Who Gets to Name Terrorism? Power, Knowledge and the Politics of Violence

Book Review | Why does student protest get branded as extremism while state violence faces less scrutiny? Irfan Ahmad’s Terrorism in Question examines the politics of violence, from 9/11 to the cases of Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam

Date:

Share post:

Who has the authority to define terrorism, and whose interests does that definition serve? This question becomes particularly urgent in contemporary India, where the boundaries between political dissent, student activism, national security and criminality have become increasingly contested. The banning of student organisations, the prolonged incarceration of Muslim student activists and the public framing of dissent through the language of national security extend beyond individual cases. They concern not merely the exercise of state power, but the authority to classify political action, determine its legitimacy and establish which accounts of violence are accepted as credible.

These questions lie at the centre of anthropologist and sociologist Irfan Ahmad’s Terrorism in Question: Decolonizing Anthropology and the Study of Islam (2026). The book challenges the assumption that terrorism is a self-evident or politically neutral category of violence. Rather than treating terrorism as an established phenomenon awaiting explanation, Ahmad examines the institutions, political interests and unequal relations of power through which it acquires meaning. His intervention shifts the analytical focus from those labelled terrorists to those who possess the authority to apply the label. In doing so, he questions a political imagination in which Western democracies are positioned as the natural opponents of terrorism, while Muslim political activity is repeatedly interpreted through the vocabulary of extremism and suspicion.

Reading Ahmad in the context of contemporary India foregrounds a pressing democratic dilemma: what happens to citizenship and political belonging when national security becomes the primary lens through which political dissent is understood?

Post-9/11 Politics: When Islam Became a Security Question

The events of 11 September 2001 fundamentally altered the global political vocabulary through which Islam and Muslim political activity were discussed. The association between Islam and terrorism became increasingly embedded in political discourse, security practices and academic writing. Ahmad challenges the tendency to interpret Muslim political activity primarily through the vocabulary of extremism without adequately examining the historical and political circumstances in which it emerges.

One of the book’s important contributions is its challenge to the presumed neutrality of counterterrorism institutions. States and international organisations claiming the authority to identify and contain terrorism cannot automatically be understood as standing outside the political processes they seek to regulate. Their policies, surveillance practices, arrests and use of force must also become objects of critical inquiry.

This does not mean treating all forms of violence as equivalent. State repression, unlawful coercion and non-state political violence have distinct historical, legal and political characteristics. Ahmad’s larger intervention is to expose the institutional conditions under which particular definitions become authoritative while alternative interpretations are pushed to the margins.

SIMI Ban and UAPA: Rethinking Muslim Student Politics in India

Ahmad’s discussion of the Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) brings these questions directly into the Indian context. The organisation, declared an unlawful association under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), offers an important case through which to examine the relationship between Muslim student mobilisation, state authority and political representation.

The Union government’s decision to renew SIMI’s ban for another five years in January 2024, subsequently confirmed by the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Tribunal in July 2024, keeps this discussion urgently relevant. Drawing on interviews with three former members—two who had spent 30 and 27 months in prison respectively, and a third who had never been incarcerated—Ahmad examines how their political experiences diverge from the official accounts through which the organisation has largely been represented.

The significance of these interviews lies in the epistemological challenge they pose to official narratives. People frequently discussed through police records, security classifications and media representations are given an opportunity to describe their own experiences. Treating individuals associated with banned movements as producers of knowledge rather than mere subjects of institutional investigation fundamentally alters how we understand political organisations.

Nevertheless, three individual accounts cannot independently establish the broader political character of an organisation. Their testimonies need to be situated alongside historical records, institutional evidence and the wider political circumstances in which they were produced. What remains essential is the distinction between the legal status of an organisation and the political identities of the people associated with it: a legal prohibition does not, by itself, resolve questions of individual responsibility, political conviction or lived experience.

Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam and the UAPA Bail Battle Over Delhi Riots

The legal and political dynamics surrounding SIMI find a contemporary parallel in the prosecution of Muslim student activists Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam. Their arrests and prolonged incarceration in connection with the February 2020 Delhi riots have brought questions of political dissent, Muslim identity, national security and the use of anti-terror legislation to the forefront of public debate.

Both were associated with protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and the proposed National Register of Citizens (NRC), and were subsequently accused by the prosecution of involvement in a larger conspiracy linked to the violence. The allegations remain contested and subject to ongoing judicial proceedings.

The legal trajectory of their cases underscores the stakes of prolonged pre-trial detention. On 5 January 2026, the Supreme Court rejected their bail pleas while granting bail to five co-accused, permitting Khalid and Imam to renew their applications after the examination of protected witnesses or the expiry of one year, whichever occurred earlier. On 30 September 2026, the Delhi High Court rejected their subsequent bail appeals. Both filed fresh petitions before the Supreme Court on 4 November.

These developments should not be reduced to a simple opposition between the state and individual activists. The allegations are serious, and the legal process must establish responsibility through evidence and a fair trial. However, the distinction between an allegation, a prosecution’s account and a finding of guilt remains fundamental, particularly when extended pre-trial incarceration tests the constitutional guarantee of a fair and timely trial.

While Ahmad’s book predates these specific legal battles, his analytical framework illuminates what such prosecutions reveal about the conditions under which Muslim students and activists participate in public life. Public debate frequently moves beyond specific evidentiary claims to broader questions of national loyalty and belonging, risking a slide in which political dissent is treated not as disagreement with government policy, but as evidence of a wider ideological threat.

2013 Muzaffarnagar Violence: Riot, Pogrom or Terror?

While the cases of SIMI, Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam draw attention to the treatment of Muslim political mobilisation, Ahmad’s discussion of the 2013 Muzaffarnagar violence shifts the focus towards how collective violence is represented, interpreted and remembered.

Through his visits to refugee camps and engagement with affected communities, Ahmad critiques what he calls the “ditto theory”—the tendency to represent communal violence as an equal confrontation between two sides. Such descriptions conceal stark asymmetries in power, responsibility and vulnerability, while overlooking the experiences of people who have been displaced, targeted or left without adequate state protection.

The distinction between a riot, a pogrom and an act of terror matters because these terms do more than describe events; they organise public understanding, distribute responsibility and shape collective memory. By challenging the reflex to flatten asymmetric violence into a symmetrical clash, Ahmad demonstrates how official vocabulary itself can obscure the structural realities of displacement and state failure.

Yet, challenging established descriptions requires conceptual precision. An alternative vocabulary cannot simply replace existing categories; it must explain what those categories obscure and why another description is more appropriate. Ahmad opens this debate, although a more explicit framework for distinguishing different forms of collective violence would have strengthened his argument.

Majoritarian Nationalism and the Blind Spots of Counterterrorism

Ahmad extends his argument beyond India through his account of a conference organised in Muzaffarpur following arrests after the 2013 Patna rally bomb blasts. The gathering brings into focus a community repeatedly framed through the language of terrorism that simultaneously experiences itself as living under the threat of state power—a stark reversal that exposes whose experiences of insecurity are recognised in dominant political narratives and whose are excluded.

His reflection on a United Nations Development Programme conference in Oslo further develops this critique. Invited to speak about working with faith-based organisations and religious leaders to counter the abuse of religion by violent extremists, Ahmad questions the limited attention given to nationalism as a driver of political violence. Through discussions of Myanmar, Sri Lanka and India, he challenges international counterterrorism frameworks that fixate on religious extremism while overlooking violence rooted in majoritarian nationalism and state structures.

This is a significant intervention because it questions the tendency to explain political violence through religious identity alone, without adequately examining the political structures and ideologies that enable other forms of violence. However, the relationship between different forms of state violence could have been made more precise. State repression, unlawful coercion and terrorism may overlap in particular circumstances, but they are not interchangeable categories.

What Urdu Fiction Reveals That Police Records Miss

In the final part of the book, Ahmad turns to Urdu literary narratives to explore what fiction can reveal about political violence, memory and lived experience. This widens the archive through which terrorism is studied and challenges the assumption that institutional records and conventional academic sources are sufficient for understanding political life.

One particularly striking literary reference is Ahmad’s engagement with Saadat Hasan Manto, who scripted his own epitaph shortly before his death: even after being buried, Manto wondered whether he was the greater storyteller or God. Ahmad places this literary reflection alongside the thousands killed during the Global War on Terror, many of whom were buried in mass graves without even the dignity of a proper burial. The juxtaposition moves the discussion beyond the conventional identification of terrorism with non-state actors and raises an unsettling question: who is the greater terrorist, the state or ethnicised non-state actors?

This is where literature acquires significance beyond its artistic value. It can make visible the fear, uncertainty and loss that official documents and policy discussions routinely leave unaddressed. Ahmad’s engagement with Urdu literary expression also disrupts an epistemic hierarchy that treats state archives and security reports as inherently more authoritative than vernacular cultural knowledge.

Yet literary representation and empirical evidence perform distinct analytical tasks. Fiction deepens our interpretive understanding of political life, but it works best when read in dialogue with—rather than as a substitute for—interviews, archival research and ethnographic evidence. A fuller discussion of how these different forms of knowledge complement one another would have strengthened this section.

Who Decides What Counts as Terrorism in a Democracy?

A decolonised approach to the study of terrorism requires more than questioning the categories imposed on marginalised communities. It demands rigorous scrutiny of the institutions, political elites and international networks that produce, legitimise and circulate those categories. Ahmad’s work is valuable precisely because it redirects attention towards those who claim the authority to define terrorism while taking seriously the lives of people governed by that definition.

At the same time, the book’s central limitation lies in its conceptual precision. Ahmad is far more convincing in showing how the category of terrorism is politically produced than in establishing clear analytical boundaries between different forms of violence—whether riots, pogroms, unlawful state coercion, state repression or non-state terrorism. Overlapping in practice does not make these categories legally or politically interchangeable. Questioning the authority of the state does not mean denying the reality of non-state violence, just as recognising the criminalisation of dissent does not exempt political actors from scrutiny or accountability.

A genuinely decolonised approach cannot simply invert existing hierarchies of interpretation; it must build stricter frameworks for weighing evidence, responsibility and institutional power.

Ultimately, Terrorism in Question asks us to look beyond the labels through which political violence is packaged. Its enduring contribution lies in showing that the authority to name violence is itself an exercise of power—one that shapes public memory, institutional responses and the boundaries of democratic belonging.

A democracy cannot afford to surrender its capacity for independent scrutiny to the very institutions that claim to protect it.

Sheikh Ayesha Islam
Sheikh Ayesha Islam
A Delhi-based writer who focuses on art, culture, politics, entertainment, digital discourse and broader social narratives. An alumna of the Department of Educational Studies, Faculty of Education at Jamia Millia Islamia, she holds master’s degrees in Social Work and Early Childhood Development. She can be reached at islamunofficial@gmail.com.

Related articles

From Goethe to Kolkata Classrooms: Why Learning Arabic Matters for Self-Reliance and Leadership

At Kolkata’s charity-run Umeed Global School, where over 75 per cent of students come from underprivileged backgrounds, a November 14 Khutba competition became a powerful lesson in self-reliance. Addressing the students, Imarat-e-Shariah Ameer Ahmed Wali Faisal Rahmani and founder-secretary Wali Rahmani emphasised how understanding Arabic—a language admired by thinkers from Roger Bacon to Goethe—empowers young learners to engage with sacred texts firsthand, perform family rites independently, and emerge as confident leaders.

Newborn Denied Birth Certificate as TMC, CPI(M), Congress Unite Over Bengal Voter Roll Deletions

TMC, Left, and Congress united in Kolkata to call a November 21 convention over West Bengal’s SIR voter list deletions after a Cooch Behar newborn was allegedly denied a birth certificate and 37 lakh appeals remained pending.

Killed Over a Skullcap, Ignored by the System: What 405 Documented Hate Incidents Reveal About Impunity in India

A new APCR report documents 405 hate crimes and speeches across India in nine months—including 54 deaths, post-poll violence in West Bengal, and 37 per cent state actor involvement—exposing how public incitement and police inaction fuel targeted minority violence.

The Architect of Indian Minds: From Macaulay’s Clerks to Azad’s Engineers

Maulana Azad held no formal degrees, yet he built the IITs and dismantled the British system designed to produce clerks. As India debates commercialised schooling and institutional credibility in 2026, his radical republic of learning demands an urgent revisit