Home Blog Page 215

Coming Soon: A Golden Period in Indian Athletics

0

The eight metre barrier of Indian athletics, which has vexed many great champion long jumpers of yore, doesn’t exist any more as far as M Sreeshankar is concerned. At the National Open Athletics Championship in Bhubaneswar on September 27, when Sreeshankar leaped to a distance of 8.20m in the long jump final to erase the national record of Ankit Sharma by a centimetre, the 19-year-old from Kerala was proving a point to himself as much as to the rest of the world.

Eight metres was a mythical “mental block” for at least four generations of Indian long jumpers who tried and failed to beat the great TC Yohannan’s mark of 8.07m set in the 1974 Asian Games in Tehran — a record that stood for 30 years till it was broken in 2004. Yohannan was the first Indian to cross eight metres, Sreeshankar is the latest and the youngest to do so. Besides the two, there are only six Indians who have crossed the mark.

Sreeshankar’s record, in fact, is the best in the world by an Under-20 athlete this season. What’s more heartening is the ease with which he jumped eight-plus metres in Bhubaneswar, not once, but twice in the final.

Sreeshankar, who missed out on the Commonwealth Games on the Gold Coast due to appendicitis, finished out of the medals in the IAAF Under-20 World Championships in Finland and the Asian Games in Jakarta-Palembang as he struggled to get back into the kind of form that took him to a personal best of 7.99m earlier in the year. He touched 7.95 in Jakarta to finish fifth, and was disappointed not at missing out on a medal, but at not achieving a benchmark he had set for himself on the continent’s grandest stage. The eight remained untouched, by the minutest of margins. Now that barrier has been breached.

Sreeshankar’s attitude exudes confidence and a desire to break out and become a global athlete, going beyond the trappings of continental medals, job promotions, presidential citations and awards. He represents the very special next generation of Indian athletes — joining the ranks of Neeraj Chopra and Hima Das — world beaters in their age group, striving to make a mark on the grandest arena of them all, the Olympic Games.

But what connects the three, beyond attitudes, is the sheer talent they possess, and the willingness to work hard on cashing in on their innate gifts.

For Sreeshankar, that would mean refining his technique. Long jump, after all, is not just about brute strength. It is about rhythm, smooth transitions and a leap that should exude a balletic grace.

The son of former triple-jump international S Murali and 800m runner KS Bijimol is a work-in-progress as of now — the father, his first coach, chipping the rough edges, and the national team coaches chiselling the finer details, taking him towards perfection. Sreeshankar changed his technique last season to include kicks after takeoff, and is already considering stints abroad to further refine his craft. Tokyo 2020 is on his mind.

The great Yohannan believes the younster is capable of touching 8.5 metres in the coming years. Anything around that distance could earn Sreeshankar a medal on the world stage. For the record, the gold in Rio Olympics was won by Jeff Henderson of the US with a leap of 8.38m.

“He is special,” Yohannan said. “He needs to build strength to increase his approach speed and so he needs to work hard on that.”

Similar words were spoken of javelin champion Neeraj Chopra a couple of seasons back when he burst onto the global scene with a gold in the Under-20 World Championships. Chopra has, since then, grown in stature with the Asian Games and Commonwealth Games gold in his kitty, and more importantly, touching 85 metres consistently in all the events he takes part in now. His gold in Jakarta came after a national record throw of 88.06m which would have earned him bronze at the 2016 Rio Olympics. Neeraj is one of the top five leading javelin throwers in the world now, and at 21, is looking at a career with infinite possibilities.

Infinite possibilities may well be the title of Hima Das’ autobiography, in the not too distant future. Till a couple of years back, Das was playing football with boys in her village.

On the athletics track she has been a revelation this season. With her gold in the junior World Championships, and subsequent performances, bettering personal bests and breaking records, the 18-year-old seems to be in the kind of hurry quarter-milers are notorious for. Indian athletics won’t complain if she keeps adding to her already unmatchable pace.

While there are many athletes coming up through the ranks in India, as of now, Neeraj, Das and Sreeshankar represent the cream that could take Indian athletics to unprecedented heights. The promise is there, the performances have laid the foundations. With barriers broken, records shattered, the future is theirs for the taking, provided the sports ecosystem in the country — the ministry, the federation and private agencies which support athletes — is ready to put forth a concerted effort and create the right channels for these athletes to grow.

Sreeshankar would have grown up wearing jerseys with the the Kerala Sports Council logo that reads, Citius, Altius, Fortius’. Words borrowed from the Olympic ideal. He embodies those Latin words today, striding alongside Chopra and Das. The ‘Faster, Higher, Stronger’ era is up ahead, ushering what could be a golden period in Indian athletics!

UP Police Shoots Apple India Executive in Lucknow

1

New Delhi: The Uttar Pradesh Police, which has been on an encounter killing spree, seems to be now training its guns on civilians in the state. In a gruesome incident on the intervening night of Friday and Saturday, an Apple executive was gunned down by two constable rank police officials in the posh Gomti Nagar extension area of Lucknow.

As per reports, 38 year old Vivek Tiwari, area manager of Apple, along with his colleague, Sana Khan, were returning home after a mobile phone launch event when the two policemen on patrol flagged his SUV, asking them to stop. Tiwari first hit the police patrol bike and then rammed a wall while allegedly trying to escape, the police said.

“Constable Prashant Chaudhary opened fire at the car on noticing “suspicious activity” and the bullet pierced through the windscreen,” Lucknow police chief Kalanidhi Naithani was quoted as saying by ANI.

The two policemen in their defence said that the shot was fired in self-defence. The constable and his colleague have been arrested, and a murder case has been registered against them.

Terming the incident as shameful for the police force, UP Additional District General (ADG) Law & Order, Anand Kumar said, “The post mortem report establishes a firearm injury from a bullet on the left side of the chin, and viscera of the victim was preserved. Thorough investigation is being conducted to establish the sequence of events. Law has been violated in this case. If the situation demanded firing of a bullet, it could have been fired at the car tyre, even then it was not right to do so. This is a shameful incident for us.”

Meanwhile, Tiwari’s wife Kalpana has written to Chief Minister Adityanath demanding a CBI inquiry into the incident. She has also demanded a compensation of Rs 1 crore and a job in the police department.

‘We had voted for BJP’

“We had voted for the BJP with a lot of trust. When Yogi Adityanath became our Chief Minister, we were so happy and this is what happens to us? Which law gave Uttar Pradesh police a right to shoot him? The cops are framing him saying he was in an inappropriate position when he was shot, but if this was so, they should have arrested him from his residence,” Kalpana told media persons.

The victim’s uncle, Tilakraj Tiwari, a former police inspector, alleged that it was a clear case of murder. “I have served as a police inspector, I know a person is never shot in the neck. Such an incident never occurred the way it has under the Yogi government,” Tiwari said.

Speaking with Newsclick, senior police officer Amitabh Thakur, said, “Whatever has happened is very wrong. There is a dire need for a basic change in the police system and police thinking. This incident is very embarrassing and directs us to learn many lessons from it.”

The UP Police has been facing a lot of flak for the rise in number of ‘encounter’ killings after the Adityanath-led BJP government came to power. According to a report in The Hindu, Since March 2017, 49 persons have been killed in over 1,100 encounters, more than 370 have been injured and over 3,300 arrested across the State.

The most recent incident that invited a lot of criticism was the state police inviting the media to witness a ‘live encounter’ in Aligarh, in which two persons were shot dead.

Bengal’s share of shame: Beggar died from hunger and not illness, claim activists

1

Kolkata: West Bengal registered its second starvation death in 2018, when 68-year-old Bimla Pandey, breathed her last in her small one-room mud hut in Tola-Lagam area of Panrua village of Purulia district, claimed a fact-finding team of social activists.

Bimla, who used to share the hut with her 43-year-old unmarried son Abir Pandey, earned their living by begging. But the duo had been unable to go out to beg for food due to incessant rain, and had starved to death on August 9.

Soon after news was highlighted, Bengal government officials claimed that Bimla had died of dysentery and not starved to death.

Contrary to the government version, a fact-finding report filed by the Right to Food (RTF) and Work Campaign, Bimla, had died of starvation and not dysentery.

Sharing the details of the case, Anuradha, a member of RTF informed, “In Bimla’s case, sadly, her caste went against her. Being from the upper caste she was unable to avail many of the government aid. This case is, thus a classic case, which asserts the need for the universality of the National Food Security Act.”

On being asked, what now? She added, “We will be adding this case to the on-going case at the Supreme Court of India, with regards to the 56 other hunger deaths that have occurred across India.”

The fact-finding report also maintained that there was a dearth of information as far as availing the benefits of the government schemes in the region is concerned. “Illiteracy and lack of awareness with regards to existing government policies, which could have easily helped Bimla’s son Abir to get a job, is also one of the reasons which actually led to her starvation death,” said Anuradha.

But government officials are firm on their stand, even after fact finding team report. Speaking to eNewsroom over the phone, Ujjwal Kumar Biswas, the newly recruited BDO of Jhalda, said, “The death had occurred much before I took on the charges of Jhalda. But from the official records that we have with us, it is very evident that the lady had died because of her ill health and not hunger.”

However the fact finding report clearly stated, “The deceased is a victim of negligence and improper implementation of NFSA, NREGA and pensions schemes. She was eating once or twice a day for a long time and was starving for a month or more. If surveys and Gram Sabhas had been done regularly and properly, then how did this family be deprived of its rights? The outreach of the administration to reach out to people who are in dire need of help seems totally inadequate.”

However, Biswas maintained, “It was dysentery and not hunger, which is responsible for her death. This lady was having dysentery and had been referred to be admitted at some other hospital in Purulia. But the family took her back to their home. Following which her condition got worse and she died. Things have changed over the years in Purulia. Now, we distribute enough food and have enough work under MNREGA for the poor. People are not starving in our state.”

Sunil Mahto, Nirman Sahayak of the Panchayat, speaking about Bimla’s death said, “We were not aware of their condition till the media reported their plight. Had we known about the same, we would have definitely helped the family.” On being asked if she had died of dysentery, he said, “The panchayat has no record stating that she died of dysentery.”

Bimla’s death is the second hunger death in the state in the year 2018. It registered its hunger death on March 24, when 63-year-old Surath Kumar Gayen of Bhatpara municipality committed suicide, stating that his disputed ration card was responsible for his death.

“We will send people to assist villagers to get their documentation and papers in place to avail the welfare scheme benefits,” added Anuradha.

On Santoshi’s death anniversary, elders narrate how Aadhaar linkage has stopped their pension

0

Ranchi: “My physically-challenged wife has not got her pension for the last four years. When we go to the bank to find out the reason, they always tell us that the money has not been credited to her account,” rued Manmase Tikri from Nagri block, Ranchi.

Duryodan Oran from Chatarpur has his own litany of complaints. “Despite filling the form for at least ten times, I didn’t get any pension. Finally, I had to submit it online twice. On top of that though I did some job for a year, still someone else took the pension.”

People like Manmase Tikri, Duryodan Oran and hundreds of senior citizens, widows, single women and differently-abled persons from different districts of Jharkhand gathered at Raj Bhavan for a public hearing organized by the Jharkhand Right to Food Campaign and Pension Parishad. They presented their testimonies before the panelists and their main demand is the right to universal social security pensions ahead of World Elderly Day on October 1.

As many as 17 lakh senior citizens, widows and differently-abled persons in Jharkhand who qualify for social security pensions, do not receive their entitlements. One important reason is that pension coverage in Jharkhand is not universal. Even those who do receive pensions face chronic selection errors and administrative glitches. In 2016-17, 3 lakh pensioners were identified as “fake”, even though many genuine and eligible persons, whose pension accounts were not linked with Aadhaar, were also excluded from the list.

The oral and written testimonies presented by the participants threw light on the havoc created by pensions. They highlighted that people who do not come under below-the-poverty line (BPL) or earn more than a measly Rs 875 a month in rural areas are not eligible for most state social pensions. Further, at least 5 cases of starvation deaths in the last one year alone in Jharkhand can be attributed to the mandatory imposition of aadhaar. In some cases, the pension amount was credited to the wrong account while in others there were aadhaar authentication failures. Further, the cumbersome application procedures, irregular and chronically delayed payments and inconvenient collection methods for measly amounts have eroded the efficacy of this lifeline.

With the rallying call of “APL BPL Band Karo, Sabko Pension, Ration Do”, the main demands were – implementation of universal pensions, removal of mandatory imposition of Aadhaar, timely payment without delays, an inflation-indexed increase in the pension amount to at least Rs 2,000 per month and reducing the eligibility age. They exhorted all political parties to include these demands in their election manifestos.

Jean Dreze, the Development Economist, who was present there as a panelist mentioned, “Pensioners have been badly let down by the central government. The central contribution to old-age pensions has stagnated at Rs 200 per month for many years. Even that measly amount is not paid regularly, despite Supreme Court orders calling for payment by the 7th of each month. A series of Aadhaar-related problems have made pension payments even more erratic.”

“Based on the Supreme court orders money should be paid on time. Due to Aadhaar there are many problems. The online process is excluding people from their rightful service. There should be an auto inclusion process as per which as soon as people attain the age of 60 years they should be given pension automatically without applications and any exclusions should be considered a serious violation of human rights,” said Balram of Right To Food.

September 28 also marks the first death anniversary of Simdega’s 11-year-old school girl Santoshi Kumari, who died of hunger. Her family’s ration-card was cancelled as it was not linked to Aadhaar. She breathed her last crying for “bhaat, bhaat”.

The occasion is particularly poignant after the Supreme Court verdict has not struck down Section 7 of the Act and therefore offers virtually no relief to the vulnerable millions who will need to provide the 12-digit biometric number to avail of government subsidies.

The campaign coincides with the National Action Day on Starvation Deaths with protests nationwide and on social media on the theme #BhookhKiBaat.

Vasundhara Raje has failed as CM, she has also ruined Rajasthan’s bhaichara: Manvendra Singh

0

Barmer/Kolkata: It took almost three days to pin Manvendra Singh down for a telephonic interview. Singh recently dropped a brick following his announcement to dissociate himself from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). In the process, he has stolen the thunder from Vasundhara Raje’s Gaurav Yatra just a few months ahead of the assembly elections. Son of BJP’s founding member Jaswant Singh, Singh doesn’t mince words while speaking about the raw deal being meted out to him and his father by a political party which had been nurtured by the family. Following are excerpts from the no-holds-barred conversation:

eNewsroom: From being an ardent supporter of BJP to saying ‘Kamal Ka Phool, Badi Bhool’, the journey must have been a difficult one for you….?

Manvendra: Well, it definitely has been a difficult decision to severe links from a party which you have served all these years through thick and thin. But sadly enough, BJP has failed to deliver on any of the promises that it made during the last assembly polls or before the general elections. Also, the slogan, Kamal ka Phool, Badi Bhool, is not actually my statement. It’s the sentiment of the common man which I realized during my Swabhimaan Yatra. The people of Rajasthan are definitely regretting having voted for a party which has failed them miserably.

eNewsroom: What about you and your father Jaswant Singh. Do you think, you people too perhaps made the wrong choice?

Manvendra: (Pauses) We definitely have been given short shrift because of certain politicians within the BJP, both at the state and national level. The way my father has been sidelined after having dedicated his entire life to this political party is quite shocking for us all. So, to be honest, the fault lines had appeared way back in 2014 but it took me around four years to take a final call. You see, it’s not easy to move away from a political party to which you have dedicated your lifetime or your prime years.

eNewsroom: Has the party been unfair to you too, like your father?

Manvendra: Yes. My decision to quit is linked with the way we have been treated. Since 2014, my father and his supporters have been continually targeted and harassed by the BJP.

eNewsroom: Why flag off a Swabhimaan yatra to announce your decision?

Manvendra: This is a battle or fight for our self-respect and there could be no better occasion to announce my decision. But let me tell you, I announced my decision only after gauging the public sentiment of my area. During this yatra, which I had flagged off about a month back, I have been interacting with the masses, who have only one slogan – Sabak Sikhana Hai (We want to teach a lesson). You see, the common man has been treated badly by the Rajasthan’s chief minister, who had made tall promises but has miserably failed to deliver.

eNewsroom: So, do you feel that Vasundhara Raje has failed to succeed as the chief minister?

Manvendra: Of course! The common man had showed a lot of confidence in her leadership. She won all the seats and see, how she has performed. Equally annoying has been her Sphinx-like silence on lynching cases in Alwar. She has not been tuned into the needs of her people. Development has been conspicuous by its absence. On the contrary, Rajasthan has been denuded of its vibrant local culture of bhaichara during her tenure.

Lynching and communal riots were not prevalent in our state. It’s not part of the Rajasthani culture. Raje’s failure to deliver on her promises and her apathy towards social fragmentation will be the cause of her downfall. And let me be clear, it’s not just the Muslims but the Hindus too are unhappy with her.

eNewsroom: Not just you, many BJP leaders have quit the party in Rajasthan. Why?

Manvendra: My dissociation with BJP is an outcome of Raje’s apathy towards me and my father. She has failed to be a leader who keeps her party members together.

eNewsroom: Do you think that the BJP has a chance to win the Assembly Elections?

Manvendra: I don’t think so. The people are looking for a change as they have seen through Raje’s rhetorical pyrotechnics.

eNewsroom: What about the Lok Sabha election next year, do you think BJP will win?

Manvendra: Well, I can’ comment much about BJP’s performance at an all India level, as I don’t travel a lot. But yes, one thing is for sure, the Modi wave is fading in the country.

Next day of launch of Ayushman Bharat by PM, a woman dies because of its procedure in Jharkhand

0

Ranchi: On September 23, Prime Minister Narendra Modi launched a major healthcare scheme, Ayushman Bharat —Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojna, which has been nicknamed as Modicare from Ranchi like famous Obamacare in the US. But Bhaktu Ravidas, a resident of Jamshedpur, 128 kms from Ranchi, had no idea that it would cause the death of his mother.

On Monday around 7 o’clock, the next morning of the launch of Ayushman Bharat, Ravidas reached AGM Hospital with his mother, Ritu Devi, an eighty-year-old lady for the treatment of diarrhoea.

But PK Sahu, the doctor on duty at AGM hospital, sent Ravidas to make Ayushman Bharat card to begin the treatment. Ravidas insisted that since his mother was having diarrhoea for 10 days, it would be better if the treatment began while he made the card. But the doctor would have none of it and asked Ravidas to get blood and urine tests of the patient also done.

Ravidas left his mother alone and went to make the card. It took him a gruelling 6 hours to get the Ayushman Bharat card made, and when he returned to the hospital, her mother had already breathed her last.

A livid and agitated Ravidas tore the card. Weeping uncontrollably, he said that it was the Ayushman Bharat which took the life of his mother.

Deputy Superintendent of AGM Hospital, Dr Nakul Choudhury said that strict action would be taken against the doctor. He said when a patient reaches the hospital, he or she should be treated first and documents can be made later. It is sheer dereliction of duty on the part of doctor as an elder woman died for lack of care.

The story has been reported at all the vernacular media’s Jamshedpur edition on September 25 including Dainik Bhaskar. However, it did not make it into any major national newspapers.

Jharkhand’s former chief minister and Jharkhand Mukhti Morcha (JMM) leader Hemant Soren, however, tweeted the incident, with the pictures of vernacular media reports.

According to National Health Profile, 2018, Jharkhand has third poor doctor: population ration (1:18518) after Bihar and Uttar Pradesh in India. While as per recommendation it should be 1:1000. But it seems it is not only the manpower and infrastructures Modi government should make available to the health and wellness centers (the new names defined for government hospitals) but it is also the responsibility of government to inculcate sensitivity among doctors on how to take care of patients.

As election approaches, saffron groups smell love jihad in Bengal’s air

0

Kolkata: West Bengal has been a focal point for the right-wing ideologues for some time now. Reports of foot soldiers of the saffron brigade making inroads into Bengal are now frequent in Bengal. The news from the right wing camp being that Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), has been distributing pamphlets in colleges of West Bengal, trying to warn Hindu girls of the dire consequences of so called love jihad, they might face if they marry a Muslim man.

To counter VHP’s campaign of creating an atmosphere of hate and fear in Kolkata, a city which till date is known for its liberal ideology, had a round table discussion organised by Al-Eman Mission, a Kolkata-based social organisation, on Saturday at the Academy of Fine Arts.

The event had people from different communities participating to come up with ideas to counter the campaign of hate in colleges of Bengal by propagating the bogey term of love jihad coined by the saffron brigade to describe the inter-faith marriage of a Muslim man with a Hindu girl. The saffron outfits, till date, have effectively used this terminology, to create a divide between the Hindu and Muslim community, in the Hindi belt to get votes in their favour. With the 2019 General Election approaching, VHP seems to be using the same strategy in Bengal, to polarise votes. In fact, at the recently concluded World Hindu Congress in Chicago, the posters of Sharmila Tagore, who had married former Indian cricket skipper Nawab Pataudi used to exhibit the case of love-jihad. Sharmila, who hails from the prestigious Tagore clan of Bengal had a love marriage with Nawab Pataudi in 1969.

Abdul Aziz, an Urdu writer and member of Milli Etayar Parishad, a social organisation, which aims at building unity and propagating communal peace, began by saying, “Where there is love, there cannot be Jihad. The two are quite opposite in nature. Love conquers all, but Jihad cannot.”

He then went on to explain the meaning of Jihad. ‘It is a struggle or fight against the enemies of Islam. How can love be an enemy?’ questioned Aziz.

However, VHP has decided to go ahead with their plan of circulating leaflets and pamphlets, which comes laden with instructions like wearing sindoor and mangalsutra and celebrating all Hindu festivals to assert one’s Hindu identity. The leaflet also has a solution for girls ‘trapped’ in an inter-faith marriage – make your husband accept Hinduism. These pamphlets are all set to be distributed across Bengal’s educational institutes. Not only that, the VHP cadres will be doing a door to door campaign to make girls wake up to the conspiracy of love-jihad. Around 35,000 cadres of Durga Vahini and 40,000 members of Bajrang Dal, both affiliated to VHP, will be a part of this campaign.

“The members of Durga Vahini and Bajrang Dal will be doing the legwork. Initially, we will start with the sensitisation programme at various educational institutes and will then move ahead with our door to door campaign. We have already flagged off this campaign in some of the districts but in a scattered way. By the end of this month, we will begin this campaign in Kolkata,” informed Sourish Mukherjee, state spokesperson of VHP. He added that his party has already prepared a list of families whose daughters have been trapped. “We will counsel the girls and the parents. We will tell them the danger of such marriages,” said Mukherjee.

The pamphlets and booklets have a detailed report on how to identify cases of ‘love-jihad’, its prevention and what needs to be done, if ‘a Hindu girl falls prey’. The pamphlet even directs families to avail counselling and to contact members of VHP or Bajrang Dal, lodge police complaints and accept these rescued girls and unite them with the rest of the families. “In Hindu families, these girls are not accepted but we counsel the family members to accept them and reintegrate them with the rest of the family,” said Mukherjee.

Speaking to eNewsroom from Port Blair, Sachindranath Sinha, VHP organising secretary for Bengal, Bihar, Orissa and Andaman Island claimed, “For the past five to six years, this has become a major issue in Bengal. Districts with higher Muslim population like North and South Dinajpur, Murshidabad, Nadia, North and South 24 Parganas such things (inter-faith marriages) are being encouraged. We are not against love or not against Muslim or Christian communities. We are against conversion. We are trying to create awareness about it,” said Sinha.

Interestingly, it is not only ‘love jihad’ issue being a common practice in Bengal a worry for VHP workers, but they see an infiltrator angle in it too.

“Infiltrators from Bangladesh are posing a problem. In Port Blair too, most of the golgappa wallas and chaat wallas are from Bangladesh. They leave their families behind in Bangladesh and marry a local girl. The demographic picture is changing fast and its socio-cultural effect can no longer be ignored,” claimed Sinha.

But, Asif Khan, chairman of El-Eman said that divisive agenda of VHP would not be as easily implemented in Bengal. “We too will begin our campaign. We will not let Bengal be converted into another UP,” said Khan. He added, “Supreme Court has decriminalised 377.  Now, men can love men and can freely move around without being harassed by police. Then why Hindus and Muslims cannot move freely. In this way, we will be moving backwards. We will not let Bengal move backwards,” added Khan.

Along with Jharkhand’s Santoshi, 55 died of hunger across India in last three years

0

Ranchi:  As many as 56 starvation deaths have been reported in the last four years in India, of which 42 deaths took place between 2017 and 2018.

And in two Indian states – Jharkhand and Uttar Pradesh (16 cases each), maximum number of hunger deaths have taken place.

A group of social activists have compiled a list of hunger deaths to mark the death anniversary of Santoshi Kumari, who had starved to death in Jharkhand last year. Her family claimed that she had died crying bhaat-bhaat (boiled rice).

The press communiqué issued by the activists stated, “This is a telling reminder of the precarious living conditions of the Indian poor.”

“In a healthy democracy, hunger deaths would make it to the headlines and become a matter of debate and action. Some of the cases reported here did receive some attention, but even those did not lead to the sort of sustained pressure that would force the government to do what it takes to prevent hunger deaths. Most of them barely made it to the ‘news ticker’ of the fast-paced breaking news,” it further read.

On the occasion of Santoshi’s death anniversary, social activists like Siraj Dutta, Reetika Khera led by Jean Dreze compiled a list of reported hunger deaths from 2015, by searching news reports related to hunger deaths on Google.

Hunger deaths mean that the victim died after prolonged hunger because there was no food or money in the house, and that, quite likely, he or she would have survived otherwise.

News reports of “starvation deaths” have been coming in a steady trickle over the past few years in India. One particularly tragic episode was that of eleven-year old Santoshi Kumari in Jharkhand. She died on September 28, 2017 begging her mother for rice as she slipped into unconsciousness. It was later learnt that her family had lost their ration card because it had not been linked with Aadhaar (in mid-2017, the Jharkhand government mass-cancelled Aadhaar-less rations cards).

“Many of them depend critically on social security pensions and the public distribution system (PDS) for their survival. Denial of PDS rations or pensions accounts for most of the hunger deaths. Most of the victims are from disadvantaged groups, e.g. Dalits, Adivasis and Muslims,” wrote the activists.

During their research the activists found out that, out of the 42 hunger deaths in 2017 and 2018, a majority (25) of the cases were related to the Aadhaar issue.

Further investigation revealed that out of these 25 cases, 18 were due to loss of one’s ration card or pension for lack of Aadhaar linking, and failure of Aadhaar-based biometric authentication (ABBA), which is compulsory in several states.While the remaining 7 deaths were due to individuals being denied PDS rations or a ration card for unspecified reasons, which are likely to be related to Aadhaar in some cases at least, mentioned the release.

In Jharkhand, ABBA is compulsory in most ration shops. Uttar Pradesh too, has implemented the National Food Security Act but in a belated and haphazard manner.

“Despite the growing evidence of the counter-productive role of ABBA in the PDS, the central government persists in its determination to make it compulsory across the country,” it added.

Year wise deaths listed in the table:

Number of reported hunger deaths Aadhaar-related deaths Aadhaar in PDS/pension?
2015 7 0 No
2016 7 2 Some states
2017 14 11 Yes
2018 28 14 Yes

 

The country will go to the dogs if an unapologetic killer is allowed to become a leader: Afrazul’s wife

0

Kolkata: As the disturbing news of Shambhulal Regar getting a ticket to contest election from Agra in Uttar Pradesh reached Malda’s Kaliachak area, Gulbahar Bibi looks visibly agitated. Bibi, the widow of Afrazul Khan, a migrant labourer from West Bengal was hacked and burnt to death in Rajasthan’s Rajasmand district by Regar last year in December, who at present is behind bars.

Regar’s unimaginable brutality had instantly catapulted him into fame as he became a sort of celebrity for the Hindutva supporters, as he justified his killing to counter ‘love-jihad’, a bogey term coined by Right wingers for inter-faith marriages. His supporters even crowdfunded to support his family’s legal battle and even took out a tableau during Ramnavami to celebrate Regar’s act.

 A criminal can’t be allowed to contest elections

Speaking to eNewsroom, a disconsolate Bibi said, “We know that my husband’s murderer was being supported by a section of people. But I had never anticipated that this person accused of murder would be given a ticket to contest the election.” After a pause, she added, “The country will go to the dogs if an unapologetic killer like him is allowed to become a leader. If he goes on to become a political leader then it will become difficult for us to get justice. I will consult a lawyer and make sure that his political ambition is nipped as early as possible after speaking to the gram panchayat.”

On being asked what she wants, she quickly replied, “We want justice. We want him to be hanged till death. As the video shows, which is one of our documentary evidences, he not only tried to instill fear in the common man but also tried to polarize the society. Under no circumstance will I allow this man to be let off so easily. We want justice and shall do our best to have him punished for his heinous crime.”

Seeking support of the intellectuals

Criticising the UP-based political party for having decided to allow Regar contest the approaching Lok Sabha elections, Tanmoy Ghosh, General Secretary of Bangla Sanskriti Manch, a Kolkata-based NGO, which had previously led several protest march, is now demanding justice for Afrazul. He said, “The news of him getting a ticket came as no surprise. He had got immense support from several Hindutva outfits. We are aware of the financial constraints of Afrazul’s family and hence will be filing a PIL soon at the Kolkata High Court, demanding him to be barred from contesting elections. We also plan to mobilize society and seek support from the intellectuals.”

He added, “If required we will approach the opposition leaders to raise this issue at the Parliament. We will definitely not let fringe elements to bring such criminals to the mainstream, as it will set a bad example for India’s democracy.”

PIL can act as a deterrent

Speaking about the legality of Regar contesting elections, Kolkata High Court lawyer, Shabnam Sultana said, “Under the Representation of People’s Act and the Indian Constitution, a criminal is barred from contesting elections. In this case, we have strong digital evidence which proves that Regar has committed a grave crime. I will be filing a PIL on behalf of Bangla Sanskriti Manch and am very hopeful of getting a stay order on his move to contest elections. If required, we shall take up the issue at the Supreme Court.”

Murder politically motivated?

On being asked if the killing of Afrazul (a hate crime) was politically motivated? Ghosh replied, “Of course, the brutal murder had a political agenda. I was shocked to hear Amit Shah boast in one of his speeches that they won the Gujarat elections despite ‘Akhlaque issue’. This definitely amounts to patronizing hate crimes. We definitely don’t expect such comments from the president of a political party.”

But does the contemplation of Regar being given a ticket to contest the election, mean that he will win the election? Political analyst Bishwanath Chakraborty said, “Mark my words, even if Regar contests the election, he will not win. The party giving him the ticket is using him to gain instant popularity. Other major political parties will be least affected by the Regar factor.”

NPA defaulter’s list: More trouble brewing for Modi government

0

More trouble may brew up for the NDA government led by Narendra Modi as the Lok Sabha elections approaches closer. Liquor baron Vijay Mallya’s case is only one of the many scandals for which the answers will be sought from the BJP.

The Rafale deal scam is already troubling the BJP. The ruling party’s harried panelists tried to see a ray of hope when Chief of Indian Air Force Air Chief Marshal B S Dhanoa observed that the Air Force was reeling under a severe shortage of fighter aircraft and the purchase of Rafale fighter aircraft would strengthen the Air Force. The Air Force Chief may have been advised by the government to come to its defence for the purchase of Rafale, as some critics of the deal have asserted. But that does not minimise the gravity of the scandal. The efficacy of the aircraft was never under dispute. It is the ‘higher’ price and the manner of the deal struck by Prime Minister Narendra Modi that is being questioned. Even Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa could not help the government spokespersons in this respect. Asked if the present deal was cheaper than the earlier one, he said that it would ‘be answered by the Ministry of Defence’.

The original deal for the purchase of 126 Rafale aircraft was abandoned by Modi in favour of the purchase of 36 aircraft. The original deal involved the outright purchase of 18 aircraft and the manufacture of the remaining 108 aircraft in India on the basis of transfer of technology. The price per aircraft in the original deal was Rs 715 crore while in Modi’s modified agreement, the price per aircraft was agreed at Rs 1670 crore. Not only that, the contract was taken away from Public Sector Undertaking HAL and awarded to Anil Ambani’s outfit ‘Reliance Defence’ which was incorporated less than a fortnight before the deal was signed by Modi and had no expertise in manufacturing defence aircraft.

Vijay Mallya’s revelation that he had met Finance Minister Arun Jaitley before leaving India seems to have rattled Jaitley. First he outrightly denied having had any meeting with Mallya; then he admitted meeting him informally at the Parliament and added that there was no formal meeting between the two. Who is Jaitley trying to fool? Does a man, running away from the law after committing a major crime, fix a formal appointment with the authority to seek his help for escaping to a safer place? Some BJP panelists came to Jaitley’s defence by alleging Mallya’s cosy relations with Congress leaders. Whatever be Mallya’s relations or dealings with Congress leaders, his escape from the country’s law was facilitated by the Modi government, presumably at the instance of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, so much so that a ‘detention’ notice was converted into a ‘just inform’ notice at the airport for Mallya.

Perhaps a greater bomb will explode when Raghuram Rajan’s list submitted to the PMO is out – and it has to surface after some time. In his deposition before a Parliamentary Committee, the former Governor of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) revealed that he had sent a list of ‘high profile cases of fraud in the banking sector’ to the PMO urging coordinated action ‘to bring at least one or two to book’. The PMO, however, did not act. Rajan had made it clear that frauds are different from normal non-performing assets (NPAs).

Rajan has not named the fraudsters nor has he specified when he sent the list to the PMO – during the UPA rule or during Modi’s regime. It can, however, be safely surmised that the list was sent to Modi and it was Modi who had scuttled any action against high profile fraudsters. Surely it could not have been Manmohan Singh. Raghuram Rajan became Governor of RBI in September 2013. In less than six months the election process had started. He did not have enough time to fully understand the functioning of the RBI, collect and collate the details of the high profile fraudsters and submit it to the PMO. Even if he did submit to Manmohan Singh as the UPA government was on its way out, he would not have time to scrutinise the list and would leave it for Modi. Moreover, had Manmohan Singh been even remotely involved with the list of high profile fraudsters, loudmouthed Modi would have mentioned it ad nauseam in his speeches in India and outside.