I keep coming across posts and comments about certain “chinks” emerging from Belonging. Full disclosure: I liked the book, and I have said so publicly. I am not denying that there may be legitimate criticisms. But what is baffling is that people who confidently claim to have read the book go on to parrot such patently absurd claims.
So I decided to revisit the book and check the facts.
- That she has not written about the Mumbai attacks.
She has. In detail. Chapter 37.
- That she hasn’t revealed her father’s army background, insinuating that she was hiding his “fascist background”.
She has. In fact, in considerable detail. Chapters 1 and again in 3. She mentions his service, his unit and the campaign, along with the stories his comrades told about him.
As for his alleged “fascist background”, these pages tell us about his army service and a modest family culture built around duty. They say nothing about his political leanings. Serving in a national army during wartime is hardly the same as being an ideologue. By the same logic, can we assume that every man serving in the Indian Army wears the same political stripes?
- That she has not written about Indira’s reservations over Sanjay’s wedding to Maneka.
She has written about this too. Chapter 13. Indira certainly had reservations, primarily because Maneka was “still a minor”, the 10-year age gap was considerable and, more importantly, Sonia writes it was Maneka’s mother who was pushing Sanjay to marry her. That went against Indira’s grain.
- That she has not written about the Shah Bano case.
She has. Chapter 24.
- That her father skipped her wedding because he was a fascist.
The book has a different story to tell. Chapter 6. He was wary of his daughter leaving the country for an unknown destination, and exasperated after the Italian press laid siege to his home once they learnt of the wedding. A disciplinarian, he did not trust her decision. Yet, before she left for India, he wrote her a one-line letter: “Dear Sonia, remember that the door of this house will always be open for you, my daughter. Your father.” By the time his grandchild arrived, his tough exterior had begun to melt.
These five are enough to make the point. None of them is an issue about how she wrote about a subject. Each claims she didn’t write about it at all, but the book proves otherwise.
After reading certain posts and comments on social media, I found it hard to resist the thought that those making them had skimmed the book as though they were reading newspaper headlines, then taken to social media to criticise the author.
Now, about the real slips.
The book does have slips, and readers have spotted them.
- The RSS. The memoir dates its founding to 1921 (Chapter 24). The RSS was founded in 1925, in Nagpur.
- The Anna Hazare movement. The book places it in 2012 (Chapter 33). The movement gained prominence in 2011.
- Ahmed Patel. The memoir says he died of Covid in 2022 (Chapter 29). He died in November 2020.
There may be more such errors. Where a date is wrong, it is wrong. The editor should have caught these, and I hope later editions correct them. But look at the difference. These are errors of recollection — a year here, a year there — which can be corrected. Quite the contrary, the claims above are of another kind: an insinuation that she deliberately hid her father’s army past and the Shah Bano case. But the book reveals otherwise. Every one of those subjects is on the page.
It is not possible for any author to satisfy the preferences and expectations of hundreds of thousands of readers. A memoir this good isn’t asking readers to agree. It is asking them to listen to a story told in lucid prose. Those who can’t should simply put the book down, but not pretend they read it.




