Unlearning Hate, Understanding Love: Reading Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging Through an Anti-Establishment Lens

Book Review | Forget the political noise. Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging reveals a story of generational grief, quiet resilience and a love that outlived tragedy

Date:

Share post:

I deliberately stayed away from reviews until I had finished reading Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging: A Journey of Love. I was not ready to let myself see it, even subconsciously, through someone else’s lens. It’s purely my opinion that the purpose behind reading a book shapes how we eventually judge it. My reasons were these:

  1. Two young souls from different geographies and cultures falling in love is not uncommon, so how Sonia fell for Rajiv held little interest for me. What made me sit through this memoir was why she stayed back even after the love of her life was, in physical form, blown to bits.
  2. How she turned herself into an astute politician. As a fly on the wall in the house of the most formidable PM, her mother-in-law Indira Gandhi, she observed and absorbed. Where did she apply those lessons? And for how long did Mrs Gandhi’s shadow follow her?
  3. How did she bring up her children in an atmosphere thick with fear and violence, and still keep them from turning cynical and dejected?

As a young girl in Italy, when her family moved from the village of Sangano to the town of Orbassano, she would wave at the slow train heading for her village every evening. It gave her “a comforting sensation of traveling back to my friends and the village I so loved.” When I read this, I thought only love in its purest form could pluck someone so rooted out of her home country and plant her in India. It was a love, tender and deep, that settled in the marrow of both lovers. It is this love that comforts the reader and eventually pierces the heart.

Any reader, whatever their political inclination, whose eyes don’t turn moist at what follows has yet to understand what pure love can be. Fewer still will grasp that the day Sonia signed the register formalising her wedding to Rajiv, she was already entering a contract with loss. And fewest of all will see that to keep loving Rajiv, and to keep missing him, has been both the greatest tragedy and the greatest triumph of Sonia’s life.

Two passages jabbed right at my heart.

The eyes.

After Rajiv’s brutal assassination, Sonia was not allowed to see him, however much she pleaded. Then she remembered that he had pledged to donate his eyes, and she wanted to honour his wish at any cost. In the midst of chaos, she somehow got the message across to the family doctor. He replied:

“Aankhen? Arre kya baat karte ho, kuchh nahin bacha hai, kuchh nahin!” (“Eyes? What are you talking about? There’s nothing left, nothing!”)

Nothing was left to give, only empty hands and a wish left unfulfilled.

The travel bag.

After Rajiv’s ashes were emptied into the river, Sonia opened his travel bag that he had carried on his final political tour. It was packed neatly with essentials and an array of family photographs, among them one he had taken of her in their Cambridge days, and later ones. She writes:

“I look at them one by one: the children at different stages of their growing up, his mother and brother. A separate bag has the clothes he had changed out of. I bend over it, seeking to inhale the elusive scent of my beloved, gone forever.”

My second reason needs a confession.

As a little girl, I hated Mrs Gandhi to the core. My father had instilled a strong anti-establishment sentiment in his children, and our family voted for what he then thought was the viable alternative: the Janata Party. But he never bad-mouthed Mrs Gandhi. The ‘stories’ I heard from others only deepened my hatred, and I could barely stand the slogan painted on the walls: “Vote for Indira, Vote for India.” They said she had Lal Bahadur Shastri killed to become PM. They said she had her husband killed, a man she had married only for his surname. They said she even had her son killed “for slapping her at a public function.”

It was only later, through several writings, Katherine Frank’s biography of her among them, that I saw her from a different angle. As for the Emergency, she lifted it herself and faced the election, and, as the book tells it, she knew she would lose. I feel that not just she but her entire family has paid the price for the excesses of that period, and of the one that followed later: the anti-Sikh riots.

This is the woman Sonia lived with under the same roof for 16 years, in a house where politics was served for breakfast and crisis at dinner, quite often both. She was a daughter-in-law who was least interested in politics, and yet she watched, absorbed and, I suspect, took notes without knowing it. She followed Indira on her foreign tours and learnt her way of mingling with dignitaries. She pulled her saree over her head, feeling it was an instant way to connect with her Amethi constituency. She even learnt to snub those who betrayed her trust, by refusing to meet them or even make eye contact. Most of all, she learnt from Indira how to hold her ground, again and again, in a room brimming with male privilege. And Indira’s shadow followed her into Parliament, where Sonia faced relentless “Videshi bahu” (foreign daughter-in-law) barbs and thought of the days her mother-in-law had endured similar ordeals.

Then, the children.

Born into immense political heritage and terrible losses, Rahul and Priyanka endured what no child should. As teenagers and then as adults, they lived as good as under house arrest, in a harsh world where friends were few and far between, and some of those came calling only when the family’s political weather was fair. Their father’s teachings, through letters and conversations, and their mother’s unwavering commitment to her family must have made them see the world differently. Their father’s and grandmother’s brutal endings gave them every reason to grow cynical and shut themselves away from the world’s trappings.

Still, there they were, standing by their mother when she was pushed hard to accept the PM’s chair. They urged her not to enter the fray out of pressure, but to decide for herself. Decide she did, leaving her children prouder than ever, beaming with happiness. Can any other political family, big or small, claim as much?

It is clear that the “lacerating sorrows” Sonia and her family suffered shaped the children’s worldview, but it would be unfair to dismiss the intrinsic values that guided them through it and let them emerge smiling. Without them, perhaps the ‘antithesis’ to the current dispensation, Nafrat ke bazaar mein mohabbat ki dukaan kholo (In the marketplace of Hatred, open the store of Love), would never have come about.

As a young girl, I could not see Rajiv as PM through an unbiased lens, given the impression I carried of his mother. The one thing I connected with instantly was that the day he was assassinated happened to be my birthday. But if Sonia stayed on despite her sister Nadia’s pleas to return to Italy, found solace on his side of the bed when in distress, and entered politics with the same urge that had pushed a reluctant Rajiv into it, the powerful force behind it all was her husband’s love. Through her eyes, I have come to respect him more than ever: a gentleman who loved his wife to the fullest.

As a book, it moves at an uneven pace. Her home country and her love story keep you going, and the Indira chapters are unputdownable. It lags a little when she describes her foreign tours after Rajiv becomes PM, a stretch that could have been shorter. Then comes her husband’s death and its aftermath, which are heart-rending, and the pace returns once she enters politics.

Some headlines I glanced at have pointed to factual slips, and where a date is wrong, it is wrong. But I did not read Belonging as a history of India. I read it as one woman’s account of what she lived through, and that account is hers to tell. Only hers. A hundred readers will write a hundred reviews, and each will say as much about the reader as about the book.

I have also come across headlines saying the book whitewashes history. I can only speak of what I read, and what stirred me in it. That does not mean I dismiss her version as baseless. Take for instance Rajiv’s stand on the Emergency: as she tells it, he, unlike Sanjay, advised his mother to resign. Those conversations took place in the family’s living room, and few besides Sonia could vouch for them. Whether we believe her account or not says less about the book than about why we picked it up in the first place.

When Sonia arrived in India for the first time, she was hosted by Harivansh Rai Bachchan and his family. “Uncle Bachchan,” as she calls him, told her: “You must know, Sonia beti, child, that in this country it is not what you are that counts, it is what people think you to be.” Prophetic! Now it is for her to let us know where she stands.

She, who would tell herself “Wait, Sonia, stay calm, don’t react” in Parliament while facing bilious attacks, has finally written to her heart’s content. I hope the book becomes an international bestseller, and that its success heals her and her family. If nothing else, its reception in just one week shows how hungry one part of India was to hear from her, and perhaps that she was accepted all along, which was her ultimate longing: to belong.

And finally, I hope the memoir does right by readers like me, to whom she owed this book.

Savita Hiremath
Savita Hiremath
Savita is a writer and former journalist from Bangalore. Her nonfiction and fiction explore memory, language and belonging. Long engaged with ecology and sustainability, she brings her composting practice and rural roots into her creative work. She is the author of 'Endlessly Green: Solid Waste Management for Everyone' (Simon & Schuster/Yoda Press). Her debut fiction is forthcoming.

Related articles

Who Gets to Name Terrorism? Power, Knowledge and the Politics of Violence

When national security becomes the primary lens through which political dissent is judged, what happens to due process and democratic citizenship? Reviewing Irfan Ahmad’s Terrorism in Question: Decolonizing Anthropology and the Study of Islam, this essay examines how states acquire the power to classify political action—tracing the thread from post-9/11 counterterrorism and the SIMI ban to the 2013 Muzaffarnagar violence and the ongoing bail battles of Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam

From Goethe to Kolkata Classrooms: Why Learning Arabic Matters for Self-Reliance and Leadership

At Kolkata’s charity-run Umeed Global School, where over 75 per cent of students come from underprivileged backgrounds, a November 14 Khutba competition became a powerful lesson in self-reliance. Addressing the students, Imarat-e-Shariah Ameer Ahmed Wali Faisal Rahmani and founder-secretary Wali Rahmani emphasised how understanding Arabic—a language admired by thinkers from Roger Bacon to Goethe—empowers young learners to engage with sacred texts firsthand, perform family rites independently, and emerge as confident leaders.

Newborn Denied Birth Certificate as TMC, CPI(M), Congress Unite Over Bengal Voter Roll Deletions

TMC, Left, and Congress united in Kolkata to call a November 21 convention over West Bengal’s SIR voter list deletions after a Cooch Behar newborn was allegedly denied a birth certificate and 37 lakh appeals remained pending.

Killed Over a Skullcap, Ignored by the System: What 405 Documented Hate Incidents Reveal About Impunity in India

A new APCR report documents 405 hate crimes and speeches across India in nine months—including 54 deaths, post-poll violence in West Bengal, and 37 per cent state actor involvement—exposing how public incitement and police inaction fuel targeted minority violence.