in Secular India, organised by the Centre for Peace & Progress in Kolkata.
Basu, who co-convened the discussion with peace activist OP Shah and social activist Bimal Sharma, recalled receiving a call around two years ago from Samik Bhattacharya, now a Rajya Sabha MP and the BJP’s West Bengal president. Bhattacharya had reportedly sought her help in getting a child admitted to St Xavier’s.
Recalling the conversation, Basu said: “Two years back, I had got a call from Samik Bhattacharya, the Rajya Sabha MP and BJP Bengal state president. Bhattacharya called me regarding the admission of a child at St Xavier’s. I asked for some details about the child’s background. I do this with everyone, whether the request comes from the son of an IAS or IPS officer, because without knowing the background, we cannot pursue the case before the Father Principal.”
She alleged that Bhattacharya became angry when she sought the details and warned her that he would “see” what happens if the admission did not go through.
“He got angry and said that if the admission did not take place, he would ‘see’. Now that they are in power in Bengal, perhaps there are longstanding grudges against missionary schools,” Basu alleged.
Her remarks come days after Bhattacharya criticised Christian missionary institutions in Bengal. The Telegraph reported on November 15 that the BJP state president had alleged forcible religious conversions and threatened the closure of “any Christian missionary school” involved in what he described as “anti-India activities”.
eNewsroom reached out to Samik Bhattacharya via phone and text message for his response to the allegation, but received no reply. This report will be updated if he responds.
Basu recalls Mukul Roy’s admission request, contrasts his response
Speaking to eNewsroom after the roundtable, Basu, who frequently receives requests from people seeking school admissions, recalled another incident involving the late Mukul Roy, the former Railway Minister and Trinamool Congress leader who later joined the BJP.
“Roy had called me for the admission of a big businessman’s son. When I could not help get the boy admitted, he did not get angry. In fact, he took another person’s reference and tried to get it done,” Basu said.
She contrasted Roy’s response with her experience of dealing with Bhattacharya.
No centralised data on religious conversion
During the roundtable, Janata Dal leader Amitabh Dutta questioned claims of large-scale religious conversion, pointing out that there was no comprehensive official data to establish the extent of conversions in the country. He argued that there was no significant religious switching among Hindus and Muslims.
The Union government has previously acknowledged the absence of centralised statistics on the issue. In a Lok Sabha reply in 2015, the Ministry of Home Affairs stated that no centralised data on religious conversions was maintained.
Caste discrimination and constitutional rights trigger heated exchange
Veteran journalist Abdul Aziz argued that the Indian Constitution does not prohibit voluntary religious conversion and questioned attempts by political parties and organisations to stop conversions through coercive means.
Aziz also criticised the present government’s approach to secularism, identifying caste discrimination as a major reason behind religious conversion. Instead of trying to prevent people from changing their faith, he said, the focus should be on social reform and ending caste discrimination.
His remarks prompted an interruption from Vijay Sharma (a right leaning person), who described himself as a social activist. Both Sharma and RSS member Rajendra Raja repeatedly objected when speakers referred to the RSS and the BJP during their interventions.
Rural poverty, lack of welfare and the Ghar Wapasi debate
Former professor Purnima Mukherjee, who has visited several villages to study religious conversion in rural areas, said that while conversions were taking place, they could not all be described as forced.
“There is some conversion, but we cannot claim that all of it is forced. It has happened because people are extremely poor and government schemes and benefits have not reached them,” she said.
Her remarks shifted the discussion towards poverty and gaps in rural welfare delivery.
Advocate Rajnikant Srivastava also pointed out that Ghar Wapasi, or reconversion to Hinduism, should equally be treated as religious conversion.
Other participants at the event included Nurul Huda, Swapan Pali Roy Chowdhury, Kaushik Mitra, Dr Manabendra Naskar, Mahesh Shah, Debraj Mitra and Mukhtar Ali.
Centre for Peace & Progress stresses dialogue despite sharp exchanges
Despite sharp exchanges when speakers referred to the BJP and the RSS, the roundtable continued until its conclusion.
OP Shah, underscored the importance of bringing people with opposing ideological positions together. He said he had organised several such dialogues in the past and that disagreements were to be expected.
“It is okay to disagree with others, and that has happened in my roundtables as well. But dialogues should continue,” Shah said.




