More than for demanding representation in Lok Sabha election, case registered by administration to show us communal

0

Ranchi: He has been sent to jail during Jai Prakash (JP) Andolan. He happens to be one of the founders of the old All Jharkhand Student Union (AJSU) which had played a pivotal role during the Jharkhand Andolan along with Surya Singh Besra and Prabhakar Tirkey. He has also been a member of the Prime Minister 15-Point’s Programme, Coordinator of Jharkhand Sadvawna Manch, and is an acquaintance of Harivans, the deputy speaker of Rajya Sabha (Upper House), whose calendar on disaster management has been released by the Jharkhand government itself.

These are the many introductions for Bashir Ahmad, a member of the Jharkhand Union of Journalists, and a resident of Hindpidi Ranchi, who has been named in the FIR for violating Election Model Code of Conduct and creating communal disturbance.

One Vijay Kumar Uraon, a Jharkhand government officer, lodged an FIR against 16 Muslims on the basis of news reports, which had reported about a meeting, where Muslims had said that they would contest election on five Lok Sabha seats, if established political parties did not field at least three candidates from their community.

“First, the meeting was not just for seeking candidates from Muslim community but to make voters understand the need to ask for hospital, school and other facilities. Secondly, we have not mentioned any other caste or religion to press our demand of Muslim candidature. And the most important, there was not a single political leader present nor any poster-banner was used during the meeting. The meeting was not against anyone, but to make our community aware about our own rights,” said Ahmad while talking to eNewsroom.

But Bashir believes the issue of representation of Muslims in political parties (especially in Mahagathbandhan) is not the factor because of which the case has been registered. He feels that the administration has done so, intentionally to give the issue a communal twist.

“The FIR says that we have tried to disturb communal harmony, how is that possible when we do not mention any caste or religion during the meeting? But it is the FIR, filed by the administration the entire episode has been given a communal twist,” added Bashir.

Significantly, on condition of anonymity, a JMM leader after going through eNewsroom’s report on the FIR filed against 16 Muslims in Ranchi, reacted, “We have never ran away from having minority representation in our party. The only thing that we at present want to keep in mind is the time, when and how it can be managed. This 2019 election is completely different from all the other elections that have taken place in the history of Indian democracy, so we wish that the people from minority community will react to our strategies as it will benefit the parties who have the sole agenda of causing harm to them.”

Meanwhile, it has been reported that the Ranchi administration had lodged a similar case against a section of the Brahman community, who had organised a meeting to seek their representation in the ongoing Lok Sabha election.

On the FIR against Brahaman community leaders, CPI (ML) leader Vinod Singh claimed that it has been lodged to justify the first FIR, but now Election Commission should immediately interfere and take action against the administration, which is barring people from expressing their choice.

Shhhhh… Muslims, do not ask for representation, simply be the vote bank

0

Ranchi: In India, it always been a normal practice for people belonging to different caste and religion to hold meetings and then seek representation of their candidate from various political parties. However, when 16 well-known Muslim faces from Ranchi assembled to discuss election-related issues for the ongoing Lok Sabha elections, they all were named in an FIR for violating election code of conduct and creating communal disharmony.

Interestingly, the FIR complaint has been made on the basis of news reports which was splashed post the March 14 meeting. The news papers had reported that Muslim community would independently field candidates in as many as five seats, if major political parties did not give tickets to Muslim candidate from least three Lok Sabha constituencies. The FIR has been lodged by one Vijay Kumar Uraon at Hind Pidi police station. A news website vidrohi24.com reported about it in detail.

“We had organized the meeting with the intention of spreading awareness among the Muslim community to not just become a vote bank but to ask for electoral representation. We also wanted the community to become aware of its needs and to demand for schools, colleges, hospitals and good infrastructure from the candidates seeking our votes,” stressed Dr SS Ahmad, a social activist while talking to eNewsroom. Dr Ahmad is one of the 16 people who had participated in the meeting.

“The meeting’s agenda was to demand representation from all the parties – BJP, Congress, JMM, JVM etc. But, since the so-called secular parties seek Muslim votes, so many people feel that our demands were from them only. But it was a social gathering and not political one. It has no poster-banner or anything belonging to any political party,” said social activist Nadeem Khan, another participant.

Significantly, most of the people who were present in the meeting had fought for the creation of Jharkhand as a separate state. Some of the participants were social activists and journalist.  Many participants, earlier in the past, had helped the administration in maintaining peace in Ranchi.

Bashir Ahmed, Dr SS Ahmad, Ajaz Ahmad, Nadeem Khan, Haji Imran, Raza Ansari, Lateef, Md Naushad, Abdul Ghaffar, Hafeez, Junaid, Nawab Chisti, Sonu Bhai, Imam Ahmad, and Mohammad Shahid have been accused of violating the election model code of conduct.

However, ironically the behaviour of Ranchi administration, who also echoed the view of the complaint lodged against these men. Ranchi SDO, Garima Singh said, “FIR has been filed under section 125 of RP Act against people involved for organizing a meeting at the Aman Community Hall, with the motive of creating communal disharmony during the elections.

CPI (ML) leader Vinod Singh while talking to eNewsroom said, “Election Commission should take note of this case, as there has been no violation of model code of conduct or attempt of creating communal disharmony. It is the right of every community to seek representation from political parties. In fact these days, many political parties openly take religious minority groups name during rallies to polarize votes, but very rarely any action is taken against them.”

Jadavpur University students connect Harry Potter’s magical world with present India

Kolkata: All the Potterheads from Kolkata had assembled in great strength at Jadavpur University’s Alohomora – Unlock the Magic, to relive the memories of growing up with Harry Potter. The two-day magical extravaganza organised by the muggles of JU kicked off in style at the University’s Vivekananda Hall.

Alohomoro – Day 1 began with the anchor, Kamilini Mukherjee, Student of Economic, JU, stating, “Harry Potter is much more than a childhood fantasy. It has an inherent social message, so we wanted to bring Harry Potter onto the socio-political map of India to make all the Potterheads to take charge of the society. For, if an 11-year-old Harry dared to bring about social change then we too can.”

The excitement level ran high in all those who are organizing the event. “It’s an integral part of my childhood and I am very excited about being part of the organising team for the event,” said Arup Mondal, a student of International Relations, JU.

Taking on from there was Pramit Sarkar, who beautifully evoked the spirit of Harry Potter film series by playing on the violin. The audience in the auditorium memerised by the music seemed to be teleported to the magical world of Harry and his friends.

Watch the violin performance by a JU student:

 

This was quickly followed by the screening of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, to set up the momentum for the concluding day, when a panel discussion on Institutional autonomy will take place.

With the idea of removing the disparity in the society, they even invited Nilanjan Saha, a student of English Literature, who holds a musical show between 7 to 8 pm in front of the Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture, Golpark. “Let me tell you that Musical Sandwich we sell are not sandwiches which are musical. They are the regular edible stuff you get. But what makes it tastier is the guitar performance of mine, which the buys get as a bonus. This is an attempt to create an open air platform for any artists to perform.”

Apart from the on-stage competition, two offline events – Shutters and Daily Scribe paper presentation were organised. Shutters, was a photography contest, to express what participants perceived as Magical in their daily lives.

Two short Iranian films – My Tree and One Problem Two Solutions, were also screened on the occasion. Both the films were thought provoking and had a deep social message.

Once the film screening over, it was time to test the HP quotient of the Potterheads. Quizzitch, a quiz based on the Harry Potter series had over 60 participants.

Magical world of Harry Potter recreated at Jadavpur University

0

Kolkata: The two-day Harry Potter extravaganza – Alohomora kicked off in style at Jadavpur University’s Vivekananda Hall on Tuesday. The inaugural ceremony was followed by the screening of Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix, which was followed by a quiz programme Quizzitch. However, what stole the cake were the sketches adorning the passage leading to the hall. Both the side walls came alive with tales of muggles told with a Potter-like spin. eNewsroom brings to you some of the best sketches that will portus you into the magical world of Jadavpur University’s world of Harry Potter.

 

 

From a Potterhead to a Professor Teaching Harry Potter Inspired Law Course

0

Kolkata: Shouvik Kumar Guha, 33-year-old assistant professor at Kolkata’s National University of Juridical Science (NUJS) engages in a candid conversation with eNewsroom, about his law course inspired by JK Rowling’s seven-series novel and Jadavpur University’s Alohomora event. Following are excerpts from the conversation that transpired:

eNewsroom: What made you choose Harry Potter to be part of the present curriculum in NUJS?

Shouvik: Had this course been offered a couple of decades back, I might have tried something like Star Trek or Star Wars or some other contemporary cultural phenomenon. Even now, I could have chosen something else like say, Game of Thrones! The reason I chose Potterverse is its proximity to modern-day society and the way Rowling has sought to highlight the various limitations of law and legal institutions throughout the books, albeit indirectly. We come across various problems such as the possible consequences of a government that is not democratically elected, a judiciary that is not independent, the rights of citizens being compromised without due process of law, certain sections of the society being overtly or subtly discriminated against, the media being used by the government to spread propaganda and so on.

eNewsroom: Does it have to do with the fact that you are a Potterhead yourself?

Shouvik: Well, to a certain extent. I can say that I grew up with Harry Potter. The first novel was handed over to me when I was in standard nine. Since then the bond with the book and its character has only grown stronger. I can identify certain issues of the present era which is highlighted in the novel. Hence, I chose this curriculum to be based on the Potter Series.

eNewsroom: Were you at any point influenced by the fact that Harry Potter is part of the academic curriculum in several international universities?

shhouvik kumar guha Harry Potter law course kolkata-alohomora jadavpur university
Shouvik Kumar Guha

Shouvik: It’s always reassuring to find like-minded people and existing scholarship about an idea that you have. I have sought to get in touch with the academics who have done research on similar lines and even now, am receiving a whole lot of constructive feedback and suggestions from senior academics all over the world about how to make the course better. The course is aimed to be a sub-set of Law and Literature, which is an established field of study in law.

eNewsroom: How are law and Harry Potter even related?

Shouvik: For the relationship between law and Potterverse, I cannot do justice by explaining in detail outside the classroom. I can definitely mention some of the topics that we would be covering in the course, but not limited to legal traditions and institutions in Potterverse (including role of law and rule of law in a magical society, moral choice and liberty and the role of bureaucracy in the Ministry of Magic), crimes and punishments, morality, social values, identity and class rights in Potterverse is often a depiction of the limitations rather than the utility of law, but at the same time, its creator often urges the readers, the potential future of humankind, to proceed ‘beyond the popular notions of law’ in pursuit of justice.

eNewsroom: What do you intend to achieve through this specialised course?

Shouvik: This course is very much an experiment. I hope the students may in the process gain some interesting insights into the way legal principles and justice work and ought to work, by means of allegorical references to real-world scenarios among others. Above all, I hope they can get into the spirit of creative thinking and questioning instead of staying limited by convention in their ideas of solutions to a given set of problems. That is what law and legal education are meant to achieve among other things, after all.

Harry Potter law course kolkata alohomora jadavpur university

eNewsroom: What has the response been to this course?

Shouvik: It has been great. At present, I have around 40 students enrolled in this curriculum.

eNewsroom: What now?

Shouvik: I am toying with an idea to publish a volume should a significant amount of quality original literature emerges out of this course from the students (similar attempts have been made in the West already), but that’s merely a distant thought at present. Mostly I am hoping for the usual, viz. ending up learning more from my students that they get to learn from me in the process.

eNewsroom: What’s your take on Jadavpur University’s Harry Potter event – Alohomora?

Shouvik: Alohomora is a great initiative. It actually reflects the creativity of our youths. I glad about the way they have the Harry Potter theme with the contemporary time we are living it. An event of this magnitude and serious intention punched with a high dose of creativity could only be conceptualised by the students of Jadavpur University.

Jadavpur University hosts the first Harry Potter event in Kolkata

0

Kolkata: Jadavpur University is all set to give the college goers of Kolkata the taste of the first ever Harry Potter event in the city.  Alohomora: Unlock the Magic, a two-day event for the Potterheads of the city, has been designed to indulge in fun and soak in the Pottermania.

The students of the University have an agenda, very much like Harry Potter and his friends had in J. K. Rowling’s series.

Speaking to eNewsroom, Saranya Basu, one of the JU students, who has played a pivotal role in structuring the event said, “We at JU have tried to understand the significance of Harry Potter, in today’s world or rather India. We in university, are at an age where we are almost ready to enter the realm of adulthood, just like the trio from the book. Given the present situation, as we enter the space of higher education, we are realising that the autonomy of an educational institution is crucial to impact and influence its students. When this autonomy of the institution is at stake, is making us fight for it as we understand the message sent us in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix – interference is never a policy.”

He then added, “This precisely is the inspiration behind our two-day event ALOHOMORA: Unlock the Magic.”

The event was born out of the need to analyse and express Harry Potter in the context of the endangered freedom of the educational institutions and of the people of India as a whole. They have even launched the Daily Scribe, the paper presentation event, which aims to highlight the issue of witch-burnings and witch-lynchings throughout history, and the intervention of government in the education system and its representation in the magical world as a reflection of our modern society.

Shutters, a photography competition, as part of the event aims to provide a platform to emerging photographers, as a means of expressing themselves, and what they perceive as magic. However, the event has been specifically designed to highlight the intervention of the authorities in the autonomy of an educational institution and destroying the hegemony of the political power that lies with the privileged few in the country today. Prisoner of the Azkaban will be screened to showcase the inspiration behind Alohomora.

 

Adding to that Shouvik Kumar Guha, assistant professor, National University of Juridical Sciences, who has recently introduced a law course based on Harry Potter said, “This is one of the biggest inject of high-quality creativity in the world of education. This out-of-the-box event will not just enthuse the students but will bring out the best of both the world.”

On being asked why now, he said, “This type of an event wouldn’t come from traditionalists. Creative thoughts can only come from youths. Given the fact that JU is a hub for such revolutionary concepts, it comes as no surprise that they have given a complete contemporary connect.”

On being asked about what type of events have been designed to engage the youth, Arup Mondal, from team Alohomora said, “At Jadavpur University, we believe that parley is the path to true democracy. Hence, we present two events, the W.A.S.P. – The Wizard’s Astonishingly Scintillating Parley and the Wizengamot—a simulation of a mock ministry, one that is poised to deal with the biggest threat they have faced in the recent past; the return of Voldemort. These two events take us straight to the heart of what is imperative to the ministry in the wake of the return of the Dark Lord; the absence of a consolidated leadership and how it affects a whole community.”

To add more vigour to the event, Quizzitch – quiz for the Potterheads, The Warlock’s Quest, a simulation of the eponymous Triwizard Tournament in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire and a Quidditch match for the muggle players who have been disappointed at the lack of a Hogwarts acceptance letter and a way to play the best sport in the world.

So, if you are a Potterhead, dreaming of bringing about a change in the world around you, feel free to walk into the world of magic being recreated at JU on March 19 and 20. Just remember to say Alohomora, for the magic to unlock!

Woman delivers a baby on the railway platform, doctor and TTE ask for baksheesh

0

Gaya/Ranchi: A woman gave birth to a baby in Gaya railway station in wee hours of Friday. It was around 2 am, when the railway doctor assisted the lady in the delivery. But even before the mother and child could settle, the doctor along with two Travelling Ticket Examiner (TTE)s demanded Rs 300 as baksheesh (tip).

Recounting the details was good Samaritan, Swati Narayan, who had to catch a train for Ranchi, was sleeping at the platform, when she woke up, “I saw a blanket soaked in blood following which I realized that the woman had just delivered a baby. But the parents were stunned by the demand of the doctor and the TTEs.”

She further said, “When I intervened and mentioned that it was illegal to ask money for the delivery. Then they reduced the amount to Rs 250, adding that it was needed for the certificate, as they needed to get the delivery registered.”

Swati, a Right to Food activist added, “But who are they to issue birth certificate? In fact, the mother needed to be immediately shifted to a hospital. The parents were worried a lot, as the child had not cried since birth.” While arguing with the Railway officials, Swati took photos of the TTEs and tweeted it. When they realized they were being captured, they left the place.

woman railways Gaya platform doctor samaritans
The lady doctor and the TTE who were demanding backshees at Gaya Junction

“After they left, I called the ambulance, but it did not came, so the parents along with the newborn took an auto and rushed to the nearest hospital.”

Later, Swati lodged an online FIR about the incident and also wrote to the Women Commission about the incident.

After tweeting the incident to Divisional Railway Manager (DRM)s, she came to know that one Shreenath Sah, who was travelling in the same train Ganga Damodar Express (13330) was the first one to notice the pain of the pregnant lady. Following which he had tried calling on 182 and 138, but when the calls were not attended, he had tweeted,

“@PiyushGoyal sir kindly help one pregnant lady travelling in 13330 currently and she feels too much pain … I had tried 182 and 138 but only bg responses are coming. The lady is at last bogi of Mahila compartment #emergencymedicine (sic).”

It was after his tweet, DRM Mughalsarai had arranged for a doctor to assist the lady to deliver the baby at Gaya Junction.

Meanwhile, the father, Dilip Kumar, when contacted did not want to talk about the incident, while the mother while talking to eNewsroom said, “Baby is fine.”

Will BJP’s poor bypoll performances impact on 2019 Lok Sabha Elections?

0

New Delhi: BJP president Amit Shah might have often said that losing Lok Sabha bypolls was not bigger than winning state elections but available statistics indicates a dissatisfactory trend for the ruling party ahead of General Elections 2019.

Post the historic win of the Saffron Alliance in the 2014 general elections, the performance of BJP and its alliance in the Lok Sabha bypolls over the last five years has been underwhelming. Since May 2014, BJP has seen a significant decline in getting success in Lok Sabha bypolls. The party has only managed to win only 6 seats out of the 30 seats, where bypolls held between 2014 and November 2018.

BJP received a major setback in March 2018 when it lost the losses in the by-election held in UP Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s home turf – Gorakhpur and Deputy CM Keshav Prasad Maurya’s former seat – Phulpur in Allahabad. The party also lost in Bihar’s Araria, which the RJD managed to retain.

Of all Lok Sabha seats that had witnessed bypoll post 2014, 15 were previously held by the BJP. The party has not added any new seats to its kitty and lost 9 of their seats. Of the only 6 seats that BJP has managed hold back, two of party’s wins came in 2014, the year Narendra Modi won his historic mandate, and the other two came in 2016. Between 2015 to March 2018, BJP did not win a single by-election. In 2018, party succeeded in retaining of its 2 seats – Palghar (Maharashtara) and Shimoga (Karnataka) constituencies.

In contrast, the Congress has won 6 of the Lok Sabha battles in the bypoll battle. Of these six seats, the Congress retained the Amritsar Lok Sabha seat and wrested the other 5 from the BJP’s kitty. After Congress and BJP both the parties bagging 6 seats each, All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) managed four wins each, to grab the third position.

In 2014, by-elections were held in five constituencies. All five seats were retained by the respective parties that had won them in the General Election. BJP retained Maharashtra’s Beed and Gujarat’s Vadodara, which Modi had won and vacated in 2014. The BJD retained the seat of Kandhamal in Odisha, the SP retained UP’s Mainpuri and the TRS managed to hold the seat of Medak in Andhra Pradesh.

The year 2015, however, saw a slight reversal, with BJP losing Ratlam constituency in Madhya Pradesh, to Congreess, which it won in 2014. On the other hand, the TRS held the Warangal seat while the TMC held the Bangaon seat in West Bengal.

BJP performed better in 2016, when it retained the Lakhimpur seat in Assam and the Shahdol seat in Madhya Pradesh. However, it failed to wrest TMC’s strongholds – Coochbehar and Tamluk in West Bengal. In the Tura bypoll, BJP’s Meghalaya unit chose not to contest the polls and instead, supported the NPP, which won the election.

For BJP, 2017 began on a bad note. The party lost two bypolls in Punjab. In Amritsar, the Congress managed to retain the seat while in Gurdaspur, it wrested a seat that BJP had won four times. In Kerala, too, the party lost the Malappuram Lok Sabha bypoll and in Srinagar, its ally PDP lost its seat to NC’s Farooq Abdullah.

BJP witnessed another string of losses in 2018. Of the eight seats which previously had BJP MPs, six were lost. It succeeded in retaining only 2 seats from Palghar (Maharashtara) and Shimoga (Karnataka) constituencies.

In February 2018, BJP lost the bypolls in Rajasthan’s Ajmer and Alwar, to the Congress. It also failed to defeat TMC in West Bengal’s Uluberia. Besides the losses in Gorakhpur and Phulpur, the party lost in the Araria bypoll in Bihar to the RJD.

However, other including SP, TRS, NPP, IUML and BJD have fared better and managed to retain their respective seats. TRS managed to retain the two of its seats which went for the bypolls. The best strike rate, was of TMC. Four seats from West Bengal that had TMC MPs and witnessed by-elections between 2014 and 2018 were retained by it.

The only party that seems to have failed in retaining its seat in the past five years is BJP.

Chaibasa, the bone of contention for JMM and Congress in Mahagathbandhan!

0

Ranchi: Former Union Minister Yashwant Sinha, who hails from Jharkhand, tweeted on March 11, regarding the issue plaguing the mahagatbandhan.

“BJP has given up sitting seats in Bihar and Jharkhand to have alliances. The opposition parties are not ready to compromise even on non existing seats. Good luck to them (sic).”

The situation is exactly the same in Jharkhand, where except Jharkhand Mukhti Morcha (JMM), no opposition party is in condition to make any claim. There are about fourteen Lok Sabha constituencies in Jharkhand, out of which twelve were won by BJP and the remaining two by JMM.

But now there is more than one claimant Mahagathbandhan party on many Lok Sabha seats in Jharkhand.

First of all mahagathbandhan, which has mainly four parties in it—Congress, JMM, JVM and RJD is already weak in Jharkhand. As communist parties are not part of it here, Left has not been accommodated into the mahagathbandhan even for one single seat.

So when they say, that they have formed the alliance to fight against BJP, keeping communist parties out, the claim is somewhat hallow.

Practically, CPI-ML or CPI will field candidate on two seats—Koderma and Hazaribagh, as CPI-ML has been the runner up on two consecutive times in 2009 and 2014 in Koderma while CPI had won Hazaribagh seat in 2004. Now, communist parties are under one roof, so they can impact on more than three Lok Sabha constituencies of Jharkhand.

“The major problem with two main political parties of Jharkhand —JMM and JVM is, they are fighting Lok Sabha election but trying to execute everything keeping an eye on assembly polls. Without BJP being reduced to minimum parliamentary seats in Jharkhand and dethroned from center, it will not be easy for opposition to come into power in Jharkhand,” reacted a Left leader.

Amid these, CPI’s Bhuneshwar Mahto claimed that Left parties will fight on all fourteen seats.

While Arup Chatterjee, Marxist Coordination Committee (MCC)’s MLA from Nirsa, Dhanbad told eNewsroom, “We are in wait and watch, to see what decision mahagathbandhan takes on Left parties. If they will not give us any seat, MCC will also not support their candidate in Dhanbad.”

Now coming to gathbandhan’s seat sharing understanding so, Congress claims for seven seats, left four for JMM, two for JVM and one for RJD.

Initially, JMM who is looking beyond Lok Sabha polls, was ready to give ‘big brother’ status to Congress, despite being the largest party in state, was slow to react on this seat sharing. But when they found that Chaibasa seat which has five JMM MLAs was gone to Congress, then it expressed unhappiness.

This seems to be the reason behind, as why JMM’s working president Hemant Soren did not attend Congress President Rahul Gandhi’s Ranchi rally.

There is an interesting claim by RJD too. The party which has not a single MLA in Jharkhand wants to fight on two seats. There is an understanding among gathbandhan parties to offer RJD, Chatra Lok Sabha seat, but they also want to fight from Palamu.

“We consider Congress as big brother and are ready to give them six seats, but we want Chaibasa,” said a JMM leader. He wished to be anonymous, but has also claimed that the gathbandhan is intact and that they will fight together.

Congress is in a fix, Hemant Soren and JVM chief Babulal Marandi recently met in Ranchi and left a message that they are together, if Congress is not accepting their formula, they can go ahead, leaving Congress.

“In Jharkhand, Congress, which has no MP in the state, if they fight on six seats under gathbandhan, there is chance that they can win four seats, while they may win 2, if fight independently. They are getting good share, but not listening to other allies will hamper their chance only,” said Amit Raja, a political analyst.

Ramadan will not affect voting percentage of Muslims believe commoners

Kolkata: The dates for the 2019 General Election have been announced. And not many political parties are happy with the dates allocated for West Bengal elections. Trinamool Congress minister and mayor of Kolkata Firhad Hakim was the first to raise it.

During a media interaction, he brought up the issue of Ramadan clashing with the election timings. He even alleged that Modi-led government “didn’t want the minorities to cast their votes in huge numbers” during the seven-phase election in Bengal.

With Bengal having over 31 per cent voters hailing from the Muslim community the election date seems to have become a major political issue, especially for districts like Malda and Murshidabad, where Muslims constitute about 50 per cent of the population.

Reacting on the same, Md Rafay M Siddique, convenor, Loktantrik Janata Dal, West Bengal said, “This move is a deliberate one, with the sole agenda of benefiting BJP in Bengal as it will definitely affect the Muslim turnout.” However, he went on to add, “Given the present political scenario, it is now the duty of the Muslim leadership to ensure that every single Muslim voter casts his vote. If required special arrangements for the wheelchairs etc needs to be made for those coming out to vote despite fasting in the scorching summer heat.”

AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi was also quick in reacting to Hakim’s comment. Owaisi even criticised the TMC minister for raising and unnecessary controversy and even requested politicians from politicizing Ramadan.

Reacting on the same Ghazala Yasmin, assistant professor, department of journalism and mass communication, Aliah University said, “It shouldn’t because the religious obligations of Ramadan don’t stop us from performing our worldly duty, they never have. And the present situation warrants complete participation of all sections of society including Muslims to come out and vote in unprecedented numbers to save the spirit of democracy and salvage the social and economic fabric of the country.”

On being asked if the move, as alleged by politicians was a deliberate move to restrict Muslims from voting she said, “I can’t comment whether it’s a deliberate move or not but it surely puts the onus on us to detoxify the politics of the country by casting our votes in an intelligent manner.”

Speaking along the same line was Khidderpore’s Maulana Ashraf Qasmi, he said, “We can’t accuse the election commission like this, we have faith on it and our system. We can only request them to consider doing something with regards to making voting easier for those fasting, as it would be really very hot in the month of May. We have no issue with Ramadan and election coinciding. But it’s the heat, which may create some health issue of old and the weak while waiting in cue. If some special care is taken to provide shamiana (tent) or seats for us to sit then it would be fine.”

“However, I would request every single individual to not use heat and Ramadan as an excuse to not cast their vote. We must come out in great numbers to give a clear electoral mandate to India,” he added.