Beyond the Headlines: The Subtle Art of Ignoring Independent Media

Date:

Share post:

Kolkata: The issue of duplicate voters, or the same EPIC (Electors Photo Identity Card) number being assigned to two or more voters, has now been raised in Parliament. Almost all opposition parties are united on this issue.

For some, the issue of duplicate voters became public either through West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee or on social media. Mamata Banerjee mentioned it during an event in Kolkata, and a few days later, the Election Commission held a press conference on the matter in the national capital, Delhi. While the Commission accepted that duplicate voters do exist, it also claimed that they were addressing the issue after it was highlighted on several social media platforms.

However, the reality is that Mamata Banerjee was not aware of the existence of duplicate voters until it was brought to her notice, nor was there any viral social media debate or issue surrounding it.

A non-government organization (NGO), Parijayee Shramik Aikya Mancha, which works with migrant workers, discovered several such cases and sent a letter on December 27, 2024, to the Bengal State Election Commission as well as to Mamata Banerjee.

The Mancha also shared its findings with eNewsroom. Recognizing the significance of the issue, we immediately published the report on January 5, 2025.

In late February, Mamata Banerjee raised the issue but did not mention the organization that discovered the anomalies or reported the issue. A few days later, after the Bengal Chief Minister’s comment, the Election Commission, in its press briefing, only mentioned that the issue was being posted on social media. The Commission neither acknowledged Mamata Banerjee, eNewsroom, nor the NGO. However, sources at the Bengal State Election Commission confirmed that it had received a letter from the Mancha and forwarded it to the National Election Commission, after which the press conference was held.

The significance of the duplicate voter issue for the opposition is clear. After Banerjee highlighted it, TMC leaders held a press conference in Delhi. Now, the Leader of the Opposition, Rahul Gandhi, has also spoken about it, both inside and outside Parliament.

Yet, throughout this entire process, neither the Mancha nor the media organization has been mentioned. Additionally, the people from the Mancha have now gone silent on the matter.

Even without receiving credit, as a media organization, eNewsroom has been raising such important issues for the past eight years and will continue to do so. We believe that it is the people and their rights that matter to us.

Shahnawaz Akhtar
Shahnawaz Akhtarhttp://shahnawazakhtar.com
Shahnawaz Akhtar is a senior journalist with over two decades of reporting experience across four Indian states and China. He is the Managing Editor and founder of eNewsroom India, an independent, Kolkata-based digital media platform. His work focuses on human-interest reporting, capturing lived realities, resilience, and voices often ignored by mainstream media

Related articles

Suspected Cattle Thieves or Victims of Mob Justice? Two Dead, Survivors Arrested in Siliguri

Two men were killed and three critically injured after a mob allegedly attacked five travellers in Siliguri over suspected cattle theft. Police arrested the three survivors and seven others in connection with the violence, while questions remain over what triggered the attack.

गांधी की पत्रकारिता और आज की वायरल दुनिया: मायने क्या रखता है—रीच या असर?

गांधी की पत्रकारिता और आज की वायरल दुनिया के बीच क्या बदला? eNewsroom Conclave में जवाहर सरकार, प्रतीक सिन्हा, राशिद किदवई, अरफा खानम शेरवानी समेत वक्ताओं ने स्वतंत्र मीडिया, एल्गोरिद्म और पत्रकारिता के बदलते सरोकारों पर चर्चा की

Gandhi Had Newspapers. We Have Algorithms. What Would He Make of Today’s Media?

Gandhi had newspapers; today’s journalists have algorithms. At the inaugural eNewsroom Conclave, journalists and public voices explored what happens when clicks, virality and Big Tech influence what people see, while independent media struggles to keep public-interest journalism alive.

Echoes of a Crisis: Why Biswajit Roy’s Tagore and Palestine Still Matter Today

Biswajit Roy’s Palestine, Arab-Jewish Relations and Rabindranath explores Tagore’s ideas on nationalism, imperialism, religion and coexistence. At a time of war and civilian suffering in Gaza, the book offers a deeply humanist lens through which to understand Palestine’s history and the crisis today