There are moments in our community when the heart feels both hope and unease at the same time. The proposed one-lakh–person Quran recitation in Murshidabad, announced by a suspended MLA, is one such moment.
On the surface, it is stirring: thousands gathering to recite Allah’s Book together, voices rising in unison with divine words. Any Muslim’s heart would soften at that sight. The Prophet ﷺ described such gatherings beautifully:
“Tranquility descends upon them, mercy envelops them, angels surround them, and Allah mentions them…”
(Sahih Muslim)
What more could a believer ask for?
Yet, surrounding this spiritual promise is a political shadow. The programme comes soon after the foundation ceremony of a new Babri masjid in Murshidabad, and soon before the next phase of that project. It arrives at a time when Bengal is emotionally and politically fragile.
And it is led by a politician whose past continues to make parts of the community uncomfortable. The one who, to further his own political ambitions, had previously joined the very party that was responsible for the demolition of the original Babri Masjid,.
A Question of Trust
This unease is not born out of prejudice. It is born out of experience. For years, many Muslims have viewed his public positions with caution. His shifting political loyalties, his recent suspension, and his tendency to appear prominently during high-visibility moments have created a natural sense of doubt.
This does not render the current initiative invalid. But it does mean that the community’s concerns are grounded in lived reality, and not merely suspicion.
Still, this does not mean the gathering is wrong. But it does make the moment heavier, more layered, and more deserving of deep reflection.
Niyyat: The Heart of Every Act
In Islam, acts of worship are judged by something invisible: intention.
“Actions are judged only by intentions, and every person will have only what they intended.”
(Bukhari& Muslim)
A Quran recital of one lakh people may look grand on earth, but in the heavens, it will be weighed by sincerity, not size. A feast for thousands may impress the public, but it will not impress Allah unless it begins from a place of purity.
The Qur’an itself warns us against confusing religious appearance with religious purpose. In the story of Masjid Dhirar, Allah says:
“Never stand (to pray) there. A mosque founded on righteousness from the first day is more worthy of your standing.”
(Qur’an 9:108)
The lesson is timeless: an act may appear noble, yet lose its soul if the inward intention is tied to worldly aims.
The Prophet ﷺ cautioned us strongly:
“Whoever does a good deed to show off, Allah will expose his intentions on the Day of Judgement.”
(SahihBukhari)
For an event of this magnitude, organised by a leader whose political history contains troubling chapters, these warnings naturally rise to the surface. This does not define his intention. Only Allah knows the hearts. But it does make the question of niyyat unavoidable.
In the end…
The community today is sensitive, wounded, and anxious. Every gathering, every statement, every symbol carries weight. The last thing Muslims need is for the Qur’an — our book of guidance — to become entangled in reaction, rivalry, or political theatrics.
If this massive recital is truly for Allah, may it bring blessings beyond measure.
But if it becomes a show of numbers, a tool of mobilisation, or an attempt to counter another gathering recently held at the Brigade ground in Kolkata, then we must pause, breathe, and ask ourselves:
Is this what the Qur’an asked from us?
If a lakh people gather with sincerity, the angels will descend.
If a lakh gather for spectacle, only cameras will.
There is nothing wrong with large gatherings.
What matters is what is sought through them.
May Allah guide our intentions, protect our community, and make every recitation of His Book a light on this earth, not a headline in a political season.
Aameen.
