The Essence of Baqri-Id

0

Most of us are aware that Eid ul Zoha or Eid-ul-Adha — also known as Baqri-Id — celebrates the unflinching faith of Prophet Abraham or Ibrahim to God. The Creator had asked him to sacrifice his son, Samuel or Ismail and the prophet thus tied up the child to the sacrificial post and raised his sword. At the very last minute, Angel Jibreel (Gabriel) called Ibrahim “O’ Ibrahim, you have fulfilled the revelations.” A lamb from heaven was miraculously placed by the Angel for prophet Ibrahim to slaughter, instead of Ismail.

Incidentally, while Muslims insist that this son was Ismail or Samuel, Jews and Christians say he was Isaac or Ishaq. Muslims worldwide celebrate Eid al Adha to commemorate both the devotion of Ibrahim and the survival of Ismail the son with a ram, which was then slaughtered. Eid-ul-Adha means the festival of sacrifice.

This Eid also marks the final day of Hajj, the holy pilgrimage to Mecca — which is another important event. The festival begins on the 10th of Dhū al-Ḥijjah, the last month of the Islamic lunar calendar and basically celebrates human bonding.

Groups and families that can afford to sacrifice a ritually acceptable animal (sheep, goat, camel, or cow) do so and then divide the flesh equally among themselves, the poor, and friends and neighbours. Eid al-Adha is also a time for visiting with friends and family and for exchanging gifts.

Depending on the country, the celebrations of Eid-ul-Adha can last anywhere between two and four days. Muslims congregate at the nearest Mosque on the morning of Eid for the Eid Salaah (Eid Prayers) which are extremely important as they convey the meaning of the ritual.

After this, the act of Qurbani (sacrifice) is carried out. The Qurbani meat can then be divided into three equal portions per share; one-third is for the family, one-third is for friends, and the final third is to be donated to those in need. This sharing and compulsory donation to the poor are really a unique features of Islam.

Muslims believe that only the righteous can cross over to heaven on the Pul-sirat, the Bridge of Death, and those who had not led a clean life would definitely fall off — into the open jaws of hell. This bridge is finer than a hair and is sharper than the edge of a sword. The larger the sacrificial animal the more it feeds, which explains why cattle (that hardly thrived in Arabia) were chosen for this Eid in the East. Crossing over the Pul-sirat became easier.

Traditionally, the day is spent celebrating with family, friends and loved ones, often wearing new clothes or the best attire one has and in giving gifts. Community bonding is indeed a great unifier of Islam.

Critics of mass scale sacrifice shudder at this bloodshed on Eid days but we may also remember that several billions of living creatures, including fish, and birds are slaughtered every day so that more than 6 out of the 7 billion humans can eat. Just because we do not see the slaughter or sully our hands with blood does not mean that they do not happen.

Ten years ago, it was estimated that in Pakistan alone nearly ten million animals are sacrificed on Eid days, costing over $2 billion. The skins of the animals are also sold or auctioned and the proceeds used for charity or common causes.

The essence of Baqri Id lies in Surah 22, Verse 37 of the Holy Quran that mentions that it is “neither their flesh nor their blood (that) reach God, but it is piety that reaches Him”.

 

This post has been taken from Jawhar Sircar’s Facebook page.

 

Has Virat Kohli dropped the ball?

After India’s defeat in the just-concluded Edgbaston Test, now people, as well as critics, have begun to ask: Has the 34-year-old former Indian captain Virat Kohli become a liability to the team? What was sacrilegious until a couple of years ago is now obvious and very much valid. In the Edgbaston test, Virat Kohli scored a pathetic 11 and 20, respectively. He hasn’t scored a hundred in more than two years. His overall scoring form has dropped considerably, and despite all his efforts, he continues to struggle for runs. Remember, Kohli has the rare distinction of being the only Indian batsman with 50 plus average in all formats of the game. But it doesn’t hold true anymore as his test average has gone down below 50.

Every successful cricketer worth his salt goes through a lean phase in his career. It has happened with the likes of Tendulkar as well. So, to single out Kohli for this rough patch may not be entirely justified. But, for some inexplicable reasons, Kohli, once a potential match-winner for India, hogged the limelight at the Edgbaston test for all the wrong reasons, and which has now become the talking point on social media and in journalistic circles. He indulged in sledging, something we haven’t seen him doing so often before. He also got into an argument with one of the umpires for his decision to continue playing despite fading light.

In the first innings, Kohli kept sledging Bairstow (he scored centuries in both innings) just to provoke him and disturb his concentration. Then the former Indian captain blew a kiss after taking Bairstow’s catch. Perhaps, instead of his bat doing the talking, Kohli in this test match let sledging and gestures do all the talking which many believe was simply an uncalled-for display of bravado and machismo. Was this display of disruptive behaviour meant to cover up for his poor form?

Kohli, in this case, had wanted to run away with the assumption that his on-field behaviour, no matter how frivolous or juvenile it may be, would endear him to his cricket fans on social media. Nothing of that sort happened.

Last year, during the test at Lord’s, former England opener and old Kohli baiter Nick Compton came down on Kohli like a ton of bricks for his behaviour. “Isn’t Kohli the most foul-mouthed individual? I’ll never forget the barrage of abuse I received in 2012 when the swearing stunned me to the point that he did himself a serious disservice,’’ he had tweeted out.

And, despite the flow of runs having virtually dried up in the last two years, the former Indian captain seems to delude himself into believing that his place in the team, irrespective of his performance, would always be secure. In other words, no one can question either his questionable on-field behaviour or his poor run with the bat.

Last December, before the departure for the South Africa tour, Kohli set the cat among the pigeons when he refuted BCCI president Sourav Ganguly’s claims that he had asked him to not quit the T20 captaincy. Everybody sat up and took notice just because he played the perfect victim card besides throwing the gauntlet at Ganguly. And, perhaps, even Kohli knew that taking on BCCL on a sensitive issue was not a child’s play and that there would be debates and discussions galore on TV channels. It did happen with many former Indian players supporting Kohli on his stand. Again, was Kohli’s fulmination a red herring, and an attempt to deflect attention from his poor form?

In the South Africa test series, Kohli failed to fire on all cylinders. He managed to score only one half-century in the entire series. Dejected fans kept consoling themselves that this too shall pass and that he would again bounce back into reckoning by scoring runs. But Kohli is yet to prove his critics wrong even as the team continues to carry the can for his repeated failures.

More than Kohli’s flop show at Edgbaston, what would rankle with cricket lovers is his uncharacteristic on-field behaviour which is unbecoming of players of his stature. We are all fallible, and it behoves us all for this reason to be cautious. His theatrics are something the team can afford to do without. He is a senior player who needs to be an inspirational figure in the team brimming with young talent. What the team urgently needs is Virat Kohli’s return to form in this year’s ICC Men’s T20 World Cup to be held in October.

Father Stan Swamy’s work was for nation development, his death has shamed India: Father Felix Raj

Kolkata: On the first death anniversary of Father Stan Swamy, widely known as an ‘institutional murder’, the tribal rights defender was remembered in several parts of the country, including in Kolkata in West Bengal, and Ranchi and Dumka in Jharkhand. Tributes were paid and the commemorations took place through candlelight marches and memorial lectures in several places.

The eleven co-accused in the Bhima-Koregaon (Elgaar Parishad) case also observed a day-long fast at the Taloja Prison in Mumbai in protest against the death of a co-accused Jesuit priest: Stan Swamy.

In Kolkata, a silent candle march was held between Park Circus Maidan to Lady Brabourne College under the banner of Kolkata Nagarik Sammelan and Pashchim Banga Smajik Nayay Mancha. It was attended by social activists, political leaders and Jesuits.

The 84-year-old Swamy, a tribal rights activist based in Ranchi, was accused in the Bhima-Koregaon case and the National Investigative Agency (NIA) took the octogenarian to Mumbai. A Parkinson’s patient, Swamy did not even get a straw to drink for several months, despite requests. It was given to him only after a nationwide hue and cry. Later, he suffered from Covid-19 but did not get proper treatment. Only after a serious deterioration in his health did the court intervene; he was shifted to a hospital in a critical condition. He breathed his last on July 5, 2021.

When asked how did India miss the crusader, Father Felix Raj, the Vice-Chancellor of St Xavier University and a Jesuit, who was leading the candlelight protest in Kolkata told eNewsroom, “India has lost a committed Indian. An Indian who worked for tribal development, that is, for nation development. He wanted to bring marginalised people to the forefront. We have lost someone who used to make a serious analysis of grassroots problems. We have lost a Jesuit. The tragedy just cannot be accepted.”

Father Raj also said that Father Stan was a man who stood for justice, human rights and humanity. “It is our shame, India’s shame. He was treated inhumanely both in jail and outside. No one should treat any human being like that. He was treated with such inhumanity at the age of 85,” he said. “He got an international award from a Geneva group. He had become an international figure. People are still concerned and ask why did this happen to him?”

CPM leader Dr Fuad Halim, another participant in the march, told eNewsroom, “India will miss a person who was dedicated to the cause of backward classes, especially the Adivasis. India will miss a courageous person because he spoke his mind. And India will miss an investigation, an unbiased investigation — why was Father Stan Swamy arrested?”

“One has to keep in mind other factors. In a parallel case in India, you won’t find that evidence was planted in computers and laptops using the latest technology and then using intimidating evidence to prosecute innocents. This farce of an investigation is going on. Indians are waiting for the judiciary to intervene and bring clarity,” Dr Halim said.

The CPM leader pointed out, “A person who was the central voice of Adivasis has been silenced. His last days were spent in jail in a pathetic condition. The forces had it in the back of their mind that they would never be able to prosecute Father Swamy. So these important questions need to be answered, hence we are asking them today on the streets.”

A well-known activist in Kolkata, Manzar Jameel, said, “The state is turning into a Police-State, and, unfortunately, extraordinary people from different fields are behind bars in India. The government is stopping them from doing their work, not allowing and them to reach the people on the ground. India has always been a place of peace and people from different faith and culture came here and owned the country. We condemn this continuous oppression.”

Jameel added, “The most unfortunate part is that the government has made a nexus with the executive and judiciary. So honest and brave people like Umar Khalid, Siddiqui Kappan, Teesta Setalvad and Mohammed Zubair are rotting in jail on fake charges, while alleged criminals like Sadhvi Pragya, Kuldeep Senger, Sambhu Regar have not been punished.”

आर्थिक तबाही से गुज़रती दुनिया के बीच मस्त मौला बना हुआ है भारत

0

टर्की की मुद्रा लीरा जीरा हो गई है। डॉलर को सामने देखते ही कांपने लग जाती है। वहां की महंगाई ने छप्पर फाड़ने के बाद आसमान भी नहीं छोड़ा और अब अंतरिक्ष की तरफ निकल गई है। मुद्रा स्फीति की दर 80 प्रतिशत हो गई है।

इस्तांबुल राजधानी है। इसके मेयर विपक्ष के नेता हैं। वे चीख रहे हैं कि अर्दोगन ने अपने बिज़नेस मित्रों को फायदा पहुंचा रहे हैं। मुद्रा स्फीति को रोकने के लिए ब्याज़ दरों में कटौती की जा रही है ताकि उन्हें सस्ती दरों पर कर्ज़ मिल सके। मेयर एकरम इमामोगुल बिज़नेस लीडरों को ललकार रहे हैं कि जनता सड़क पर खाने-पीने की चीज़ों के लिए तरस रही है, अब तो बोलिए। मेयर एकरम कह रहे हैं कि बिज़नेस समुदाय डर गया है कि बोलने पर जांच शुरू हो जाएगी। जेल भेज दिए जाएंगे। क्या ऐसा ही आप भारत में नहीं सुनते!

बिज़नेस लीडर अब जनता के लिए नहीं बोलेंगे।भारत में भी बिज़नेस लीडर नहीं बोलेंगे, जैसे 2014 के पहले बोला करते थे। श्रीलंका इसी यारबाज़ी में डूबा। टर्की के ताकतवर अर्दोगन ने पूरे देश को अदहन की तरह खदका दिया है। आर्थिक नीतियों को समझना आसान नहीं है। दुनिया एक गिरोह की चपेट में है जो एक ही तरह की नीतियों को लागू करवा कर आम जनता को लूट रहा है। आप विकास के नाम पर फ्लाईओवर और स्टेशन की इमारत से ही मोहित हैं। ट्रेन के भीतर की हालत पर नज़र डालने का वक्त ही कहां है।

आज ही समझ लें, इसकी कोई जल्दी नहीं है, दस बीस साल का टाइम लीजिए। उसके बाद आपको यही समझना कि बिज़नेस समूहों के लिए इंसान अब मच्छर हो गया है। वो भूख और महंगाई से मरता रहे, यही उसके हित में है। मुनाफा को चंद मुट्ठियों में समेटा जाना है, तभी तो आप पढ़ते हैं कि दुनिया भर की आधी आबादी की संपत्ति के बराबर चंद लोगों के पास पूंजी और संपत्ति हो गई है।

अमरीका के एक अर्थशास्त्री ने राय दी है कि बेरोज़गारी बढ़ा दी जानी चाहिए। इससे महंगाई नहीं बढ़ेगी, जब पैसा नहीं होगा तब ख़र्च कैसे होगा। अग्निवीर दौड़ते ही रहेंगे। किसे पता चलेगा कि कौन क्या कह रहा है। आप उस अर्थशास्त्री की बात पर हंसेंगे। उसे मूर्ख कहेंगे। मूर्ख आप हैं। ऐसी बातें बारीक तरीके से कहने वालों का गिरोह बहुत बड़ा हो चुका है।वो आप पर हंसेंगे।

यूक्रेन युद्ध थमा नहीं है मगर बजट बन रहा है कि यूक्रेन को फिर से खड़ा करने के लिए 750 अरब डॉलर की ज़रूरत पड़ेगी। इस युद्ध के कारण जर्मनी का व्यापार घाटा बढ़ने लगा है। गैस और पेट्रोल के आयात की लागत बढ़ने लगी है। जर्मनी हाहाकार की तरफ जा रहा है।

अभी तक विरोधी ही पकड़े जा रहे थे, रूस में व्लादिमीर माऊ को गिरफ्तार किया गया है। व्लादिमीर माऊ पुतिन के मित्रों में से हैं। रूस में एक ही कंपनी गज़प्रोम का गैस के कारोबार पर एकाधिकार है। इसके निदेशक मंडल में व्लादिमीर का चुनाव हुआ था। चुनाव के बाद जेल में डाल दिए गए। उन पर फ्राड के आरोप लगा दिए गए हैं। जब रुस से यूक्रेन पर हमला किया तब रुस की 260 यूनिवर्सिटी के प्रमुखों ने हस्ताक्षर कर व्लादिमीर पुतिन का समर्थन किया। व्लादिमीर माऊ भी उनमें से एक हैं। बंद कमरे में कभी-कभी अलग राय रखते रहे हैं लेकिन पुतिन के मित्र और समर्थक रहे हैं।

विरोधी से लेकर मित्रों तक को जेल में डालो, फ्राड नया हथियार है, इसके ज़रिए कभी विपक्ष की गर्दन काटो तो कभी अपने मित्रों की, ताकि सब भय में रहे। किसी के बोलने की संभावना बची न रहे। ध्यान से देखा कीजिए, दुनिया भर में क्या हो रहा है, अपने देश में क्या हो रहा है, इसे ध्यान से देखने की कोई ज़रूरत नहीं है, क्योंकि पहले दुनिया में होता है, फिर यहां होता है।

फाइनेंशियल टाइम्स ने लिखा है कि रूस में बंद दरवाज़े के भीतर अलग राय रखने की भी अनुमति नहीं है। मित्र होना काफी नहीं है। पुतिन को इस बात से फर्क नहीं पड़ता कि किसी को जेल में डाल देने पर जनता नाराज़ हो जाएगी।पुतिन कंपनियों का राष्ट्रीयकरण करने में लगे हैं। भारत में तो अभी निजीकरण हो रहा है। क्या पता इसका भी वक्त आ जाए और लोग तारीफ में जुट जाएं कि पुतिन ने किया था, वही मॉडल अपनाया जा रहा है।

बहुत सारे लोग रुस छोड़ कर भाग रहे हैं। बिज़नेसमैन और अकादमिक जगत के लोगों ने भागना शुरू कर दिया है। भारत से भी आठ हज़ार अमीर लोग देश छोड़ने की तैयारी कर रहे हैं। आखिर कितने लोग जेल में डाल दिए जाने के डर से भाग रहे हैं। जो बचेंगे वे भी समर्थन की जेल में रहेंगे, जहां उन्हें पेट भरने के लिए मुट्ठी भर अनाज ही मिलेगा, बाकी समर्थन करते रहना पड़ेगा। इसे समर्थन की जेल कहते हैं।

कहानी ख़त्म नहीं हुई है। श्रीलंका, पाकिस्तान, टर्की, यूक्रेन ही बर्बाद नहीं हुए हैं। अर्जेंटीना की भी हालत ख़राब है। वहां के इकोनमी मंत्री ने इस्तीफा दे दिया।मामला नहीं संभला। नया कोई आना नहीं चाहता तो कहीं से किसी को पकड़ कर लाया गया है। अर्जेंटीना की मुद्रा पेसो भी डॉलर के आगे लड़खड़ा गई है। महंगाई भयंकर है और बाज़ार में लगाया हुआ पैसा डूब रहा है। अर्जेंटीना भी श्रीलंका और पाकिस्तान की तरह घूम-घूम कर पैसा मांग रहा है। पैसा है नहीं।

भारत की तरह अर्जेंटीना में भी पेंशन फंड है। जिसे बाज़ार में लगाया जाता है ताकि उसके बढ़ने से लोगों को पेंशन मिलेगी। खबर है कि शीर्ष पेंशन फंड ने कहा है कि वह शेयर बाज़ार में कम पैसा लगाएगा क्योंकि बाज़ार की हालत ठीक नहीं है। 2008 के बाद पेंशन फंड को घाटा हुआ है। इसका कहना है कि बाज़ार में गिरावट का दौर अभी लंबा चलेगा।जापान की भी हालत खराब है। उसकी मुद्रा येन भी कमज़ोर हो गई है। महंगाई काफी बढ़ गई है।

सारी सूचनाएं फाइनेंशियल टाइम्स से ली गई हैं। इसमें भारत की एक भी ख़बर नहीं थी। अमरीका, आस्ट्रेलिया, फ्रांस, जर्मनी, ब्रिटेन, अर्जेंटीना, टर्की की ख़बर थी। लगता है भारत में सब ठीक है। व्हाट्स एप यूनिवर्सिटी में मीम की सप्लाई जारी है। इतने बड़े देश में कोई न कोई कांड कर ही देता है जिससे लोगों का टाइम हिन्दू मुसलमान की बहस में कटने लगता है। इस डिबेट से भारत ने आर्थिक संकट को टाल दिया है। संकट है भी तो लोगों के दिमाग़ में नहीं है। लेख लंबा हो गया। आपको तो मीम पढ़ने की आदत है। लगे रहिए

 

ये लेख रविश कुमार के फेस्बूक पेज़ से साभार है। 

Do Police Have The Right, To Unfettered Access, To Your Phones, Laptops?

1

Smitha Nair interviewed Senior Advocate Rebecca John to ask some fundamental questions about the way police get unfettered access to phones and laptops of people, even before someone is getting declared accused.

On Alt News co-founder Mohammed Zubair’s electronic devices being seized, the senior advocate said, “I’d have imagined that the fundamental question a magistrate would ask in such a case is– here is the tweet, the man is not denying the tweet, why did you need the device? Clearly, there is no nexus.”

Rebecca John further said, “Law on digital evidence giving unfettered access to investigating agencies to every part of your life is vague and ambiguous-
We don’t have statutory provisions which control the right of police to seize electronic data.”

The senior lawyer mentioned, “Time has come for judicial guidelines as to circumstances under which these electronic seizures can be made. Can you compel a person to give a phone? Does that not amount to self-incrimination? Post privacy judgement, is important to draw boundaries of this power.”

She pointed out other situations as well, including Ordeal for rape survivors. “Police take their phones, and allow accused cloned copy- exposing her to the most vicious cross-examination in court, over incidents, and relationships that have no bearing on the facts of this case, which relate to years before the crime was committed.”

Rebecca claimed, “Magistrates are the first line of defence as far as the accused person is concerned. He is produced before the magistrate, he expects the magistrate to protect his rights. Every magistrate must be mindful of abuse, and must insist on certain basic safeguards.”

And pointed out, “In the iconic dissent of Justice HR Khanna in ADM Jabalpur case, he said – the defence of personal liberty is the defence of procedure. Procedural law is of utmost importance to ensure the rights of citizens. That’s all we seek from our subordinate judiciary.”

On Hyderabad police stop and search, Rebecca said, “I’d imagine this is just the kind of case, where a court should take suo moto notice and ask the police, under which provision of law have you got the power to randomly stop motorists and ask them to submit their mobile phones to you for inspection. ”

“All of this comes because I think we have steadily ignored the price that individuals pay when we don’t adhere to procedure. At some point the courts have to get proactive and insist that the law isn’t just for police agencies, the law is for the citizens.”

On Bhima Koregaon and the alleged planting of evidence, she said, “When you have extraordinary evidence which suggests that there has been tampering, then it is the duty of constitutional courts to step in. Extraordinary powers are available to constitutional courts.”

 

The interview has originally published at Scroll.in.

Extraordinary work by Mohammed Zubair and shabby little case to harass him

0

Kolkata: Every Indian or maybe Non-Resident Indians knows how impactful Ravish Kumar’s journalism is among the masses. Especially after 2014, when most of the Indian media in general and Hindi news channels, in particular, have fallen in line with the ruling party in the world’s largest democracy, Ravish continued with his speaking truth to those in power. While Ravish has a journalistic career spanning over two decades, in the past five years, onother person who has done similar impactful work in India is Mohammed Zubair.

The Alt News co-founder work has made the same impact through Twitter as that NDTV’s Executive Editor on the a Hindi news channel. While Ravish reaches out the Indian masses, Zubair’s work has a global appeal.

Ravish has been trolled and abused by right-wingers. A propaganda website OpIndia has done hundreds of stories on Ravish. But the senior journalist only went on to win several awards for his exemplary brand of journalism, including the prestigious Magsaysay award. The hope for journalists like Ravish being behind bars, remain a distant dream for right-wing supporters.

Ravish has called the fact-checker many times on his show.

But when Zubair continued with his stellar work by exposing people behind Sulli Deals, Bulli Bai Deals and highlighted hate speeches during Haridwar Dharam Sansad as well as Nupur Sharma case, it not only shook those propagating hate and fake news, right-wing supporters, and leaders but exposed them globally.

Because of Zubair’s documentation of hate speeches, several international media organizations have been able to write on the Genocide-like situation in India. Zubair’s extraordinary work of busting fake news and highlighting hate speeches in recent times eventually led to the arrest.

It is also a reality that journalists who are associated with independent media in India are more vulnerable than their counterparts in mainstream media.

When I met Zubair in October last year. He told me that before coming to Kolkata, he had appeared in a court case. Till that time, the fact-checker was facing a ‘functional’ legal system, so he was outside.

On June 27, Zubair was arrested on flimsy ground. Till now, it is already in the public domain how fabricated the case is. The tweet which led to arrest of Zubair was from a movie scene and the handle was deactivated for some days.

he Wire during its investigation uncovered the existence of a network of 757 Twitter habdles that were used to launch a coordinated attack on Alt News. It mentioned that anonymous complainants targeting Zubair’s Tweet linked to Tek Fog App, of a BJYM leader in Gujarat.

Since Zubair got arrested, just two days after the arrest of human rights defender Teesta Setalvad. Their arrest has led to widespread outrage across India and among the diaspora, globally. Even the spokesperson of Secretary-General, United Nations commented against the arrests but it did not change anything for Zubair as far as his bail was concerned.

After being in police custody for five days on Saturday, he was sent to judicial custody for 14 days.

And now there remains no doubt about the Enforcement Directorate investigating the case. A few media outlets are already speculating the same.

The sequence confirm that he is being harassed for his work and that the funding of Alt News will also be probed, for exposing fake news and documenting hate speeches, which often has a direct connection with Bharatiya Janata Party leaders and the organization itself.

Delhi Court sends Mohammed Zubair to judicial custody, Delhi police slap fresh charges

New Delhi: The co-founder of Alt News Mohammed Zubair, who has spent five days in police custody, has been sent to fourteen days of judicial custody by a Delhi court today.

Earlier today, the fact-checker’s counsel Vrinda Grover had appealed for Zubair’s bail petition. But not only has he been denied the same but has been sent for a two-week judicial custody.

However, the most significant part remained during the hearing that even before Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Snigdha Sarvaria could announce the judgment, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Delhi KPS Malhotra told the media that Mohammed Zubair has been denied bail by the court and sent to 14-day judicial custody.

The fiasco took place soon after CMM reserved the order. The leak raised serious questions.

According to a PTI report, the DCP later said that he had been incorrectly informed by the media that Alt News co-founder Mohammed Zubair had been sent to a 14-day judicial custody even before the court pronounced its order.

Zubair was arrested by Delhi police on June 27, when he was called for another case but arrested in a different one. He was arrested allegedly for hurting religious sentiment and promoting enmity through his tweet made in 2018. On the same day sent to one day of police custody. Later, he was sent to another four days of police custody, which ended today.

But special public prosecutor Atul Srivastava appearing for Delhi police told the court that fresh charges- Section 120B (criminal conspiracy) and 201 (causing disappearance of evidence of offense) of Indian Penal Code and Section 35 of Foreign Contribution Regulation) Act have been added against Zubair.

Significantly, today The Wire in its investigation uncovered the existence of a network of 757 Twitter accounts that were used to mount coordinated attacks against Alt News.

It mentioned that anonymous complainants targeting Zubair’s Tweet linked to Tek Fog App, BJYM leader in Gujarat.

It should be noted, that today the same Twitter handle of BJYM leader Vikash Ahir is now running a Twitter campaign to Arrest Pratik Sinha, another co-founder of Alt News.

ताज महल के जगह पे कोई मंदिर नहीं था, भारतीय पुरातत्त्व सर्वेक्षण का दावा

कोलकाता। अब ये आधिकारिक हो गया है कि ताज महल के जगह पे कभी कोई मंदिर नहीं था। इस बात की पुष्टि कोई और नहीं बल्कि भारतीय पुरातत्त्व सर्वेक्षण (Archaeological Survey Of India) ने एक आरटीआई के जवाब में किया है।

आरटीआई कार्यकर्ता साकेत गोखले के सवालों के जवाब में आर्कियोलॉजिकल सर्वे ऑफ इंडिया ने ये भी दावा किया और बताया के दुनिया की सबसे ऐतिहासिक इमारत में से एक ताज महल में कोई बंद चेम्बर नहीं जिसमें मूर्तियाँ हों।

मालूम हो की हाल में हिन्दूवादी संगठनो ने ताज महल के 22 कमरों में शिव की मूर्तिया होने का दावा किया था और इसके लिए वे इलाहाबाद हाइकोर्ट भी गए थे।

हाई कोर्ट के याचिका में कहा गया है कि ताजमहल के वे 22 कमरे खोले जाएं जो लंबे समय से बंद हैं। याचिकाकर्ता का दावा है कि इन कमरों में हिंदू देवी-देवताओं की मूर्तियां और शिलालेख के साथ तमाम सबूत मौजूद हैं कि ताजमहल पहले मंदिर था। इसी मामले पर इलाहाबाद हाई कोर्ट की लखनऊ बेंच में सुनवाई हुई थी और याचिका खारिज कर दी गयी।

taj mahal archaeological survey of India Hindu ISI आईएसआई ताज महल आरटीआई

हाई कोर्ट द्वारा याचिका खारिज करने के बाद याचिकाकर्ता के वकील ने कोर्ट रूम के बाहर मीडिया से बातचीत में कहा था कि वे सुप्रीम कोर्ट जाएंगे।

एएसआई ने इस बारे में एक ब्यान भी दिया था कि ताजमहल के नीचे मौजूद कमरों में छुपाने जैसा कुछ नहीं है। इन्हें सुरक्षा कारणों से जनता से दूर रखा गया था। यहां किसी भी मूर्ति के मौजूद होने के पहले संकेत नहीं मिले हैं।

पर अब लिखित जवाब और मामला ऑन रेकॉर्ड होने से इस तरह के हरकतों पर हमेशा के लिए लगाम लगाया जा सकता है।

साकेत गोखले ने भी अपने आरटीआई कॉपी को शेयर करते हुए लिखा के उम्मीद है की लोग और कोर्ट इस बात (एएसआई का आरटीआई में दिया जवाब) को ध्यान में रखेंगे जब नोएडा मीडिया जो इस बात को लेकर नफरत फैलाने की कोशिश करेगा।

Delhi Court Extends Police Custody Of Mohammed Zubair, Did Not Watch Movie Clip

0

Delhi: The Alt News Co-founder, Mohammed Zubair who was arrested on Monday by Delhi Police and sent to one-day police custody by a duty magistrate has to stay for four more days in custody, pronounced a Delhi court.

Delhi police, according to Pratik Sinha, another co-founder of Alt News, had called Mohammed Zubair in a 2020 case, in which Delhi High Court has already given protect to Zubair, but arrested him in another case for allegedly hurting religious sentiments and promoting enmity.

Zubair has been arrested under sections 153 and 295A of the Indian Penal Code.

The four-year-old tweet by Zubair, according to the complainant has hurt his religious sentiment. The tweet is an image of a film—Kisi Se Na Kehna made in 1983. The image, which is two scenes of the movie, has a name change of a hotel—Honeymoon to Hanuman shared by Zubair.

The fact-checker was defended by senior lawyer Vrinda Grover. The senior counsel told the court, “It is an old film. There are multiple Twitter handles which are applauding the fact that Honeymoon hotel is made of Hanuman hotel. The entire case is borders on absurdity.”

She also argued, “Section 153A says one community. What are the groups human bhakt is making? He is saying Hanuman Ji was brahmachari. This was a 1983 movie. This has been then applauded by many supporters. Where is the conflict?”

Grover continued: “The first criteria that they will have to satisfy is destruction, damage or place of worship or sacred object. This is a photograph of a movie. This isn’t a place of worship. This is a joke on the honeymooners. Where is the damage? ”

“Prima facie where is the case? Yes, he is a fact-checker, a journalist. He speaks his mind. How is 295 even invoked in this FIR? Let me show a judgement,” she added.

Some reports also suggest that the defence lawyer had wanted to show the movie clip in the court, but it was not permitted by the judge Snigdha Sarvaria.

Later, the court granted police remand saying that the mobile phone/laptop of Mohammed Zubair is to be recovered from his Bangalore residence and that he has remained non-cooperative.

Meanwhile, several organizations from DigiPub, an association of digital-only media organizations to the Press Club of India and Amnesty International all have condemned the arrest of Zubair.

Zubair’s arrest came after two days of the arrests of human rights defender Teesta Setalvad and RB Sreekumar, ex-Director General of Police.

Today, the global Indian diaspora including The Indian American Muslim Council also condemned the arrests of Teesta, Sreekumar and Zubair.

Alt News Co-founder Mohammed Zubair arrested by Delhi Police

0

Delhi: Mohammed Zubair, the Co-founder of Alt News, a fact-checking website has been arrested by Delhi police today.

Zubair was called to a police station for questioning in connection with a different case but was then arrested under unknown charges. 

Pratik Sinha, another co-founder, informed it by a tweet. He expressed surprise and tweeted a note, “Zubair was called by the special cell of Delhi police for an investigation in a 2020 case which he had already protected against arrest from the High Court. However, today at around 6.45 pm we were told he has been arrested in some other FIR for which no notice was given which is mandatory under law for the Sections under which he has been arrested. No FIR copy is being given to us despite repeated requests.”

Pratik again tweet at 8.38 pm: “After the medical examination, Zubair is being taken to an undisclosed location. Neither Zubair’s lawyers or I are being told where. We are in the police van with him. No police person is wearing any name tag (sic).

Zubair was originally summoned for questioning in the 2020 POCSO case but has been arrested in a different case.

The POCSO case against Zubair was registered in 2020 over his tweet calling out an abusive user and confronting him. A user had abused Zubair in a reply to his tweet about a fact check, and Zubair had responded by sharing the user’s profile picture with the caption: “Does your cute granddaughter know about your part-time job of abusing people on social media? I suggest you change your profile pic.” Zubair had blurred out the minor girl’s face while sharing it. Later, the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) asked for action to be taken against Zubair following an official complaint from the abusive handle. The Delhi police’s cyber cell had then booked him under sections of the POCSO Act as well as the IT Act. At the time, Alt News had rubbished charges against Zubair that he had doxxed the minor. Zubair had then approached the Delhi High Court and the court had restrained the Delhi police from taking any coercive action against him.

The Delhi police has issued a statement on the arrest of Zubair: “Today during the course of investigation of registered at PS-Special Cell u/s 153A/295A IPC alleged Mohammed Zubair was joined in the investigation of the case and after having sufficient evidence on record, he was arrested in the present case. He is being produced before the magistrate for seeking further PC remand for the purpose of the investigation of the case.”

Last month, Zubair was booked by Uttar Pradesh police for a tweet where he called three controversial Hindu leaders Yati Narasinghanand, Mahant Bajrang Muni and Anand Swaroop– hatemongers.

The three leaders are known for making provocative speeches against Muslims and Narsinghanand was also jailed in a hate speech case.  

Zubair has been relentlessly debunking fake news for several years now.