Mr Modi, you can maintain silence but you can’t keep us silent: People of Kolkata

Joint Forum against NRC and Citizens’ Forum For Social Justice in their protest also demanded resignation of Manipur chief minister Biren Singh for his failure to control violence

Date:

Share post:

Kolkata: India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi, remained silent for 78 days while Manipur kept burning. When he spoke, it was just for 39 seconds, and that too he compared brutality in the Northeast state with opposition-ruled states in India. There was no empathy for the women of Manipur in his speech. Now also, PM Modi is not going to Parliament and speaking inside the Loksabha. He is forced to speak as a no-confidence motion has been brought against the Modi-led government. All these have anguished concerned citizens of India across the country and in Kolkata as well.

“You (Mr Modi) have forgotten that the crowd that has made you prime minister, will take your chair away,” said Umar Owais, a resident of Rajabazar, in the inaugural speech of a protest jointly organized by Joint Forum against NRC and Citizens’ Forum For Social Justice.

While Owais set the tone and mood of the protest, all the speakers including Amitava Chakraborty, Himadri Mukherjee, Professor Albeena Shakil, Tamal Chakraborty, Nousheen Baba Khan, Manzar Jameel, and Pratip demanded PM Modi to act like a Prime Minister of the country.

They all pointed out the similarity between violence experienced during the Gujarat Riots in 2002 and what happened with Bilkis Bano. They claimed that same pattern was being followed in Manipur.

protest against manipur violence burning kolkata
A poster put up by the organizers at the event site | Picture: eNewsroom India

The speakers, who had also led several protests across Bengal against the NRC (National Register of Citizens), reminded that it is the idea of NRC that fueled the strife in Manipur.

“We have to hold this protest as when Manipur was burning PM Modi was visiting the United States of America. After returning, now, he is speaking outside the Parliament. Opposition parties are demanding that he should speak inside the Parliament, so he should go and speak there. There should be a code of law in Manipur. Biren Singh should be removed as chief minister, Prosenjit Bose, the convener of the Joint Forum against NRC told eNewsroom.

The drizzle during the event didn’t deter listeners. They remained seated to listen to the speakers despite the chances of a heavy downpour.

The programme was moderated by Jawed Alam, another local from Rajabazar.

Related articles

From Goethe to Kolkata Classrooms: Why Learning Arabic Matters for Self-Reliance and Leadership

At Kolkata’s charity-run Umeed Global School, where over 75 per cent of students come from underprivileged backgrounds, a November 14 Khutba competition became a powerful lesson in self-reliance. Addressing the students, Imarat-e-Shariah Ameer Ahmed Wali Faisal Rahmani and founder-secretary Wali Rahmani emphasised how understanding Arabic—a language admired by thinkers from Roger Bacon to Goethe—empowers young learners to engage with sacred texts firsthand, perform family rites independently, and emerge as confident leaders.

Newborn Denied Birth Certificate as TMC, CPI(M), Congress Unite Over Bengal Voter Roll Deletions

TMC, Left, and Congress united in Kolkata to call a November 21 convention over West Bengal’s SIR voter list deletions after a Cooch Behar newborn was allegedly denied a birth certificate and 37 lakh appeals remained pending.

Killed Over a Skullcap, Ignored by the System: What 405 Documented Hate Incidents Reveal About Impunity in India

A new APCR report documents 405 hate crimes and speeches across India in nine months—including 54 deaths, post-poll violence in West Bengal, and 37 per cent state actor involvement—exposing how public incitement and police inaction fuel targeted minority violence.

The Architect of Indian Minds: From Macaulay’s Clerks to Azad’s Engineers

Maulana Azad held no formal degrees, yet he built the IITs and dismantled the British system designed to produce clerks. As India debates commercialised schooling and institutional credibility in 2026, his radical republic of learning demands an urgent revisit